The Future Of Abortion Law: Will It Stand?

The US Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade in June 2022 has had a profound impact on abortion rights and access across the country. The ruling eliminated the federal constitutional right to abortion, empowering individual states to determine their abortion policies. As a result, abortion access has been severely restricted or banned in several states, with about half of the states expected to ban abortion in the near future. The decision has sparked widespread debate and strong reactions, with advocates for abortion rights highlighting the devastating consequences for women's rights, bodily autonomy, and health. The impact of the ruling is expected to be far-reaching, affecting not only abortion access but also other areas of reproductive health and freedom.

The impact of overturning Roe v. Wade

On June 24, 2022, the United States Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, the 1973 decision that had legalised abortion access in the country. The overturning of Roe v. Wade means that women's ability to choose to have an abortion or continue a pregnancy is no longer protected by the US Constitution. Instead, each state can now independently decide the legality of abortion.

On women's health

The overturning of Roe v. Wade will have a significant impact on women's health, particularly midlife women's health. Unintended pregnancies are a common occurrence among midlife women, and with restricted access to abortion, they may face critical health issues during their pregnancy. Additionally, the loss of Roe v. Wade may result in a lack of adequate abortion care education for healthcare providers, potentially leading to negative consequences for women's health in the long term.

On miscarriage care

Miscarriage care will also be impacted by the overturning of Roe v. Wade. The standard of care for treating a miscarriage is the same as for providing an abortion. As a result, people suffering miscarriages may face challenges in accessing the necessary medication and treatment due to restrictive abortion laws and policies.

On maternal mortality

The overturning of Roe v. Wade is expected to have deadly consequences, particularly for Black women and other people of colour who already face a maternal mortality crisis. If abortion is banned nationwide, pregnancy-related deaths are estimated to increase by 21% nationwide and 33% among Black women.

On access to abortion

The overturning of Roe v. Wade has resulted in a patchwork of abortion laws and restrictions across the country, with about half of the states expected to ban abortion. This has created a fragmented and polarised landscape, with "abortion trigger bans" and "gestational age bans" in several states. As a result, people seeking abortions may have to travel to other states or countries, face financial and social challenges, and endure suspicion, investigation, and potential arrest.

On reproductive justice

The overturning of Roe v. Wade has taken away the constitutional right to abortion and, with it, the agency over the lives and futures of those who can become pregnant. This decision disproportionately impacts marginalised communities, including women of colour, those struggling financially, young people, immigrants, people with disabilities, and LGBTQ+ communities. It has also opened up space for anti-abortion activists to push for the recognition of fetal rights, further curtailing the bodily autonomy of pregnant people.

On healthcare providers and infrastructure

The overturning of Roe v. Wade has had a significant impact on healthcare providers and infrastructure. Brick-and-mortar abortion clinics have closed, and physicians have fled restrictive states or left the medical profession altogether. Additionally, there has been a decline in applications for obstetrics and gynaecology residency programs in states with restrictive abortion laws, further straining access to gynecological care.

On IVF and other reproductive technologies

The overturning of Roe v. Wade has also raised questions and concerns about the potential impact on in vitro fertilisation (IVF) and other reproductive technologies. The way certain terms are defined in the new abortion laws, such as the definition of "pregnancy" and "unborn child," could potentially affect the use and disposal of embryos created during IVF. However, it is still unclear how these laws will ultimately affect IVF and other reproductive technologies.

State abortion laws

In June 2022, the US Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, eliminating the federal constitutional right to abortion and giving individual states the power to restrict or prohibit abortion access. As a result, abortion policies and reproductive rights now vary significantly across the US.

Currently, abortion is illegal in 13 states, with half of all states expected to ban abortion in the near future. Some states have passed laws protecting the right to abortion, while others have introduced restrictions or expressed a desire to prohibit abortion entirely. This has resulted in a fragmented abortion landscape, with "abortion deserts", where abortion is illegal, and "abortion havens", where care is still available.

The impact of these varying state abortion laws is significant, with consequences for abortion access, reproductive rights, and the safety and wellbeing of individuals seeking abortions. The restrictions have resulted in the closure of brick-and-mortar abortion clinics, with physicians fleeing restrictive states or leaving the medical profession altogether. Additionally, there has been a rise in pregnancy-related prosecutions, and miscarriages are now subject to suspicion, investigation, and potential arrest. The burden of these restrictions falls disproportionately on marginalised groups, including women of colour, people with low incomes, young people, immigrants, people with disabilities, and LGBTQ+ communities.

The impact on people seeking abortions

The overturning of Roe v. Wade in June 2022 has had a profound impact on people seeking abortions in the United States. The decision eliminated the federal right to abortion, leading to a fragmented landscape of abortion policies across the country. While some states have taken steps to protect and expand access to abortion, others have enacted total bans or introduced restrictions. This has resulted in reduced access to abortion care for millions of people, particularly those from marginalized communities.

People seeking abortions now face significant logistical and financial challenges, especially in states with total bans. They must either travel out of state to access care, self-manage an abortion, or carry an unwanted pregnancy to term. These options are particularly difficult for those facing economic insecurity and structural racism. The increased distance to abortion clinics also impacts the congestion of each center, as they serve both local patients and those from nearby states with more restrictive policies.

