Consequences Of Breaking Immigration Law: Understanding The Risks

Breaking immigration law can have serious consequences, including fines, detention, and deportation. The specific repercussions depend on the nature and context of the violation, as well as the country in which it occurs. For example, in the United States, the Immigration and Nationality Act outlines that citizenship and legal status can be revoked if individuals fail to follow the country's rules, including those specific to their immigration status. This can result in deportation, especially for those who entered the country illegally. Similarly, in the United Kingdom, breaching immigration bail conditions can lead to re-detention, additional penalties, and negative impacts on one's immigration status and future applications.

Detention and deportation

Detention

If a noncitizen is detained, they may be held in a detention centre before their trial or deportation. However, they may also be granted bail or released under supervision. In some cases, individuals may be eligible for an alternative to detention, such as the Intensive Supervision Appearance Program, which uses technology and case management to monitor individuals who do not need to be detained.

Deportation

Deportation is the process of removing a noncitizen from a country for violating immigration law. In the US, deportation is carried out by the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Before deportation, a noncitizen may go before a judge in an immigration court. If the judge rules that deportation should proceed, ICE will carry out a removal order. In some cases, noncitizens may be subject to expedited removal without appearing before a judge. This can happen if the individual enters the country without proper travel documents, uses forged travel documents, or does not comply with their visa requirements.

Rights of Individuals

Regardless of immigration status, individuals have guaranteed rights under the Constitution. For example, individuals have the right to remain silent and do not have to discuss their immigration status with police, immigration agents, or other officials. They also have the right to refuse a search of their person or belongings without their consent or probable cause. If detained, individuals have the right to consult with a lawyer, although the government is not required to provide one.

Re-entry

Individuals who have been deported may face challenges if they attempt to re-enter the country. In the US, laws such as Sections 1325 ("illegal entry") and 1326 ("illegal reentry") of Chapter 8 of the U.S. Code criminalize unauthorized re-entry and can result in criminal sanctions in addition to civil immigration detention and deportation proceedings.

Criminal charges and prosecution

Criminal Charges

The types of criminal charges an individual may face for violating immigration laws differ based on their circumstances and jurisdiction. Here are some common examples:

• "Illegal Entry": This charge applies to individuals who enter a country without proper inspection, such as those who enter between designated ports, avoid examination, or make false statements during entry.
• "Illegal Re-Entry": This charge is applicable to individuals who unlawfully re-enter or attempt to re-enter a country after being deported or removed.
• Crimes of "Moral Turpitude": These are crimes that may be interpreted in various ways and can include misdemeanors or more serious offenses. Immigration authorities have some discretion in using these crimes as grounds for deportation.
• Document Fraud: Providing false or fraudulent documents during the immigration process can lead to criminal charges.
• Other Criminal Offenses: Depending on the jurisdiction, certain crimes like domestic violence, drug offenses, firearms trafficking, money laundering, espionage, terrorism, rape, and murder can have immigration-related consequences, including deportation.

Prosecution and Penalties

The prosecution process for immigration law violations can vary, but it often involves collaboration between immigration authorities and the criminal justice system. Here are some key aspects:

• Right to an Attorney: Individuals facing criminal charges for immigration violations have the right to legal representation. If they cannot afford a private attorney, the government may provide one, although the quality of representation may be compromised in mass prosecution settings.
• Plea Agreements: Prosecutors may offer plea deals to migrants charged with immigration offenses. For example, a prosecutor might offer a reduced charge or sentence if the migrant agrees to plead guilty and waive certain rights.
• Incarceration: If convicted of an immigration-related offense, individuals may face incarceration in federal or immigration detention facilities. The length of incarceration varies based on the specific charges and sentencing guidelines.
• Impact on Immigration Status: Criminal convictions for immigration violations can have significant implications for an individual's current and future immigration status. It may lead to deportation, affect their ability to legally immigrate in the future, or increase their priority for future criminal prosecution or deportation if they are apprehended again.

It is important to note that the consequences of breaking immigration laws can be complex and vary based on individual circumstances and the specific laws of the country in question. Seeking legal advice from an experienced immigration attorney is crucial for understanding one's rights and navigating the immigration system.

Revoked bail and re-detention

Breaching immigration bail conditions can lead to severe consequences, including re-detention, additional penalties, and potential risks to your immigration status. The immigration authorities can revoke your bail and place you back in an immigration removal centre. This can make it harder to apply for bail in the future and negatively affect your overall immigration case.

If you breach your immigration bail conditions, acting promptly to limit the potential repercussions is essential. The first step is to seek immediate legal advice from an immigration lawyer or solicitor with expertise in these cases. A qualified legal professional can guide you on the best course of action and may be able to negotiate with immigration authorities to minimise the impact of the breach.

Loss of citizenship or legal status

Involuntary loss of citizenship, also known as denaturalization or forfeiture, can occur due to various reasons. These include fraud in the naturalization process, failure to renounce other citizenships, and severe legal breaches such as treason. For instance, if an individual obtains citizenship illegally, such as by lying during the naturalization process, they may face deportation and criminal charges for fraud.

In the context of student visas, violating the terms of the visa can result in falling out of status, leading to potential deportation and a bar on re-entering the country for several years. This can happen through unauthorized employment, reducing the course load below full-time, or switching schools without proper approval.

Separation of families

Breaking immigration law can have serious consequences, including the separation of families.

In the United States, more than 16.7 million people live with at least one family member who is undocumented, and roughly six million of these people are children under the age of 18. Immigration enforcement actions can have significant physical, emotional, developmental, and economic repercussions for these children.

Deportations of parents and other family members can have serious consequences for children, including an increased risk of mental health problems such as depression, anxiety, and severe psychological distress. Children who are suddenly separated from their parents experience toxic stress, which negatively impacts brain development and increases the risk of developing chronic mental health conditions such as depression and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). They are also at greater risk of physical conditions such as cancer, stroke, diabetes, and heart disease.

In addition to the direct impact on children, the threat of immigration enforcement can also lead to decreased participation in health insurance programs, negatively impacting a child's healthy growth and development and threatening a family's financial stability. Children who reside in communities that partner with ICE or are the focus of ICE raids may also experience negative educational outcomes, as their families choose to leave or avoid moving to these communities.

The separation of families due to breaking immigration law can have long-lasting and devastating effects on the well-being of children and communities. It is important to be aware of the rights that individuals have when interacting with law enforcement and immigration officials to help protect families and minimize the potential harm caused by immigration enforcement actions.

Frequently asked questions