Abortion Law: Political Divide Or United Front?

Abortion laws in the US have been a highly contested issue between the Democratic and Republican parties. The Democratic Party platform supports access to safe and legal abortion and considers abortion as healthcare. On the other hand, the Republican Party platform states that the unborn child has a fundamental right to life which cannot be infringed and aims to oppose late-term abortions. While public opinion on abortion has fluctuated, it currently stands at 63% in favour of legal abortion and 36% against it. This divide between the two parties has led to significant political and social consequences, with the Democratic Party seeking to restore abortion rights and the Republican Party pushing for stricter abortion restrictions, including a national abortion ban.

Republican Party platform on abortion

The Republican Party platform on abortion has been a topic of much discussion and debate in recent years, with some shifts in the party's stance ahead of the 2024 election. The official Republican Party platform states that "the unborn child has a fundamental right to life which cannot be infringed." This position reflects the party's longstanding principle that the Constitution extends rights to fetuses and opposes abortion.

However, in 2024, the Republican National Committee (RNC) adopted a scaled-down platform that omitted the explicit call for a national abortion ban, instead ceding the issue to the states. This change was influenced by former President Donald Trump, who sought to steer clear of strict abortion language during his campaign while taking credit for the reversal of Roe v. Wade in 2022. The new platform reflects a desire by the Trump campaign to avoid providing additional material for Democratic warnings about his intentions if he were to regain the White House.

Despite this shift at the national level, there are varying opinions within the Republican Party regarding abortion. Some Republican candidates in swing states or tough House districts have pivoted on abortion, with some even describing themselves as "pro-choice." These candidates are attempting to neutralize the Democrats' most potent attack and shift the focus to other galvanizing issues. Additionally, some Republicans are trying to walk back or abandon their previous anti-abortion rights views, recognizing the political cost of holding strict anti-abortion positions.

While the national party's messaging on abortion has been inconsistent, some Republican leaders have worked behind the scenes to sell a more moderate message on the issue. For example, the House GOP campaign chief, Rep. Richard Hudson, has advised Republican candidates to clearly articulate their views to counter potential Democratic attacks.

The Republican Party's stance on abortion also varies depending on religious affiliation. Republicans who favor legal abortion are far less religious than abortion opponents within the party. Additionally, Republicans who oppose legal abortion are more likely to be Protestants, including White evangelical Protestants, and highly religious.

In summary, while the official Republican Party platform opposes abortion and recognizes the rights of fetuses, there are nuances and differing opinions within the party. Some Republicans are adopting more moderate positions, particularly in competitive electoral districts, while others remain firmly opposed to abortion and seek to influence policy at the state level following the reversal of Roe v. Wade.

Democratic Party platform on abortion

The Democratic Party platform supports access to "safe and legal abortion". They believe that every woman should be able to access high-quality reproductive health care services, including safe and legal abortion. They also want to repeal the Title X domestic gag rule and restore federal funding for Planned Parenthood, which provides vital preventive and reproductive health care for millions of people, especially those from low-income backgrounds, people of colour, and the LGBTQ+ community.

The Democrats oppose and aim to overturn federal and state laws that create barriers to reproductive health and rights. They want to repeal the Hyde Amendment and protect and codify the right to reproductive freedom. They also condemn acts of violence, harassment, and intimidation of reproductive health providers, patients, and staff. They recognise that quality, affordable comprehensive health care, medically accurate and LGBTQ+-inclusive sex education, and the full range of family planning services are all essential to ensuring that people can decide if, when, and how to start a family.

The Democrats are proud to be the party of the Affordable Care Act, which prohibits discrimination in healthcare on the basis of sex and requires insurers to cover prescription contraceptives at no cost. They believe that health care is a right for all, not a privilege for the few. They are committed to achieving universal, affordable, quality health care and will continue to fight until all Americans can access secure and affordable health insurance.

The Democrats also want to eliminate racial, gender, and geographic health inequities. They plan to launch a sustained, government-wide effort to eliminate racial, ethnic, gender, and geographic gaps in insurance rates, access to quality care, and health outcomes. This includes tackling the social, economic, and environmental inequities that contribute to worse health outcomes for low-income Americans and people of colour. They also want to expand access to health care for people living and working across the United States by extending Affordable Care Act coverage to Dreamers and working with Congress to lift the five-year waiting period for Medicaid and Children's Health Insurance Program eligibility for low-income, lawfully present immigrants.

Public opinion on abortion

When broken down by party affiliation, the differences in opinion become more apparent. Among Republicans and independents who lean towards the Republican Party, 57% say abortion should be illegal in all or most cases, compared to 85% of Democrats and Democratic leaners who support legal abortion. The religious divide is also a significant factor, with 73% of White evangelical Protestants believing abortion should be illegal in all or most cases, while 86% of religiously unaffiliated Americans support legal abortion.

