Males And Sharia Law: Breaking The Rules

Sharia law, or Islamic law, guides the personal religious practices of Muslims worldwide. It is a code for living that all Muslims should adhere to, including prayers, fasting, and donations to the poor. While it is a source of guidance for many Muslims, it has also been a source of controversy, especially regarding its teachings on criminal justice, democracy, and social equality.

Sharia law is derived from two main sources: the Quran, which is considered the word of God, and hadith—the sayings and practices of the Prophet Muhammad. The interpretation of Sharia law is called fiqh and is conducted by Islamic jurists. While Sharia law itself cannot be altered, its interpretation is given some flexibility.

In this context, how do males specifically break Sharia law? Men, like women, can break Sharia law in numerous ways, and the consequences can be severe. For example, criticising or denying any part of the Quran, Prophet Muhammad, or Allah is punishable by death. Additionally, men who beat their wives for insubordination or unilaterally divorce their wives are breaking Sharia law. Furthermore, in some countries where Sharia law holds sway, men can face restrictions on their dress and behaviour, such as in Saudi Arabia, where men are expected to adhere to modest dress codes and religious norms.

Criticising or denying the Quran

Sharia law is derived from two main sources: the Quran, considered the direct word of God, and the Hadith, which are the sayings and practices attributed to the Prophet Muhammad. Criticising or denying the Quran can be seen as blasphemy, which is a serious offence in the eyes of Sharia. However, the interpretation and enforcement of blasphemy laws vary widely across Muslim-majority countries.

In classical Sharia jurisprudence, blasphemy refers to any form of cursing, questioning, or annoying God, Muhammad, or anything considered sacred in Islam. This includes denying one of the Islamic prophets or scriptures and insulting an angel. The punishment for blasphemy could range from imprisonment or fines to the death penalty, depending on the specific circumstances and the legal school of thought.

In modern times, some states and radical groups have used blasphemy charges to burnish their religious credentials and gain political support. However, there is also a growing movement to abolish blasphemy laws, as they are seen as a violation of freedom of speech and are often used to persecute religious minorities and settle personal scores.

The interpretation of Sharia law is not uniform, and there are different schools of Islamic law that may vary in their approach to criticising or denying the Quran. The four main Sunni schools are Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, and Hanbali, and there is also the Shia school, Jaafari. These schools differ in how literally they interpret the texts and the specific punishments they prescribe.

Additionally, the application of Sharia law can vary depending on the local culture and customs. For example, the interpretation and enforcement of Sharia in Saudi Arabia may differ significantly from that in Indonesia or Malaysia. The role of religious scholars or muftis is crucial, as they issue fatwas (legal opinions) that guide the understanding and application of Sharia law.

In conclusion, criticising or denying the Quran is a complex issue in Sharia law, with a range of interpretations and consequences. The specific approach depends on the context, the authorities involved, and the school of Islamic law being followed. While blasphemy is generally considered a serious offence, there are varying degrees of punishment and an ongoing debate about the role of blasphemy laws in the modern world.

Criticising Muhammad or denying he is a prophet

Historically, Muhammad has been criticised by non-Muslim contemporaries, medieval Jewish writers, and Western and Byzantine Christian thinkers. In the Middle Ages, various Christian scholars considered Muhammad a false prophet or even the Antichrist. Modern criticism has questioned Muhammad's sincerity, morality, and psychological condition, as well as his treatment of enemies and his marriages.

In the Islamic world, criticising or denying Muhammad's prophethood is generally viewed as deeply offensive and may be considered blasphemous. Blasphemy, or insulting or defaming the Prophet Muhammad, is a serious offence in many Muslim-majority countries and can carry severe penalties, including imprisonment, flogging, or even the death penalty. The interpretation and enforcement of blasphemy laws vary across countries, and some countries have stricter laws than others.

In recent years, there have been several controversial incidents involving criticism of Muhammad, including the publication of cartoons depicting him in European newspapers and magazines, as well as online content and films deemed offensive to Muslims. These incidents have sparked protests and, in some cases, violent reactions from Muslims around the world who consider any depiction of Muhammad, let alone criticism or denial of his prophethood, as deeply disrespectful.

While not all Muslim-majority countries have specific blasphemy laws, criticism of Muhammad can still lead to social ostracism, harassment, or extrajudicial punishment. Self-censorship is also common, as individuals may fear reprisals for expressing controversial views. Additionally, some countries have laws against "insulting religion" or "hurting religious sentiments," which can be broadly applied to include criticism of Muhammad.

In summary, criticising or denying the prophethood of Muhammad is a violation of Sharia law and is considered deeply offensive in the Islamic world. While the specific penalties and social consequences vary depending on the country and cultural context, such acts of criticism or denial can have significant repercussions and may even be punishable by death in some cases.

Committing homosexual acts

Sharia law is Islam's legal system, derived from the Quran, the Sunnah, and the Hadith—the deeds and sayings of the Prophet Muhammad. It acts as a code for living that all Muslims should adhere to, and it aims to help Muslims understand how they should lead their lives according to God's wishes.

