Texas Abortion Law: A Controversial And Divisive Issue

The Texas abortion law, also known as S.B. 8, prohibits abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy or when a fetal heartbeat is detected. The law does not make an exception for rape, incest, or severe fetal abnormalities, and it is enforced by citizen bounty hunters who can sue anyone they suspect of aiding or abetting an abortion. The law has sparked heated debates and legal challenges, with some Texans believing that it is too extreme. The law has also led to an increase in live births in the state, with researchers estimating that there were 9,799 additional live births in Texas between April and December 2022 due to the abortion ban. The Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade in 2022 allowed states to set their own abortion laws, and Texas is one of 13 states that have since ceased nearly all abortion services.

The Texas Heartbeat Bill

The bill has also been criticised for its potential impact on healthcare professionals, who may be reluctant to perform abortions even in cases of medical emergency due to the risk of litigation. The law's vague language and broad framing have created uncertainty and apprehension among doctors, who fear being sued or facing criminal charges.

While the popularity of the Texas Heartbeat Bill is difficult to measure directly, public opinion polls suggest that many Americans, including Texans, inhabit an ambiguous middle ground when it comes to abortion. While some support certain abortion restrictions, they may not favour a complete ban, especially in cases of rape, incest, or danger to the mother's health. The extreme nature of the Texas Heartbeat Bill may have pushed some moderate Texans towards more pro-abortion-rights positions, potentially impacting future elections in the state.

Public opinion on the law

The Texas abortion law, known as S.B. 8, prohibits abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy, or when embryonic cardiac activity is first detected, and before many people know they are pregnant. There is no exception for rape, incest, or severe fetal abnormalities. The law is enforced by citizen bounty hunters, who can sue anyone they suspect of having "aided or abetted" an abortion.

However, others support the law. Kristan Hawkins, the president of Students for Life of America, applauded Texas for its "novel" and "innovative" approach to curbing abortion rights. She does not believe that rape is a legitimate reason to seek an abortion, stating that "the circumstances of your conception do not change your value and the dignity that you as a human being possess".

The number of abortions in the country has declined in recent years, but restrictions on access to the procedure are not thought to be the main cause. Instead, the reason is likely a combination of decreased sexual activity and access to long-acting, reversible birth control, such as IUDs and implants.

The Texas abortion law has sparked a debate about the role of government in deciding what happens if a woman gets pregnant and doesn't want to have a baby. While some Texans support the law, others believe that it is too extreme and infringes on their rights and privacy.

The law's impact on birth rates

The Texas abortion law, known as S.B. 8, prohibits abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy or when embryonic cardiac activity is first detected. This has resulted in a notable impact on birth rates in the state.

Researchers from Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health estimate that the Texas abortion ban was associated with 9,799 additional live births in the state between April and December 2022. This suggests that many pregnant individuals in Texas were unable to overcome the barriers to accessing abortion services and were forced to continue unwanted or unsafe pregnancies. The study's authors note that the results cannot be generalized, as the analysis was restricted to one state. However, the findings highlight how abortion bans have real implications for birthing people and their families.

The impact of the Texas abortion law on birth rates is further evident when examining the state's maternal mortality rate. According to an analysis by the Gender Equity Policy Institute, Texas's maternal death rate surged by 56% from 2019 to 2022, while the national average increase was 11%. Nancy L. Cohen, the institute's president, attributes this staggering difference primarily to Texas's abortion ban. The ban has been linked to at least one death, as Yeniifer Alvarez-Estrada Glick, a 27-year-old woman, died of complications from her pregnancy in 2022. Experts believe she likely would have survived if she had been offered and accepted an abortion.

The Texas abortion law has also had potential long-term impacts on women and families. Findings from the UCSF Turnaway Study indicate that women denied an abortion are more likely to experience economic hardship, have worse health outcomes, and are more likely to stay in contact with violent partners. Their children are also more likely to experience slower development and live in poverty.

In summary, the Texas abortion law has significantly impacted birth rates in the state, leading to thousands of additional live births and contributing to a surge in the maternal mortality rate. The law has also had potential long-term consequences for women, children, and families, exacerbating financial struggles and negatively affecting health and well-being.

The law's impact on maternal mortality

The Texas abortion law, known as Senate Bill 8 (S.B. 8), prohibits abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy or when embryonic cardiac activity is detected. This is often before many people know they are pregnant. The law has sparked controversy, with some Texans who wouldn't have an abortion themselves believing the law is too extreme.

• Texas' maternal mortality rate increased by 56% from 2019 to 2022, according to an analysis by the Gender Equity Policy Institute. The institute's president, Nancy L. Cohen, attributed this surge primarily to the state's abortion ban.
• Dr. David Eisenberg, an obstetrician-gynecologist, estimates that the law could lead to increases in maternal mortality of up to 15% overall and up to 33% for Black women. This is based on research linking abortion restrictions to higher maternal mortality rates, with Black women disproportionately impacted.
• Summer Sherburne Hawkins, an associate professor at Boston College's School of Social Work, affirms that restricting abortion based on gestational age, as Texas has done, will likely have detrimental effects on maternal health and increase maternal mortality.
• The law's extreme limit on abortions may cause many abortion clinics to close, further reducing access to care for Texas residents.
• The law's impact could be particularly harmful to those with limited resources or facing challenging circumstances, such as addiction or homelessness, who may not be able to travel out of state for an abortion.
• The law may result in more complicated pregnancies and negatively impact the physical and mental health of those carrying unwanted pregnancies to term.
• The U.S. already faces a crisis of maternal mortality, with the highest rate among developed nations, and Texas contributes significantly to this issue, with a maternal mortality rate higher than the national average.
• The maternal mortality rate in Texas is especially stark for Black women, who account for 31% of maternal deaths in the state, despite only representing 11% of live births.
• The law's restriction on abortions, combined with inadequate insurance coverage and limited access to healthcare for low-income Texans, exacerbates the challenges of addressing maternal mortality.

The law's exceptions

The Texas abortion law, known as S.B. 8, prohibits abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy or when embryonic cardiac activity is first detected. While the law does not make any exception for pregnancies resulting from rape or incest, there are certain circumstances under which abortions are allowed.

Chapter 170A.002 of the Texas Health & Safety Code prohibits abortions outright, except in specific situations. The law provides an exception for situations in which the life or health of the pregnant patient is at risk. To qualify for this exception, three factors must be met:

• A licensed physician must perform the abortion.
• The patient must have a life-threatening condition and be at risk of death or "substantial impairment of a major bodily function" if the abortion is not performed.
• The physician must try to save the life of the fetus unless doing so would increase the risk of the pregnant patient's death or impairment.

It is important to note that the term "substantial impairment of a major bodily function" is not defined in Chapter 170A. Additionally, there are additional situations where the exception for the life or health of the patient does not apply, which are outlined in Section 170A.002.

In August 2023, Texas Governor Greg Abbott signed HB 3058 into law, which allows doctors to provide abortions in cases of ectopic pregnancies or if a pregnant patient's water breaks too early, rendering the fetus unviable.

Frequently asked questions