The issue of abortion is a key factor in the 2024 election, with a growing share of voters in swing states considering it a central issue, particularly for women under 45. The Democratic Party platform includes a section on "Reproductive Freedom" that embraces the idea that abortion is healthcare, while the Republican Party platform mentions abortion only once, stating their opposition to late-term abortion and support for prenatal care, birth control, and IVF.

Abortion and religion

Religion has long been a factor in the abortion debate, with the issue often framed as a binary between “pro-life” and “pro-choice” positions. In the US, the Republican Party platform states that "the unborn child has a fundamental right to life which cannot be infringed", while the Democratic Party supports access to "safe and legal abortion". However, these positions are not universally held by all Americans who identify with or lean towards each party.

A survey conducted by the Pew Research Center in 2022 found that religion played a significant role in shaping views on abortion within the Republican Party. Among Republicans who opposed legal abortion, 62% were Protestants, including 39% who were White evangelical Protestants. In contrast, among Republicans who supported legal abortion, only 35% were Protestants, with 34% being religiously unaffiliated. The survey also revealed that Republicans who favoured legal abortion were less religious than their counterparts who opposed it.

A similar divide was observed within the Democratic Party. Democrats who opposed legal abortion were found to be more religious than those who supported it. Black and Hispanic Democrats, who tend to be more religious than White Democrats, were more likely to oppose legal abortion. Additionally, Democrats who opposed abortion were more likely to identify as Christian, while those who supported it were more likely to be religiously unaffiliated.

The influence of religion on abortion views is further highlighted by the differences between religious groups. White evangelical Protestants, who are strongly opposed to abortion, with 73% believing it should be illegal in all or most cases, exert a significant influence on the Republican Party. In contrast, religiously unaffiliated Americans overwhelmingly support legal abortion, with 86% expressing this view. Black Protestants (71%), White non-evangelical Protestants (64%), and Catholics (59%) also show majority support for legal abortion, albeit to a lesser extent.

While the abortion debate often revolves around religious and moral arguments, it is important to recognise that public opinion is nuanced. Many people hold conflicting views, and their positions depend on various factors, such as the stage of pregnancy, the circumstances of the pregnant person, and the health of the fetus. Additionally, while religion plays a significant role, other factors, such as age, education, and political ideology, also shape individuals' views on abortion.

Abortion and politics

Abortion is a highly politicised issue in the United States, with the Democratic and Republican parties holding opposing positions on reproductive rights and healthcare. While public support for legal abortion has been relatively stable in recent years, with 63% of people saying it should be legal in all or most cases, there are clear differences in views between the two parties.

The Republican Party platform states that "the unborn child has a fundamental right to life which cannot be infringed", and the party has promoted pro-life policies that seek to curtail reproductive rights and access to reproductive healthcare. On the other hand, the Democratic Party platform supports access to safe and legal abortion and considers abortion as healthcare. This divergence in positions has been a significant factor in shaping the political landscape, with abortion emerging as a top issue in the 2024 election.

Historically, the Republican Party's stance on abortion has been influenced by a coalition of political and religious conservatives, who mobilised around issues such as Supreme Court decisions banning school prayer and legalising abortion. This group, which included fundamentalist Christians and the Catholic Church, exerted influence over Republican policies, even though most Americans were becoming more pro-choice. As a result, Republican policies during the Reagan administration, for example, denied funding to important international family planning agencies.

In recent years, there has been a shift in the politics of abortion rights, with a growing number of Republicans supporting abortion rights. This shift is particularly notable in states like Arizona, Nevada, and Florida, where polls show that a significant number of Republicans plan to vote for abortion rights amendments. This change could be attributed to the backlash against the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade in 2022, which has energised supporters of abortion rights.

The Democratic Party has capitalised on this shift, with Vice President Kamala Harris embarking on a "Fighting for Reproductive Freedom" bus tour and the party platform committing to restoring abortion rights through legislation. At the same time, the Republican Party's presidential nominee, Donald Trump, has tried to distance himself from the issue, stating that abortion policy should be left to the states. However, Trump has faced criticism for his role in overturning Roe v. Wade and his refusal to explicitly reject a nationwide abortion ban.

In conclusion, abortion remains a highly contested issue in American politics, with the Democratic and Republican parties offering distinct and conflicting visions for reproductive rights and healthcare. While the Republican Party has traditionally aligned with anti-abortion forces, there are signs that this may be changing, with a growing number of Republicans supporting abortion rights, particularly at the state level. The Democratic Party, on the other hand, remains firmly committed to protecting and expanding access to abortion, positioning itself as a champion of reproductive freedom.

Frequently asked questions