The interpretation of Islamic law is nuanced and can vary according to local culture and customs, which means that Sharia law may look quite different in different places. For example, while some Muslim-majority countries have laws that call for what critics deem cruel criminal punishments, or place undue restrictions on the lives of women and minority groups, other countries such as Israel, Turkey, Jordan, and Lebanon do not persecute gay people.

Homosexuality is considered a sin by all major schools of Islamic thought, and laws in most Muslim-majority countries discriminate against LGBTQ+ people. In the Quran and Hadith, there are several verses and sayings that refer to the ancient figure Lot and his people, condemning them for acts of sodomy. The Hadith, in particular, includes many passages that call for harsh punishments for homosexual activity, including stoning, lashing, and amputation.

In some countries, Sharia law is applied to criminal law, and homosexual acts between men can be punishable by death. For example, in Iran, in accordance with Sharia law, homosexual intercourse between men can result in the death penalty, and men can be flogged for lesser acts such as kissing. Similarly, in Saudi Arabia, under the country's interpretation of Sharia law, a married man engaging in sodomy or any non-Muslim who commits sodomy with a Muslim can be stoned to death.

In other countries that have adopted Sharia law, such as Nigeria, homosexual behavior is classified as a felony punishable by imprisonment, and some states have imposed the death penalty for men. In Yemen, according to the 1994 penal code, married men can be sentenced to death by stoning for homosexual intercourse, while unmarried men face whipping or a year in prison.

The Islamic State (IS) group has also been known to target gay men, conducting public executions as part of a deliberate moral policing campaign. IS has produced a vast corpus of justifications for killing homosexuals, and they have singled out these victims as part of their program to root out "deviancy." The main method used by IS to kill these men has been to throw them off the roofs of high-rise buildings, based on a Hadith in which the Prophet's successor, Abu Bakr, prescribes throwing a man off a cliff for engaging in homosexual acts.

Failing to pray or fast

Sharia law guides the personal religious practices of Muslims worldwide, with about half of the world's Muslim-majority countries having Sharia-based laws. Most Muslims follow aspects of Sharia in their private religious practices.

Prayer is a fundamental aspect of Sharia law, with Muslims expected to pray five times a day: at dawn, noon, mid-afternoon, sunset, and night. These prayers are known as Fajr, Dhuhr, Asr, Maghrib, and Isha, respectively. Failing to perform these prayers without a valid reason, such as illness or travel, is considered a breach of Sharia law.

Fasting during the month of Ramadan is another crucial tenet of Sharia law. Muslims are expected to abstain from food, drink, and other pleasures from sunrise to sunset for the entire month. This practice is intended to bring Muslims closer to Allah and teach them self-discipline, sacrifice, and empathy for those less fortunate. Failing to fast during Ramadan without a valid reason is considered a serious breach of Sharia law.

The consequences of failing to pray or fast can vary depending on the interpretation and application of Sharia law in a particular region or community. In some cases, failing to pray or fast may result in social ostracism, reprimand by religious authorities, or even legal punishment in countries where Sharia law is incorporated into the criminal justice system. However, it is important to note that the interpretation and enforcement of Sharia law can vary widely, and not all Muslims interpret failing to pray or fast as a severe breach of the law.

Drinking alcohol or using drugs

Sharia law is Islam's legal system, derived from the Quran, Islam's holy book, as well as the Sunnah and Hadith—the deeds and sayings of the Prophet Muhammad. It acts as a code for living that all Muslims should adhere to, encompassing everything from prayers and fasting to family law, finance, and business.

The consumption of alcohol is not explicitly banned in the Quran, but several verses address the issue, and the Quran's stance on alcohol became increasingly clear over time. The first verse on the topic forbade Muslims from attending prayers while intoxicated. A later verse acknowledged that alcohol contains some good and some evil, but "the evil is greater than the good". The final verse on the topic took an unequivocal tone, calling "intoxicants and games of chance" the "abominations of Satan's handiwork" and ordering Muslims to abstain.

Muslims interpret these verses to forbid any intoxicating substance, including wine, beer, gin, and whiskey. Over the years, the understanding of intoxicating substances has expanded to include modern street drugs.

The punishment for drinking alcohol is not prescribed in the Quran, but the Hadith mentions that the Prophet Muhammad prescribed 40 lashes "administered with two palm branches... for someone accused of consuming alcohol". Islamic scholars generally agree that the punishment for consuming alcohol is flogging, but the number of lashes varies according to different schools of Islamic law.

Drug use is also considered haram, or forbidden, in Islam. Drugs are believed to dull the senses, befog the mind, and cause extensive harm. The Prophet Muhammad is quoted as saying, "Every intoxicant is khamr, and every intoxicant is haram [forbidden]. Whoever drinks khamr in this world and dies persisting in that and without having repented, will not drink it in the Hereafter."

Islamic law does not explicitly regulate drug crimes, but they are considered to fall under the category of jarîmah ta'zîr, where the legal sanctions are left to the authorities' policy. Drug dealers and traffickers may be given severe punishments, including the death penalty, due to the adverse effects of their crimes on individuals and society.

Frequently asked questions