Idaho's Abortion Laws: Understanding The Current Landscape

what are idaho

Idaho's abortion laws are among the most restrictive in the US. The state prohibits anyone from performing or assisting with an abortion unless the pregnancy is ectopic or molar, a result of rape or incest, or a risk to the life of the mother. Abortions are only lawful if performed in a hospital or a physician's office, and they must be carried out by a licensed physician. The state's abortion ban has been criticised by doctors, who argue that it puts patients' lives at risk and prevents them from providing standard medical care.

Characteristics Values
Abortion legality Illegal at all stages of pregnancy, with exceptions for the life of the pregnant person and for survivors of rape and incest who have reported the incident to law enforcement.
Criminal abortion punishment A felony punishable by a sentence of imprisonment of no less than two years and no more than five years in prison.
Physician punishment The professional license of any health care professional who performs or attempts to perform an abortion will be suspended for a minimum of six months upon a first offense and permanently revoked upon a subsequent offense.
Location Only lawful if performed in a hospital or a physician's office or a clinic, which is properly staffed and equipped.
Second trimester abortions Only lawful if performed in a hospital.
Third trimester abortions Only lawful if performed in a hospital and necessary for the preservation of the life of the pregnant woman or if not performed, the pregnancy would result in the birth of a non-survivable fetus.

lawshun

Criminal abortion

Idaho's abortion laws are some of the strictest in the country. The state has a trigger ban in place that criminalizes abortion at all stages of pregnancy, with limited exceptions. This ban took effect on August 25, following the U.S. Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade.

Under Idaho's trigger ban, abortion is only permitted to save the life of the pregnant person or for survivors of rape and incest who have reported the incident to law enforcement. The state narrowed these exceptions in 2023, limiting the rape and incest exceptions to the first trimester and attempting to redefine abortion for specific medical conditions.

Idaho's abortion laws also include criminal abortion provisions, which are outlined in the state's statutes:

Idaho Code § 18-622, also known as the Defense of Life Act, defines criminal abortion and outlines the penalties for those who perform or attempt to perform abortions. According to this statute, anyone who performs or attempts to perform an abortion is guilty of a felony and subject to imprisonment for two to five years. The law also mandates the suspension or revocation of the professional license of any healthcare professional involved in performing or assisting with an abortion.

However, there are some exceptions to what constitutes a criminal abortion under Idaho law:

  • Protection of the Life of the Pregnant Woman: Abortion is not considered a criminal act if a physician determines, in good faith, that it is necessary to prevent the death of the pregnant woman. The law specifies that a woman's potential self-harm is not grounds for deeming the abortion necessary.
  • Rape and Incest during the First Trimester: If a woman reports rape or incest to law enforcement and provides a copy of the report to the physician, abortion is not considered a criminal act during the first trimester. For minors or those under guardianship, the report can be made by the woman, parent, or guardian.
  • Accidental Death or Unintentional Injury: Medical treatment provided to a pregnant woman that results in the accidental death or unintentional injury to the unborn child is not considered a criminal abortion.
  • No Criminal Conviction for the Pregnant Woman: The law specifies that a pregnant woman on whom an abortion is performed or attempted shall not be subject to criminal conviction or penalty.

In addition to these criminal abortion provisions, Idaho has other restrictive abortion laws in place. The state prohibits abortion after viability and has a 6-week gestational ban. Idaho also requires mandatory waiting periods, biased counseling, and parental consent for minors seeking abortions. The state has also enacted a law that criminalizes assisting minors in obtaining abortions outside of the state.

lawshun

Exceptions to the law

Idaho's abortion laws include a few exceptions that permit abortions in specific circumstances. Firstly, abortions are allowed if they are deemed necessary to prevent the death of the pregnant woman. This exception is based on the physician's good-faith medical judgment and the facts known to them at the time. The procedure must also be performed in a way that provides the best opportunity for the unborn child to survive, unless it poses a greater risk to the pregnant woman's life.

Secondly, abortions are permitted during the first trimester of pregnancy if the woman or, in the case of a minor or someone under guardianship, their parent or guardian, reports being a victim of rape or incest to a law enforcement agency. A copy of the report must be provided to the physician performing the abortion, and it remains a confidential part of the woman's medical record.

Additionally, abortions performed in a hospital or a properly equipped physician's office or clinic are considered lawful. For a woman in her second trimester, the abortion must be performed in a hospital, and for a woman in her third trimester, the procedure must be deemed necessary for the preservation of her life or if the fetus is unable to survive.

It is important to note that Idaho's abortion laws are subject to change, and the state's Supreme Court has allowed certain restrictions, such as a gestational ban at 6 weeks. The laws have faced challenges and criticism, with some doctors expressing concern about the impact on patient care and their own moral distress in following these laws.

lawshun

Hospitals and abortion

Idaho's abortion laws have had a profound impact on hospitals and medical professionals in the state, with many doctors choosing to leave the state due to the restrictive nature of the laws and the potential legal consequences of providing abortion care. The laws have created a climate of fear and uncertainty, with doctors unsure of how to interpret and apply the laws, particularly in emergency situations.

