The Journey Of Provincial Bills: Laws In The Making

The process of a provincial bill becoming a law involves several steps and stages. In Canada, a bill must first be introduced in either the Senate or the House of Commons, followed by a first, second, and third reading. During the second reading, members of all parties can speak and suggest alternatives, and amendments may be made at the third reading stage. After passing the third reading, the bill receives Royal Assent, which is the formal approval by the monarch's representative, the Lieutenant Governor. Once the bill is given Royal Assent, it becomes an Act and is assigned a statute number.

First reading

The first reading of a provincial bill is the first stage of the legislative process. It is during this stage that the bill is introduced and given its first reading in the legislature. The member sponsoring the bill, usually a cabinet minister, will state its title and summarise its purpose. The bill is not read in full, nor are there any comments made about its contents or any debate at this stage. The bill is then printed and distributed to the members of the House. Once the bill has been printed, the word "PRINTED" is marked on the Order Paper beside it, and it is ready for further consideration.

During the first reading, a number is also assigned to the bill. In the case of Canadian federal bills, if they are introduced first in the Senate, they are numbered starting with an "S". Government-sponsored bills are numbered from C-1 to C-200 in the order they are presented.

After the first reading, the bill moves to the second reading stage. Here, the member who introduced the bill explains its purpose and content, and members of the House can participate in a debate on the principle of the bill.

The first reading is a crucial step in the legislative process as it formally introduces the bill and sets the stage for further discussion and debate. It is also the first opportunity for members of the legislature to hear about the bill and its proposed purpose.

In preparation for the first reading, the government caucus discusses the idea, and members of the legislative assembly (MLAs) talk with interested citizens and groups to gauge their reaction to the proposed bill. This step ensures that the bill takes into account the perspectives of those who may be affected by it.

Second reading

The second reading of a provincial bill is a crucial stage in the legislative process, where the bill is presented and debated in detail. Here is a step-by-step overview of the second reading:

• Introduction and Explanation: The member who introduced the bill during the first reading will now move for the second reading. They will explain the purpose and content of the bill, providing a detailed outline to the assembly.
• Debate and Discussion: This stage involves a thorough debate on the principle of the bill. Members of all parties can participate in this discussion, speaking only once. They may suggest alternatives, ask questions, or propose amendments to various sections of the bill. The sponsoring member may also engage in this debate, answering inquiries and addressing objections raised.
• Committee Referral: If the bill passes the second reading and receives approval in principle, it is then referred to a committee for further scrutiny. The specific committee depends on the type of bill—public bills go to the Law Amendments Committee, while private or local bills are directed to the Private and Local Bills Committee.
• Public Input: Both committees allow interested individuals or groups to provide input. The committees hear representations from any person wishing to contribute, and the time and location for these hearings are determined by the committee chair.
• Clause-by-Clause Consideration: The committees consider the bill in detail, going through each clause. Amendments, deletions, or specific changes may be recommended by the committees.
• Reporting Back to the House: After the committee stage, the bill is reported back to the House, along with any recommendations for changes. The bill is then placed on the Order Paper for its third reading.

The second reading is a critical stage in the legislative process, as it involves an in-depth examination of the bill and provides an opportunity for members to engage in a detailed discussion before the bill proceeds further.

Committee stage

Once a bill has been called for its second reading and passes this stage, it is then referred to a Committee. The type of committee depends on the type of bill. For example, in Nova Scotia, public bills are referred to the Law Amendments Committee, while private or local bills are referred to the Private and Local Bills Committee. The purpose of the committee stage is to comment on, ask questions about, and/or propose amendments to various sections of the bill.

The committee may invite individuals, groups, and ministry officials to comment on the bill in writing or in person before the committee. The committee may also travel to various locations in the province to receive comments. Each clause of the bill is then considered and may be amended or deleted. If amendments are made, the bill is reprinted.

In the committee stage, the bill is considered clause by clause. The bill is then returned to the House from these committees either with or without recommendations for specific changes. After the bill has been reported to the House, it is then considered by the Committee of the Whole House on Bills and debated in detail.

The Committee of the Whole House on Bills has a set time limit for debate, for example, 20 hours in Nova Scotia. Members may speak more than once during this debate, and the amendments made in the committees can be either approved or rejected at this time. Once the debate is finished, the committee refers the bill to the Assembly.

Third reading

The third reading of a bill is the final stage of the legislative process. This is when the sponsor of the bill summarises its benefits, and the opposition parties state their agreement or disagreement with the bill. A final vote is taken once the debate is finished. If the bill passes the third reading, it is then ready to receive Royal Assent.

The third reading of a bill is often a quick approval, but it may be debated and amended at this stage if proper notice has been given in advance to the Clerk of the House. The bill is then engrossed, which means it is put into its final form by adding any amendments that have been made.

After the third reading and engrossment, the bill is presented to the Lieutenant Governor for Royal Assent. The Lieutenant Governor may assent to the bill in the Queen's name, withhold assent, or reserve assent. When the bill is given Royal Assent, it becomes an Act and is given a statute number.

The Act takes effect on the date it is assented to, unless otherwise provided. It may also take effect on a specified date or a date fixed by proclamation by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. Different sections of the Act may come into force at different times.

Royal Assent

In Canada, a bill must go through several steps before it becomes a law. After the first, second, and third readings, the final stage is receiving Royal Assent. This is the formal approval by the monarch's representative, the Lieutenant Governor, and it is required for a bill to become law. The Lieutenant Governor may assent to the Bill in the Queen's name, withhold assent, or reserve assent. When a bill is given Royal Assent, it becomes an Act and is given a statute number.

The process of Royal Assent is a longstanding tradition in parliamentary democracies with historical connections to the British monarchy. The Lieutenant Governor, as the monarch's representative, plays a crucial role in this process. Once a bill has passed through the legislative process and received Royal Assent, it officially becomes a law, or an Act, and is given a statute number.

While the power of Royal Assent rests with the Lieutenant Governor, it is important to note that this power is rarely used independently. The Lieutenant Governor typically acts on the advice of the government and the legislature, ensuring that the bills passed are in line with the will of the people and the democratic process.

In summary, Royal Assent is a critical step in the legislative process in Canada. It requires the formal approval of the Lieutenant Governor, who represents the monarch, and it marks the transformation of a bill into an Act or law. This step ensures that the legislative process is thorough and that the bills passed will serve the best interests of the citizens.

Frequently asked questions