The Legacy Of Byzantine Law: A Foundation For Legal Systems

The Byzantine law code, also known as the Corpus Juris Civilis, was a major reform of Byzantine law created by Emperor Justinian I. It became the basis for civil law in Western Europe and influenced the canon law of the Catholic Church. The Code of Justinian, as it was later known, was written and distributed in Latin, though the prevalent language of the Byzantine Empire was Greek. It was a condensation of 2,000 volumes of legal works, some dating back about 1,000 years, and formed the basis for civil law in Western Europe. The Code of Justinian was also the basis for local legal codes in the Balkans during the Ottoman period and later formed the basis of the legal code of Modern Greece.

The basis for civil law in Western Europe

The Code of Justinian, or the Corpus Juris Civilis, is the basis for civil law in Western Europe. It was commissioned by Byzantine Emperor Justinian I in 528 CE, who believed that the empire's legal system needed repair. The code was compiled by a commission of legal experts and scholars who reviewed and condensed 2,000 volumes of legal works, some dating back to the early Roman Republic of the west and the first Roman Emperor Hadrian. The code was produced from 529 to 533 CE and formed the Codex Justinianus, later known as the Code of Justinian.

The Corpus Juris Civilis was written and distributed in Latin, which was the official language of the Byzantine Empire at the time. The code compiled all existing imperial constitutiones (imperial pronouncements with the force of law) and was based on the Codex Theodosianus, the Codex Gregorianus, and the Codex Hermogenianus. These codices provided the model for the division of the code into books and titles. The Corpus Juris Civilis was intended to be the sole source of law, and reference to any other source was forbidden.

In Western Europe, the Corpus Juris Civilis was distributed in areas regained under Justinian's wars of reconquest, including the Exarchate of Ravenna. It was also taught at the University of Bologna, which became the dominant centre for the study of law through the High Middle Ages. However, after the loss of most of these areas, only the Catepanate (southern Italy) maintained a Byzantine legal tradition. In the Middle Ages, the Corpus Juris Civilis or its successor texts like the Basilika were "received" or imitated as private law in Western Europe. Its public law content was also used by both secular and ecclesiastical authorities.

The Corpus Juris Civilis became the foundation of law in all civil law jurisdictions and influenced the canon law of the Catholic Church. It also influenced the common law legal systems, although to a much smaller extent. The four parts of the Corpus Juris Civilis constitute the foundation documents of the Western legal tradition.

The foundation of law in all civil law jurisdictions

The Byzantine law code, or the Corpus Juris Civilis, was a major reform of Byzantine law created by Emperor Justinian I. It was a collection of fundamental works in jurisprudence, enacted from 529 to 534, and consisting of four parts: the Codex Justinianus, the Digestum or Pandectae, the Institutiones, and the Novellae Constitutiones. This code became the basis for civil law in Western Europe and, in the Middle Ages, it was "received" or imitated as private law. It also served as the foundation of law in all civil law jurisdictions.

The Corpus Juris Civilis was written and distributed in Latin, which was the official language of the Byzantine Empire at the time. However, by the early 7th century, the official language had shifted to Greek, and the Corpus was revised into Greek as well. The Corpus continued to form the basis of the empire's laws, known as the Basilika, through the 15th century.

The Basilika, in turn, served as the basis for local legal codes in the Balkans during the Ottoman period and later became the foundation of the legal code of Modern Greece. It also influenced the canon law of the Catholic Church, with the saying "ecclesia vivit lege romana" – the church lives by Roman law.

In Western Europe, the influence of the Corpus Juris Civilis was more indirect after the fall of the Roman Empire, but it remained significant during the Middle Ages. During the European Renaissance, Western scholars embraced Justinian's Code as a basis for jurisprudence, but they shunned the later legal developments of the Byzantine Empire, such as the Ecloga. This was due in part to the East/West (Roman Catholic vs. Eastern Orthodox) split in the Church.

Overall, the Corpus Juris Civilis had a lasting impact on the legal systems of Europe and beyond, shaping the foundation of law in all civil law jurisdictions.

The basis for local legal codes in the Balkans during the Ottoman period

Historical Context

The Balkans, located in Southeastern Europe, have a long and tumultuous history marked by centuries of conquest and fragmentation. During the Ottoman period, the region experienced significant political and social transformations that shaped its legal landscape.

Influence of Byzantine Law

Before the Ottoman conquest, Byzantine law, a continuation of Roman law with Orthodox Christian and Hellenistic influences, held sway in the Balkans. Emperor Justinian I's Corpus Juris Civilis, compiled in the 6th century, served as the foundation for Byzantine law and had a lasting impact on legal traditions in the region.

