Abortion Laws: New York Vs New Jersey

Abortion laws in the United States have been a topic of discussion and controversy for decades, with states adopting different stances on the issue. New York and New Jersey, two neighbouring states, have notably distinct abortion laws, with New York recently voting on a measure to protect abortion rights, and New Jersey having legalised abortion at all stages of pregnancy. New York's abortion laws allow abortions up to the 24th week of pregnancy, while New Jersey has no such restrictions. New York's Reproductive Health Act further permits abortions past 24 weeks if the pregnant individual's life or health is at risk, or if the fetus is not viable. New Jersey's Freedom of Reproductive Choice Act, on the other hand, guarantees the right to an abortion for all pregnant individuals without specifying a gestational limit. These differences highlight the varying approaches taken by these states regarding abortion access and reproductive rights.

Abortion in New York is legal and protected up to 24 weeks

New York's abortion laws are less restrictive than those in many other states. The state does not mandate waiting periods, detailed consent, or counseling requirements. Additionally, New York does not require parental consent for minors seeking abortions or other reproductive health services. The state also protects the confidentiality of those seeking abortions, and prohibits employers from accessing personal information about their employees' reproductive health decisions.

New York requires insurance coverage of abortion, including Medicaid and all state-regulated private health insurance plans. The state also modified its insurance laws, mandating that private insurers offer coverage for medically necessary abortions.

After 24 weeks, abortion is still permitted in New York if the fetus is not viable or if the patient's life, physical health, or mental health is at risk. The state has also enacted shield laws to protect those seeking abortions from civil and criminal litigation from their home state.

In contrast, while abortion remains legal in neighbouring New Jersey, the state has seen some attempts to restrict abortion access in recent years. In 2015, then-Governor Chris Christie supported a 20-week abortion ban, and a Pain-Capable Unborn Child Protection Act was discussed but ultimately withdrawn due to opposition from female Republican House members. New Jersey has also seen a decline in the number of abortion clinics in recent years. However, the state does not require waiting periods or parental consent for minors seeking abortions, and Governor Phil Murphy has taken steps to preserve abortion rights, such as signing the Freedom of Reproductive Choice Act into law in 2021.

After 24 weeks, abortion in New York is permitted if the fetus is not viable

Abortion laws vary from state to state across the US, with some states imposing restrictive laws, and others, like New York, protecting abortion rights. Abortion has been legal in New York since 1970, three years before the Roe v. Wade decision, and this right is codified in New York State law.

In New York, abortion is permitted up to and including 24 weeks of pregnancy. After this point, abortion is only allowed in specific circumstances. One of these circumstances is if the foetus is not viable. This means that if a medical professional determines that the foetus cannot survive outside the womb, an abortion can be performed after 24 weeks. This is a critical protection for pregnant people, as it allows them to end a pregnancy that will not result in a live birth.

The viability of a foetus is often a central consideration in abortion laws. While New York permits abortion after 24 weeks if the foetus is not viable, other states may have different laws and restrictions surrounding this issue. It is important to note that the determination of foetal viability is a complex medical assessment and can vary depending on the specific circumstances of each pregnancy.

In contrast to New York, some states have sought to restrict abortion access and implement bans. For example, in 2015, then-Governor of New Jersey, Chris Christie, expressed support for a 20-week abortion ban. However, abortion remains legal in New Jersey, and the state has taken steps to protect abortion access, such as passing the Freedom of Reproductive Choice Act in 2021.

The differences in abortion laws between New York and New Jersey highlight the varying approaches to abortion rights across the US. While New York has established protections for abortion access, other states may have more restrictive laws, demonstrating the ongoing debate and divergence of opinions on this issue.

New Jersey permits abortion at all stages of pregnancy

Abortion in New Jersey is legal at all stages of pregnancy. In January 2022, Governor Phil Murphy signed the Freedom of Reproductive Choice Act into law, explicitly giving all New Jerseyans the right to make their own decisions about birth control, abortion, and prenatal care. This means that, regardless of the Supreme Court's stance, abortions can be obtained in New Jersey. The Freedom of Reproductive Choice Act also ensures that abortion and reproductive autonomy are protected by state law and the state Constitution, for both residents and those visiting from out of state.

New Jersey has strong, independent legal protections over the right of reproductive autonomy, including abortion. These protections are guaranteed through legislation and the state Constitution, and have not been weakened by the U.S. Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. The New Jersey Supreme Court has also struck down a law requiring parental notification, meaning that minors can obtain an abortion without parental consent.

The Freedom of Reproductive Choice Act specifically recognises the existing constitutional protections and codifies reproductive rights into state law. The Act ensures that abortion is a fundamental constitutional right in New Jersey, with robust privacy protections interpreted by state courts to safeguard the right to abortion.

In addition to the Freedom of Reproductive Choice Act, New Jersey has other laws in place to protect abortion access. For example, New Jersey is one of 15 states whose state Medicaid program covers abortion, and Governor Murphy has approved the allocation of state taxpayer money to Planned Parenthood, which offers abortion care. Furthermore, New Jersey recently enacted a law prohibiting state officials from cooperating with out-of-state investigations seeking to prosecute providers or patients for abortion care. This demonstrates the state's commitment to protecting abortion access and ensuring that residents and visitors have the right to make their own decisions about their reproductive health.

New Jersey minors can obtain abortions without parental consent

In the state of New Jersey, abortion is legal at all stages of pregnancy. The right to an abortion is guaranteed to all pregnant individuals in the state, including minors without parental consent. This means that anyone who is pregnant, regardless of their age, can consent to their healthcare.

New Jersey law states that as long as a minor has obtained the required information, such as risks and alternatives, they may give informed consent to these services without parental consent. This is in line with the state's commitment to ensuring that no barriers to reproductive freedom exist. All healthcare professionals are bound by law to adhere to HIPAA confidentiality rules, unless the minor is suspected of being a victim of child abuse or neglect, is a harm to themselves or others, or is listed by the insurance the minor may be attempting to use.

The Freedom of Reproductive Choice Act, signed into law in January 2021, recognised the existing state constitutional protections and codified reproductive rights into state law. This was done in anticipation of a possible Supreme Court decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, which did occur later in 2022.

New Jersey has some of the most progressive abortion laws in the country, and its support for abortion rights remains strong. The state also protects those seeking abortion care from other, more restrictive states. If someone is receiving abortion services in New Jersey and is travelling from a state where these services are illegal, New Jersey law protects them from being extradited in connection with receiving those services.

New York minors can access abortions without parental permission

New York has long been a leader in promoting reproductive health services for minors. Minors in New York can receive confidential prenatal care, testing, and treatment for sexually transmitted infections and abortions without parental involvement. This is an important public health policy that recognises the importance of providing teens with unimpeded access to critical health services.

While parental involvement should be encouraged, it is most important that young people have access to the services they need to remain safe and healthy. Public health studies and court rulings have shown that parental involvement laws are detrimental to minors as they increase the risk of harm or abuse, cause minors to avoid or delay seeking necessary care, and lead them to seek out more dangerous alternatives to avoid involving their parents.

In New York, abortion has been legal since 1970, and this right is codified in state law, meaning federal decisions to limit access to abortion will not impact the state. Abortion is available for New Yorkers and those from out of state, and medication abortion and in-clinic abortion are both options. New York does not have any laws about telling parents or getting their permission for an abortion.

In contrast, New Jersey is one of the few states that do not require mandatory consent for minors to get an abortion, either through parental notification or judicial bypass. Minors in New Jersey are able to obtain abortion services without parental consent, as long as they have obtained the required information, such as risks and alternatives, and can give informed consent.

Frequently asked questions