Restrictive Abortion Laws: A Costly Burden For Women

The cost of having an abortion varies depending on the trimester and the method used. In 2021, the median costs for people paying out of pocket in the first trimester were $568 for a medication abortion and $625 for a procedural abortion. In Florida, an abortion can cost between $600 to $800 during the first trimester. However, restrictive abortion laws can make it harder for people to access abortion services, leading to increased costs. For example, people may need to travel to another state or country to receive an abortion, incurring travel and accommodation expenses. Additionally, restrictive abortion laws can result in a lack of trained providers and increased stigma, further driving up the cost of abortion services. Restrictive abortion laws can also lead to unsafe abortions, which can have serious health complications and even result in death. Therefore, while the direct cost of an abortion may vary, the indirect costs of restrictive abortion laws can be significant and may pose a financial burden on individuals seeking abortion services.

The financial burden of restrictive abortion laws on women and girls

Restrictive abortion laws can impose significant financial burdens on women and girls, affecting their economic stability and well-being. These financial constraints are particularly acute for low-income individuals and communities of colour. Here's how:

Increased healthcare costs

When individuals are denied access to safe and legal abortions, they often resort to unsafe methods, which can lead to severe medical complications requiring costly treatments. The financial burden of treating these complications falls on individuals, hospitals, and taxpayers. In the United States, the cost of treating sepsis, a potential complication of unsafe abortions, can be as high as $51,000 per case. In 2019, the cost of caring for patients with post-abortion complications ranged from $189,000 to $134 million.

Loss of income

Restrictive abortion laws often require individuals to travel long distances to access legal abortion services, resulting in loss of income due to missed work. Additionally, mandatory counselling and waiting periods further contribute to financial costs and loss of income. This is especially detrimental to low-wage workers, who may struggle to take time off work and bear the financial burden of travel.

Impact on education and employment

Abortion restrictions can limit women's access to education and employment opportunities. When individuals are denied abortions, they are more likely to experience economic hardship and financial insecurity. Research has shown that being denied an abortion can lead to increased rates of unpaid debt, poverty, evictions, and bankruptcies. Restricted access to abortion also affects children's educational outcomes and their earnings in the labour market later in life.

Limited access to contraception

Restrictive abortion laws often go hand in hand with limited access to modern contraception, which can lead to unintended pregnancies. This creates a cycle where individuals, particularly those from low-income communities, struggle to access safe abortions and are burdened by the financial consequences of unintended pregnancies.

Impact on maternal and child health

Unsafe abortions can result in physical and mental health complications for women, with long-term impacts on their health and well-being. Additionally, children born to parents who were denied abortions are more likely to grow up in financially insecure households, which can affect their health and development.

The impact of restrictive abortion laws on maternal mortality

Restrictive abortion laws have a detrimental impact on maternal mortality, disproportionately affecting low-income people of colour, immigrants, and non-English speakers. These laws create geographic, transportation, and financial barriers to obtaining abortions, leading to increased rates of maternal death and adverse outcomes.

The impact on maternal mortality

Abortion restrictions can lead to unsafe abortions, which are a significant cause of maternal mortality. In countries with the most restrictive abortion laws, abortion-related maternal deaths are higher. Restrictive laws limit access to safe and legal abortions, resulting in women resorting to unsafe methods performed by untrained individuals in unsafe settings. This can lead to physical and mental health complications and even death.

Disproportionate impact on vulnerable communities

Restrictive abortion laws disproportionately impact low-income people of colour, who already face higher rates of maternal mortality and morbidity. These laws create financial barriers and limit access to reproductive health care for vulnerable communities. For example, Black people in the United States are more than twice as likely to experience maternal mortality and severe maternal morbidity compared to White people.

The role of abortion education and training

Abortion education and training for medical students and residents are essential to providing quality abortion care. However, restrictive abortion laws limit these educational opportunities, further exacerbating racial inequities in maternal health. The lack of training can result in a decrease in the quality of care and the number of physicians providing abortion services, particularly in abortion-hostile states.

Addressing the impact

To mitigate the impact of restrictive abortion laws on maternal mortality, it is crucial to advocate for federal legislation that codifies broad abortion care access and expands abortion training across medical education. Increasing access to safe and legal abortions can help reduce maternal mortality rates, especially among vulnerable communities.

The role of restrictive abortion laws in perpetuating racial inequities

Restrictive abortion laws have been shown to have a disproportionate impact on Black individuals and those with lower socioeconomic statuses (SES), contributing to existing racial and socioeconomic inequities in the United States. These laws limit reproductive autonomy and have important implications for the health and well-being of individuals and their children.