Ottoman Legal System

The Ottoman Empire governed its territories with a unique legal system that balanced central and local authority. It consisted of three court systems: one for Muslims, one for non-Muslims, and a "trade court." The sultanic law, known as Qanun, coexisted with religious law, mainly the Hanafi school of Islamic jurisprudence.

Land Ownership and Agrarian Relations

One of the most significant areas of legal concern during the Ottoman period in the Balkans was land ownership and agrarian relations. The Ottoman Land Code of 1858, part of the Tanzimat reforms, aimed to regulate landholding across the empire. It recognised the individual as a legal subject, extended rights related to land transfer and inheritance, and blurred the lines between private and public land ownership.

Impact on Post-Imperial Context

Even after the end of Ottoman rule, the influence of the Ottoman Land Code persisted in the Balkans. Newly formed nation-states, such as Bulgaria, sought to assert their sovereignty and address land ownership issues. They enacted laws to formalise private land ownership and redistribute land, particularly from large Muslim landholders to local peasants.

Judicial Reforms

The Ottoman Empire underwent substantial legal reforms in the 19th century, influenced by Western ideologies. These reforms included fair and public trials, the separation of religious and civil matters, and the validation of testimony of non-Muslims. The legal system was restructured with a three-tiered court system, similar to French models, known as the Nizamiye.

In conclusion, the local legal codes in the Balkans during the Ottoman period were shaped by a combination of historical factors, including the influence of Byzantine law, the implementation of the Ottoman legal system, land ownership regulations, and subsequent judicial reforms influenced by Western legal traditions. These factors contributed to the dynamic and evolving legal landscape of the region during this period.

The basis of the legal code of modern Greece

The Byzantine legal code, also known as the Corpus Juris Civilis, was a major reform of Byzantine law created by Emperor Justinian I. It was a comprehensive and consistent body of laws that covered all aspects of life and society in Byzantium. The code was used as the basis of Byzantine law for over 900 years and continued to influence many Western legal systems even after the fall of the Byzantine Empire in 1453.

The Corpus Juris Civilis was enacted from 529 to 534 and consisted of four main parts: the Codex Justinianus, the Digestum or Pandectae, the Institutiones, and the Novellae Constitutiones. The work was directed by Tribonian, an official in Justinian's court in Constantinople, and a team of legal experts and scribes. They studied hundreds of documents and Latin Roman laws dating back to the early Roman Republic, deciding which were no longer relevant and adapting those that were. The Corpus Juris Civilis was written and distributed in Latin, which was the official language of the government of the Byzantine Empire at the time, although the prevalent language of merchants, farmers, and other citizens was Greek.

Over time, as the administrative language of the Byzantine Empire shifted from Latin to Greek, the Corpus Juris Civilis was revised into Greek and continued to form the basis of the empire's laws through the 15th century. This revised version was known as the Basilika and served as the basis for local legal codes in the Balkans during the Ottoman period. Most importantly, the Basilika also formed the basis of the legal code of modern Greece.

In addition to its influence on the legal code of modern Greece, the Corpus Juris Civilis had a significant impact on the legal traditions of Western Europe. It became the basis for civil law in Western Europe, particularly through its influence on the University of Bologna, which was the dominant centre for the study of law during the High Middle Ages. The Corpus Juris Civilis was also a major influence on public international law and the canon law of the Catholic Church.

The basis for Serbian legal codes

The Serbian Civil Code (SCC) was the first and only complete Civil Code in Serbia. It was enacted on 6 April 1844 and remained in force for a century, until 1946, making it the longest-lasting code in Serbia's recent history. The SCC was based mostly on the Civil Code of Austria, but also on Serbian customary law, and was written by Jovan Hadžić, a lawyer and writer. It was designed to protect the owners of land and consisted of 950 articles, making it one of the shortest Civil Codes created.

The SCC was preceded by Dušan's Code, enacted in 1349 by Stefan Uroš IV Dušan of Serbia. Dušan's Code drew upon Roman law, Byzantine law, customary law, and canon law. It regulated all aspects of life, including family relations, property rights, contracts, and crimes. It was used in the Serbian Empire and the succeeding Serbian Despotate and is considered an early constitution.

Dušan's Code was heavily influenced by Byzantine law, with nearly half of its 201 articles reflecting some influence, often modified for Serbia. It was based on the Farmer's Law, a code settling disputes among peasants within a village. The Farmer's Law, in turn, was influenced by Slavic legal traditions, including those of Russia.

Serbian medieval law, which spanned from the first half of the 7th century AD to the second half of the 15th century AD, was visibly influenced by Byzantine law. During this period, punishments were introduced and status, civil, criminal, and procedural law started to develop.

Frequently asked questions