According to Idaho law, abortions are only lawful if performed in a hospital or a physician's office/clinic that is properly staffed and equipped and has made arrangements with an acute care hospital nearby for any complications or emergencies. Abortions performed during the second and third trimesters are only lawful if carried out in a hospital. In the third trimester, abortions are only permitted if necessary for the preservation of the mother's life or if the fetus is unable to survive.

The state's trigger laws, which went into effect after the overturning of Roe v. Wade, ban abortion at all stages of pregnancy, except when the mother's life is in danger or in cases of rape and incest reported to law enforcement. These laws have far-reaching consequences for hospitals and medical professionals. Doctors are unsure of how to interpret and apply the laws, particularly in emergency situations where a woman's health is at risk but her life may not be in immediate danger. The laws have created a climate of fear and uncertainty, with doctors worried about potential legal repercussions for their actions.

The impact of these laws on hospitals and medical professionals in Idaho has been significant. Many doctors, especially obstetricians and gynecologists (OB-GYNs), have chosen to leave the state due to the restrictive nature of the laws and the potential legal consequences of providing abortion care. This has resulted in a shortage of medical professionals in the state, particularly in rural areas, and the closure of maternity wards and labor and delivery units in some hospitals. The departure of so many physicians has strained Idaho's medical system, leaving remaining doctors and hospitals overwhelmed and unable to meet the needs of their patients.

The laws have also affected the way hospitals operate, with some choosing to transfer patients to other states for emergency abortions rather than risk legal repercussions. This has resulted in additional costs and logistical challenges for hospitals and patients alike. The laws have also had a detrimental effect on the doctor-patient relationship, with patients losing trust in their medical system and doctors feeling unable to provide the best possible care for their patients.

In conclusion, Idaho's abortion laws have had a profound and far-reaching impact on hospitals and medical professionals in the state. The restrictive nature of the laws, coupled with the potential legal consequences, has led to an exodus of doctors, strained the state's medical system, and created a climate of fear and uncertainty. The laws have also affected the way hospitals operate and have had a detrimental effect on the doctor-patient relationship, ultimately compromising the quality of care that patients receive.

lawshun

Idaho's abortion laws require parental consent for minors seeking an abortion. A parent or legal guardian must give consent for a minor's abortion. If this is not possible, a judge can approve a minor's abortion without parental consent.

In 2023, Idaho enacted a law that criminalizes assistance to a minor seeking an out-of-state abortion without parental consent. This law, known as House Bill 242, makes it illegal to obtain abortion pills for minors or help them leave the state to obtain an abortion without the consent of their parent or guardian. The law adds that the father, grandparent, sibling, aunt, or uncle of the unborn child has the right to sue an adult who helps a minor obtain an abortion up to four years after the procedure. Violators of this law can face two to five years in state prison.

The law does provide an affirmative defense for adults who help pregnant minors access abortions with the consent of their parents or legal guardians. This means that if a defendant can present evidence that a minor's parent or guardian agreed that the child could travel out-of-state for an abortion, they will not be held criminally liable.

However, this affirmative defense does not apply to abortion providers or providers of abortion pills based out-of-state. Therefore, if a pregnant minor obtains an abortion from a physician across state lines, that procedure is considered illegal.

lawshun

Reporting and facilities

Idaho's abortion laws are among the most restrictive in the United States. Abortions are only considered lawful if performed in a hospital or a physician's office or clinic that is properly staffed and equipped. If a woman is in her second trimester, the abortion must be performed in a hospital. For women in their third trimester, abortions are only lawful if performed in a hospital and deemed necessary for the preservation of the woman's life, or if the pregnancy would result in the birth of a non-viable fetus.

The state's trigger ban prohibits abortion at all stages of pregnancy, except when the pregnant person's life is at risk, or in cases of rape or incest that have been reported to law enforcement. The ban contains no true exceptions, allowing doctors only to mount an "affirmative defence" in court in cases involving rape or incest, or to prevent the death of the mother. The punishment for violating the law is a prison sentence of at least two years and up to five years. The state also has a Texas-style vigilante law that allows a family member of a "preborn child" to sue an abortion provider in civil court for at least $20,000.

The state's abortion laws have led to confusion and moral distress among doctors, who fear prosecution for providing medical care. Some doctors have chosen to leave the state, resulting in a strain on Idaho's medical system.

Frequently asked questions

Idaho's abortion law prohibits anyone from performing or assisting with an abortion except when the pregnancy is ectopic or molar, a result of rape or incest, or a risk to the life of the mother.

Performing or attempting to perform an abortion is a felony punishable by a sentence of imprisonment of no less than two years and no more than five years in prison. The professional license of any healthcare professional who performs or attempts to perform an abortion will be suspended for a minimum of six months for a first offence and permanently revoked for any subsequent offence.

The abortion law does not apply if the abortion is performed by a physician during the first trimester of pregnancy and the woman has reported to law enforcement that she is the victim of rape or incest. The abortion must also be performed in a hospital or a properly equipped clinic.

Idaho enacted a trigger law in 2020, which would ban abortion if Roe v. Wade were overturned. After Roe v. Wade was overturned in June 2022, Idaho began enforcing its trigger ban on 25 August 2022.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment