Moonshiners: Lawbreakers Or Folk Heroes?

The Discovery Channel's hit show Moonshiners has been accused of faking its entire premise. The show follows the lives of people in Kentucky, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia, as they produce moonshine—an illegal activity in the United States. So, how can the stars of Moonshiners break the law on national TV and stay out of jail? According to local law enforcement, the show is not real and is just a dramatization. The Virginia ABC Bureau of Law Enforcement has stated that they would have made arrests if illegal activity was taking place. The show's cast members have also indicated that television footage isn't evidence and that they could simply be distilling water. While the show takes creative liberties, some characters from the show do have a brand of moonshine, and there may be some historical accuracies portrayed.

The show's legality

The legality of the show "Moonshiners" has been a topic of debate and controversy. The show follows the lives of people in Kentucky, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia, who produce and distribute moonshine, an illegal activity in the United States. Federal law prohibits the production of spirits for private consumption without a permit.

So, how do the cast members of "Moonshiners" get away with breaking the law on national television? The answer lies in the loopholes and creative liberties taken by the show's producers. Firstly, it's important to note that the show is considered a docudrama, meaning it has some basis in reality but includes creative liberties and staged scenes. The very presence of cameras, producers, directors, and editors changes the nature of reality.

One way the show navigates legal issues is by arguing that the cast members are not necessarily breaking the law. They claim that the stills could contain water instead of moonshine, and without physical evidence and samples for analysis, law enforcement cannot make arrests. Additionally, cast members have stated that they need to be caught in the act of producing illegal moonshine, and by the time an episode airs, they are no longer in the same location.

Another factor to consider is the involvement of Magilla Entertainment, the production company behind "Moonshiners." Magilla Entertainment has a reputation for creating deceptive and misleading reality TV content. They have been accused of staging scenes, using misleading editing, and not obtaining the necessary permissions from participants. For example, in the first season of "Moonshiners," Special Agent Jesse Tate of the Virginia Alcohol Beverage Control Bureau appeared regularly, but he was unaware that the show would depict moonshine manufacturing and distribution. The Virginia ABC Bureau of Law Enforcement also stated that the show only features dramatizations and that they would have taken action if illegal activity was taking place.

Furthermore, the show's focus on the outlaw concept and illegal activities is a deliberate choice by the producers. Initially, the show was intended to feature licensed moonshiners going legit, but this concept was deemed too boring. By choosing to showcase illegal activities, the producers knowingly introduced legal risks to the show.

In conclusion, the legality of "Moonshiners" remains a grey area. While the show depicts illegal activities, it also employs creative liberties, loopholes, and deceptive production techniques to navigate legal consequences. The involvement of Magilla Entertainment and their reputation for misleading content further complicates the question of the show's legality. Ultimately, the producers and cast members of "Moonshiners" walk a fine line between reality and creative storytelling, leaving the audience to question the authenticity of what they are watching.

The cast's legal expertise

The cast of the Discovery Channel's show "Moonshiners" has been questioned by law enforcement on multiple occasions, but they have never been arrested or charged. The cast members have impressive legal expertise and are well-versed in the laws surrounding moonshining. They understand that the illegal aspect of moonshining lies primarily in the untaxed sales and the absence of permits, rather than the act of distilling itself.

Cast members have stated that law enforcement must catch them in the act of producing illegal moonshine and obtain physical samples of the product for analysis. Without concrete evidence, arrests cannot be made. The cast also claims that they could simply be distilling water, as the television footage does not serve as conclusive proof of any illegal activity.

In addition, some cast members have partnered with legal distilleries and major moonshine brands. For example, Mark and Digger have partnered with Sugarlands Distilling Company, the official moonshine of NASCAR. Tim Smith, another cast member, has gone legitimate and established a legal distillery, partnering with the Prost Beverage Company to market "Climax" brand moonshine.

The show's portrayal of illegal activities has sparked controversy and raised questions about its authenticity. Local law enforcement agencies, such as the Virginia ABC Bureau of Law Enforcement, have stated that the show features dramatizations and that they would have taken action if illegal activity was actually taking place. The show has been accused of misleading viewers and portraying false depictions of moonshine manufacturing, distribution, and transportation.

Despite the legal scrutiny and controversy surrounding the show, the cast of "Moonshiners" has managed to evade any legal consequences. Their legal expertise and careful navigation of the law have allowed them to continue their activities without incurring criminal charges.

The show's authenticity

The Discovery Channel's hit show "Moonshiners" has been accused of faking its entire premise. The show is considered a docudrama, meaning it has some basis in reality but takes creative liberties. Most of the show is staged and has producers and actors. However, some of the characters from the show do have a brand of moonshine.

The show follows the lives of people in Kentucky, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia, as they produce moonshine. Throughout most of the series, these people conducted their business illegally, which has led many to question how the show has avoided law enforcement.

There have been encounters with law enforcement on the show, adding real tension to the scenes. In some bonus footage, Tim Smith admits that police officers tried to confront him about the show one evening when he was home. They brought stills from the show to "prove" that he’d been moonshining illegally, but Tim remained calm and invited them into his house. He said that the police had come to his house many times looking for moonshine but never found evidence, which is why he was never arrested.

The show's cast members claim that the state is just mad that they haven't been able to catch them. Since agents would have to catch the cast in the act of producing illegal moonshine to have a case, they could keep making the show. Tim said, "You must be witnessed and physical samples of the product you’re producing have to be taken and analyzed." The cast tells law enforcement they are distilling water, and without evidence, there can be no arrests.

The show's stars, Tim and Tickle, have explained that they evade the law because, by the time the show airs, they are no longer in the same location, and it is difficult to prove they are actually producing moonshine. Tickle has also stated that the show is non-taxed, which is why it is illegal, and the federal government only cares about the alcohol level and how much they make, not the taste of the product.

While the show may feature real moonshining, it is unlikely that any illegal activity is taking place. Local law enforcement has stated that the show only features dramatizations of moonshining and that if illegal activity was taking place, they would have taken action. The show's production company, Magilla Entertainment, is also known for creating deceptive content, further calling into question the show's authenticity.

Law enforcement's involvement

The involvement of law enforcement in the "Moonshiners" show has been a topic of discussion and controversy. While the show depicts illegal moonshining activities, law enforcement agencies such as the Virginia ABC Bureau of Law Enforcement have stated that they would have taken action if any illegal activity was actually taking place. In fact, Special Agent Jesse Tate from the Virginia ABC Bureau appeared in the first season of the show, believing it to be an informative piece about the history of moonshine. However, he did not interact with the moonshiners, and the Virginia ABC later issued a statement claiming they were misled about the nature of the show.

There have been encounters with law enforcement on the show, adding real tension to the scenes. In some bonus footage, Tim Smith reveals that police officers tried to confront him off-camera by bringing stills from the show as evidence of illegal moonshining. However, Tim remained calm and invited them into his house, knowing that they had no solid evidence.

Cast members of the show claim that law enforcement would need to catch them in the act of producing illegal moonshine and obtain physical samples for analysis. Without concrete evidence, no arrests can be made. This has led to a back-and-forth between law enforcement and the show's participants, with the former claiming the show is fake and the latter insisting that they are evading the law.

The show's producers, Magilla Entertainment, have also come under scrutiny for creating deceptive content in other reality TV shows. This adds to the controversy surrounding the authenticity of "Moonshiners" and raises questions about the legality of depicting illegal activities on national television.

The show's production company

Magilla Entertainment, the production company behind Moonshiners, has been accused of deliberately deceiving its audience. Moonshiners is not the only show by Magilla Entertainment that has been accused of being misleading. Magilla Entertainment is also behind shows like America's Worst Tattoos, Submissive Wives' Guide to Marriage, and Militia Rising.

The show's first season featured special agent Jesse Tate of the Virginia Alcohol Beverage Control Bureau. Tate was misled about the nature of the show and had no idea that it would depict moonshine manufacturing or distribution. In a statement, the Virginia ABC said it had "agreed to participate in an informative piece that documents the history of moonshine and moonshine investigations in Virginia. Virginia ABC did not participate nor was aware of the false depiction of moonshine manufacturing, distribution, and/or transportation in the filming, and would not have participated in the 'documentary' had it known of this portrayal."

In response to the criticism, cast members of the show have claimed that the state is just mad that they haven't been able to catch them in the act. Since agents would have to catch the cast in the act of producing illegal moonshine to have a case, the show has been able to continue. Tim Smith, one of the show's stars, has said that "physical samples of the product you're producing have to be taken and analyzed." The cast also tells law enforcement that they are distilling water, and without evidence, there can be no arrests.

While Magilla Entertainment has stated that the show depicts illegal moonshining, it is unlikely that the production company would be willing to take on such significant legal risks. In fact, when Magilla Entertainment first started working on the show, they planned to feature licensed moonshiners going legit. However, they quickly realized that this would be boring for viewers. As a result, they decided to focus on outlaw moonshiners instead, while still insisting that the show depicts illegal activity.

Frequently asked questions