The lack of access to safe and legal abortions disproportionately affects low-income individuals and people of color, who already experience higher rates of abortion compared to their White and high-income counterparts. Restrictive abortion laws create geographic, transportation, and financial barriers, further exacerbating existing racial inequities in maternal and neonatal outcomes. The restrictions fall hardest on Black birthing people, who are already more than twice as likely to experience maternal mortality and severe maternal morbidity compared to White birthing people.

The overturning of Roe v. Wade has also had an impact on abortion education and training for medical professionals. Medical students and residents in states with restrictive abortion laws may have limited access to abortion training, which could affect their ability to provide care for patients requiring abortions, miscarriage management, or ectopic pregnancy care. The decision has also deterred some maternity care providers from practicing in states with restrictive abortion laws, impacting the quality of care for residents.

Additionally, social stigma and criminalization continue to be barriers for people seeking abortions. In some countries, including the United States, those who seek or provide abortions can face criminal charges, further compounding the challenges for individuals from marginalized communities. Overall, the overturning of Roe v. Wade has had far-reaching consequences for people seeking abortions, particularly those who are already facing systemic barriers to healthcare and reproductive autonomy.

The impact on medical professionals

The overturning of Roe v. Wade has had a profound impact on medical professionals, affecting their ability to provide care, their training, and their legal and ethical obligations.

Impact on the ability to provide care

Medical professionals are facing increased barriers to providing abortion care due to restrictive state laws and fear of prosecution. In some states, performing an abortion is now a felony, and doctors can be prosecuted and face prison time. This has created a chilling effect, with doctors afraid to provide care even in medical emergencies, as they do not want to risk running afoul of the law. The vague and conflicting language in the laws, as well as the lack of clear guidance from state legislators, has further added to the confusion and fear among medical professionals.

The restrictions have led to delays in care and denials of treatment for patients, even in cases of medical necessity. For example, doctors have reported being required by their hospitals to wait until patients become "sicker" before providing abortion care, even when it is clear that the patient's health is at risk. This has had devastating consequences, with some patients dying as a result of these delays.

The restrictions have also impacted the availability of certain medications and procedures used not only for abortions but also for miscarriage management, postpartum hemorrhage, and other medical conditions. For instance, mifepristone and misoprostol, commonly used in medication abortions, have been reclassified as controlled substances in some states, making it more difficult for medical professionals to access and administer these drugs.

Impact on training

The restrictions on abortion have also had a significant impact on the training of medical residents and students. Many residency programs and medical schools are now limited in their ability to provide abortion training, as they are located in states with restrictive abortion laws. This is particularly concerning as abortion training is essential not only for abortion provision but also for miscarriage management and other pregnancy complications. The lack of training opportunities will likely lead to a further shortage of providers and negatively impact patient care.

Impact on legal and ethical obligations

Medical professionals are facing ethical dilemmas as they are unable to provide the full range of reproductive health care options for their patients due to legal restrictions. They are being forced to deviate from established standards of care and medical ethics, which can cause moral distress and anguish. Additionally, the restrictions interfere with individual freedom and bodily autonomy, as patients are no longer able to make private medical decisions in consultation with their doctors.

The overturning of Roe v. Wade has far-reaching consequences for medical professionals, affecting their ability to provide care, their training, and their legal and ethical obligations. The restrictive state laws and fear of prosecution have created a chilling effect, leading to delays and denials of care for patients. The impact extends beyond abortion provision, as medications and procedures used for other medical conditions have also been impacted. The lack of training opportunities will likely exacerbate the existing shortage of providers. Medical professionals are facing ethical dilemmas and are unable to uphold their professional obligations to their patients. These consequences ultimately harm patients and put their health and well-being at risk.

The future of abortion rights

The impact of the Supreme Court's ruling is expected to be devastating, with half the states anticipated to ban abortion in the near future. This will have far-reaching consequences, particularly for those who are most vulnerable, including women of colour, people with low incomes, young people, immigrants, people with disabilities, and LGBTQ+ communities. Forcing someone to carry a pregnancy against their will can have life-altering repercussions, including serious health risks, difficulty escaping poverty, and derailing education and career plans.

In response to the overturning of Roe v. Wade, several states have already taken steps to restrict abortion access. Twenty-two states had laws or constitutional amendments in place that could be quickly used to ban abortion, and some states have trigger laws that automatically ban abortion following the Supreme Court's decision. Additionally, a dozen states have enacted six-week bans, which abortion-rights advocates argue is a de facto ban, as many people are unaware they are pregnant by that time.

The rollback of abortion rights has also coincided with a rise in pregnancy-related prosecutions, with 210 women criminally charged in 12 states in the year following the overturning of Roe v. Wade, the highest number in a single year since 1973. This trend has been driven by anti-abortion activists seeking to recognise the rights of the fetus as a person, further curtailing the bodily autonomy of pregnant individuals.

However, there has also been a strong backlash against the erosion of abortion rights, with citizens in six states voting for ballot measures to protect abortion access, and the issue taking centre stage in the upcoming presidential election. Additionally, abortion rights advocates have committed $100 million to the Abortion Access Now campaign, which aims to pass federal legislation guaranteeing the right to abortion.

Frequently asked questions