Etsy's Copyright Conundrum: Breaking Law, Evading Consequences?

Etsy, the online e-commerce website focusing on handmade goods, crafts, and vintage items, has been criticised for the copyright infringement found in its marketplace shops. The platform has over 5 million sellers, mostly individuals or small businesses without legal counsel, who may be unaware of copyright laws or neglect to do their due diligence when purchasing wholesale goods from countries that don't enforce copyright laws, such as China. This has resulted in many Etsy stores containing items that are likely cases of copyright infringement, with artists claiming that Etsy sellers are ripping off their designs. While Etsy has become more aggressive in dealing with unscrupulous sellers, the problem is far from resolved.

Etsy's Intellectual Property Policy states that it takes intellectual property rights very seriously and complies with laws and industry best practices to maintain the integrity of its creative marketplace. The policy outlines how Etsy addresses allegations of infringement, how authorised parties can submit reports, and how sellers can respond when their listings or shops are affected. Etsy reserves the right to disable any listing, shop, or account that violates its Terms of Use, including its Intellectual Property Policy.

However, it's important to note that Etsy does not automatically report or act on copyright infringement itself. Copyright infringement must be reported by the copyright owner via Etsy's dedicated reporting system. If a copyright owner discovers that their creative material has been used without permission, they can file a complaint, and Etsy may remove the infringing items, suspend the seller's account, or take other necessary actions. Additionally, content creators may choose to pursue legal action against the seller for infringing on their ownership rights.

Etsy's role and responsibilities

Etsy takes intellectual property rights seriously and strives to combat violations. It provides tools for reporting copyright infringement, in accordance with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), and takes action against infringing sellers. This includes disabling listings, shops, or accounts that violate its Terms of Use, which includes the Intellectual Property Policy and Prohibited Items Policy. Etsy also reserves the right to take action against abusers of its Intellectual Property Policy.

When Etsy receives a report of intellectual property infringement, it responds by removing or disabling access to the allegedly infringing material. Etsy makes a reasonable attempt to contact the affected member, provide information about the report and removal, and, in cases of alleged copyright infringement, offer information on submitting a counter notice. The company may also provide a copy of the infringement report to the affected member.

Etsy's Intellectual Property Policy outlines procedures for reporting intellectual property infringement, submitting counter notices, and addressing repeat infringement. It is important to note that Etsy cannot offer legal advice or make legal determinations regarding intellectual property disputes. The company's role is to facilitate the reporting process, remove infringing content when provided with a valid report, and take action as outlined in its policies.

To summarise, Etsy's role and responsibilities primarily involve providing a platform for sellers, enforcing its policies, and facilitating the reporting and removal of infringing content. The company takes intellectual property rights seriously and strives to maintain a fair and creative marketplace for all users.

Copyright law and intellectual property rights

Copyright law is a form of intellectual property law that protects original works of authorship. Copyright law covers both published and unpublished works, including literary, dramatic, musical, and artistic works, such as poetry, novels, movies, songs, computer software, and architecture.

Copyright law grants the owner of the copyright the exclusive right to reproduce, distribute, and display their work to others. It also allows the owner to authorise others to exercise these rights, subject to certain limitations. The length of copyright protection depends on when the work was created. Under current law, works created on or after January 1, 1978, are generally protected for the life of the author plus seventy years after their death.

Intellectual property rights are an important consideration for Etsy sellers. Etsy provides guidelines and tools for reporting copyright infringement, in accordance with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. Etsy takes allegations of infringement seriously and will remove or disable access to infringing material. It also reserves the right to disable any listings, shops, or accounts that violate its Terms of Use, including its Intellectual Property Policy.

To avoid copyright infringement on Etsy, sellers should familiarise themselves with intellectual property laws and create original designs. They can also use licensed or public domain content, ensuring they understand the terms and source's credibility. If using copyrighted material, sellers must obtain the necessary licenses and permissions from the owner.

Artists' recourse against infringements

Etsy is a platform that connects millions of active sellers to buyers. It takes intellectual property rights very seriously and strives to combat violations of copyright and other intellectual property rights. It provides tools for reporting copyright infringement in accordance with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and takes appropriate action against infringing sellers.

If an artist finds their work on Etsy without their permission, they can make a takedown request, and Etsy is required to remove the infringing work from its site. Etsy will then review the complaint and may remove the infringing items from the platform, suspend the seller's account, or take other actions as necessary to resolve the intellectual property issue. Artists can also choose to pursue legal action against the seller for infringing on their ownership rights.

To submit a report of alleged infringement against Etsy shop listings, artists can use the Etsy Reporting Portal. They will need to provide information about themselves, their address, and contact information, as well as details about the intellectual property in question, such as the name or title of the copyrighted work, the type of work, and examples of the work.

It is important to note that copyright infringement can result in legal action and penalties on the platform, including removing store listings and account suspension.

Additionally, artists can take proactive measures to protect their work by registering their artwork with the Copyright Office. This provides several benefits, including the ability to invoke statutory damages, which range from a minimum of $750 to a maximum of $30,000 per infringement, and having reasonable legal fees paid by the infringer if they win the case.

Artists can also use online monitoring services like ImageRights to track their images on Etsy and across the web, allowing them to be notified when someone uploads their work without permission and issue a takedown notice promptly.

While it may be difficult to sue an Etsy seller due to low sales volume and the challenge of recovering profits, registering artwork and taking advantage of online monitoring services can help artists protect their work and take action against infringements.

Takedown procedures and counterclaims

Etsy's Intellectual Property Policy outlines the process for addressing allegations of infringement, submitting reports of infringement, and responding to reports of infringement. The policy also covers counter notices, which are relevant in the context of takedown procedures.

Takedown Procedures

If Etsy receives a report of intellectual property infringement that complies with its policies, it will typically respond by removing or disabling access to the allegedly infringing material. Etsy will then attempt to contact the affected member to provide information about the report, the removal, and the process for submitting a counter notice. Etsy may also provide a copy of the infringement report, including the name and contact details of the reporting party, to the affected member.

Counter Notices

If a member believes that their content was removed or disabled due to a mistake or misidentification, they can submit a counter notice to Etsy's designated agent. This can be done by clicking the unique URL provided in the email notifying the member of the copyright infringement notice and takedown. The counter notice must include specific information, such as the member's name, address, contact information, and a statement made under penalty of perjury that the content was removed or disabled due to a mistake or misidentification.

Once Etsy confirms that the counter notice includes all the required information, it will notify both the member submitting the counter notice and the original reporting party. The reporting party may use this information to obtain a court order to prevent the reinstatement of the content. If, within 10 business days, the reporting party does not inform Etsy of an action seeking a court order, the content specified in the counter notice may be reinstated. Reactivating the content before this time may result in account termination.

It is important to note that misrepresenting the information in a counter notice can have legal consequences, including liability for damages and attorneys' fees. Therefore, it is advisable to consult an attorney before submitting a counter notice.

Artists' experiences with copyright infringement on Etsy

Artists have also expressed concerns about the ease with which banned members can reopen stores under different names, allowing them to continue selling infringing items. This makes it challenging to permanently remove copyright infringers from the platform.

On the other hand, some artists have shared positive experiences with Etsy's handling of copyright infringement. Etsy complies with takedown requests and sometimes even removes stores with multiple infringing items. The platform has also become more aggressive in dealing with unscrupulous sellers.

Artists who have had their work infringed upon can take several steps to protect their intellectual property rights. These include registering their artwork with the Copyright Office, which provides benefits such as statutory damages and the possibility of having legal fees paid by the infringer. Additionally, artists can use online monitoring services to track their images on Etsy and across the web, allowing them to be notified when their work is used without permission.

To avoid copyright infringement accusations themselves, artists should create original content, use licensed or public domain content, or obtain permission from the intellectual property owner. Staying informed about intellectual property laws and any changes is also crucial.

Frequently asked questions