Impact on Black individuals and those with lower SES

Black individuals and those with lower SES are more likely to be affected by restrictive abortion laws due to decreased access to health care, provider availability, insurance coverage restrictions, residential segregation, and economic disadvantages. As a result, they may face greater barriers to accessing safe and legal abortions, leading to adverse birth outcomes and increased risks of unintended pregnancies.

Adverse birth outcomes and increased risks

Restrictive abortion laws have been associated with increased rates of infant and maternal mortality, low birth weight, and child fatality and homicide deaths. Black individuals, in particular, experience higher probabilities of preterm birth and low birth weight compared to non-Black individuals as restrictive abortion policies increase. Those with lower educational attainment also face higher probabilities of low birth weight.

Policy implications

The compounding effects of restrictive abortion laws on existing racial and socioeconomic inequities highlight the need for policy interventions. Policymakers should prioritize enacting structural interventions that address these disparities and protect the health and rights of marginalized communities. This includes expanding postpartum Medicaid coverage, Medicaid coverage of doula services, and implementing community-informed models of perinatal and reproductive health care.

The effect of restrictive abortion laws on access to healthcare

Restrictive abortion laws have a detrimental effect on access to healthcare. The World Health Organization (WHO) considers abortion a common and very safe health intervention when carried out using a recommended method by someone with the necessary skills. However, restrictive abortion laws create barriers to accessing safe and timely abortions, leading to negative health outcomes and increased costs for individuals and health systems.

Impact on Maternal Health

Restrictive abortion laws are associated with increased maternal mortality and morbidity. Studies have found that maternal mortality rates are lower in countries with more flexible abortion access laws. Restricting access to abortion does not reduce the number of abortions but instead leads to an increase in unsafe abortions, often performed by untrained practitioners or involving harmful methods. In the United States, the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision, which established the federal constitutional right to abortion, reduced maternal mortality rates by 30-40% for people of colour. The overturning of Roe v. Wade in 2022 is expected to have a disproportionate impact on Black birthing people, who already experience significantly higher rates of maternal mortality and morbidity compared to White birthing people.

Impact on Abortion Training and Provider Availability

Restrictive abortion laws also affect the availability of abortion training for medical professionals and the number of abortion providers. Medical students and residents may have limited access to abortion education and training, particularly in states with restrictive abortion laws. This can result in a decrease in the number of physicians in these states and a lack of diversity among abortion providers. Additionally, restrictive abortion laws have been associated with a decline in the number of abortion providers and the creation of "abortion deserts," where individuals must travel long distances to access abortion services.

Impact on Access to Other Healthcare Services

Restrictive abortion laws can also impact access to other healthcare services. For example, the closure of abortion clinics may negatively affect the delivery of reproductive healthcare services such as preventative breast exams, mammograms, and pap smears. Additionally, restrictive abortion laws can make it difficult for individuals to access necessary medications for conditions such as ectopic pregnancies, miscarriage, and chronic diseases, as some pharmacists have refused to fill prescriptions associated with abortion.

The consequences of restrictive abortion laws on mental health

Restrictive abortion laws can have detrimental consequences for mental health. Research has shown that people who are denied abortions experience more anxiety, lower life satisfaction, and lower self-esteem compared to those who can obtain them. The inability to obtain an abortion also increases the risk of domestic abuse among those forced to stay in contact with violent partners, putting both them and their children at risk.

The Turnaway Study, a landmark analysis of abortion, found that women who had an abortion did not report more negative emotions or suicidal thoughts than women who were denied one. Over 97% of those studied said that having the abortion was the right decision. The study also showed that the most commonly felt emotion post-abortion was relief.

Large longitudinal and international studies have found that obtaining a wanted abortion does not increase the risk of depression, anxiety, or suicidal thoughts. In fact, the best predictor of a woman's mental health after an abortion is her mental health before the abortion.

However, for women who are denied abortions, the consequences can be severe. They may experience more physical and mental health problems, economic hardships, and a higher chance of living in poverty. They are also more likely to stay linked to violent partners or to raise children alone. The children born as a result of abortion denial are more likely to live in poverty and experience poor bonding with their mothers.

Restrictive abortion laws can also have a wider impact on society. They may lead to increased stigma and barriers to accessing abortion services, which can cause psychological distress. The costs of obtaining an abortion may also increase, disproportionately affecting those with fewer economic resources. Overall, restrictive abortion laws can perpetuate continued inequities for marginalized communities.

Frequently asked questions