Reservation Laws: Breaking The Rules, What's The Verdict?

Native American communities in the US fall under the authority of a combination of tribal, state, and federal law. The laws that apply to you if you break the law on a reservation depend on the type of crime committed, the perpetrator's Native American status, and the state and tribe involved. For example, on most reservations, the FBI investigates and prosecutes federal crimes like murder and rape, while misdemeanors like domestic violence may be handled by tribal law enforcement, state police, or the FBI if the perpetrator is not Native American. Understanding these complexities is crucial for determining the legal consequences of breaking the law on a reservation.

Tribal law enforcement are usually first on the scene

Tribal Law Enforcement: First on the Scene

Tribal law enforcement officers are usually the first to respond to any criminal incidents on Native American reservations. These officers are either tribal employees funded by the Bureau of Indian Affairs or federal employees trained and paid directly by the bureau.

The type of crime committed and the identity of the perpetrator determine the authority of tribal law enforcement. For example, the FBI investigates and prosecutes federal crimes such as murder and rape on most reservations. However, misdemeanours, including domestic violence, may be handled by tribal law enforcement, state police, or the FBI if the perpetrator is non-Native American.

Despite often being first on the scene, tribal law enforcement faces challenges due to poor communication with state and federal authorities, who often have ultimate jurisdiction in cases. This has led to a "maze of injustice," creating a culture of distrust where perpetrators believe they can act with impunity, and victims lack faith in the justice system.

Tribal police forces also struggle with inadequate resources and high turnover rates, making it difficult to provide 24/7 police coverage. As a result, they often focus on acute criminal behaviour rather than addressing systemic issues that may contribute to crimes.

To address these issues, there have been legislative efforts to strengthen tribal law enforcement and improve coordination with other agencies. For example, the Tribal Law and Order Act of 2010 requires federal prosecutors to be more proactive in prosecuting crimes reported by tribes and gives tribal police more authority to prosecute non-tribal members.

The FBI investigates and prosecutes federal crimes on reservations

Native American communities fall under the authority of a combination of tribal, state, and federal law. The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) is tasked with investigating and prosecuting federal crimes committed on Native American reservations. This includes serious offenses such as murder and rape. However, it's important to note that the FBI's involvement can vary depending on the state, tribe, the nature of the crime, and whether the perpetrator is Native American or not.

In general, tribal law enforcement officers are usually the first responders to any crime committed on a reservation. These officers are either tribal employees funded by the Bureau of Indian Affairs or federal employees trained and paid directly by the bureau. They play a crucial role in maintaining law and order on the reservation and have the authority to investigate and prosecute certain types of crimes.

When it comes to federal crimes, the FBI takes the lead in investigating and prosecuting these offenses. This is due to the unique legal status of Native American tribes as separate political entities within the United States. The FBI has the necessary jurisdiction and resources to handle these complex cases, ensuring that justice is served for all parties involved.

The investigation and prosecution of federal crimes on reservations by the FBI can be a challenging task due to the complex interplay between tribal, state, and federal laws. Effective communication and coordination between tribal, state, and federal authorities are essential to ensuring that crimes do not fall through the cracks and that justice is served for all members of the community.

In addition to the FBI's role, it's worth noting that tribal law enforcement also plays a crucial part in addressing misdemeanors and less severe crimes on reservations. This includes offenses such as domestic violence, which may be handled by tribal police, state police, or the FBI if the perpetrator is not Native American. This highlights the dynamic nature of law enforcement on reservations, where the specific circumstances of each case determine the involvement of different agencies.

Overall, the FBI's role in investigating and prosecuting federal crimes on Native American reservations is a critical aspect of ensuring justice and protecting the rights of individuals within these unique legal jurisdictions. By working together with tribal and state authorities, the FBI helps uphold the law and maintain peace in these communities.

Tribal police are trained at state academies, which may not provide tribal-specific training

Tribal police officers are often trained at state academies, such as the United States Indian Police Academy, which was established in 1968/1969. This academy is a nationally recognised institution that offers training to 191 Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) and tribal departments. The academy trains police, corrections, and dispatch officers, special agents, and command staff in basic, specialised, and advanced programs. However, it is important to note that tribal police are not always provided with tribal-specific training at these state academies.

The unique nature of tribal communities requires officers to have specialised training to effectively serve them. Tribal communities are often closely knit, with members being familiar with each other. As a result, officers serving these communities are held to a high level of accountability, as their reputation is based on the professional service they provide. This dynamic underscores the importance of tribal-specific training for law enforcement personnel working in these communities.

The United States Indian Police Academy recognises this need and incorporates tribal-specific knowledge into its curriculum. The academy's instructors are experienced in handling the unique needs and expectations of tribal communities. They are often members of the tribes, bands, pueblos, and villages that comprise Indian Country, bringing valuable insights to the training programs. The curriculum combines tribal-specific knowledge with contemporary law enforcement practices and techniques, ensuring that cadets are well-prepared to address serious situations with integrity and safety in mind.

One example of tribal-specific training is the Lieutenant Command School (LCS), established in 2015 by the United States Indian Police Academy. LCS provides instruction in the policies and practices relevant to tribal law enforcement, along with leadership development courses for supervisory-level police officers, criminal investigators, correctional officers, and command staff. The school offers tuition-free, five-day classes that cover scenario-based and instruction-led training. This training equips officers with the skills and knowledge to effectively serve Indian Country while respecting and reflecting Native American culture and values.

In summary, while tribal police officers may receive training at state academies, it is crucial to ensure that these academies provide tribal-specific training to address the unique needs and dynamics of tribal communities. The United States Indian Police Academy is a leading example of an institution that recognises the importance of tribal-specific training and incorporates it into its curriculum.

The Tribal Law and Order Act of 2010 requires federal prosecutors to be more proactive about prosecuting crimes reported by tribes

The Tribal Law and Order Act (TLOA) was passed by Congress in 2010 to address crime in tribal communities and place a strong emphasis on decreasing violence against American Indian and Alaska Native women. The Act requires federal prosecutors to be more proactive about prosecuting crimes reported by tribes. This means that federal authorities must take a more active role in investigating and pursuing charges against those who commit crimes on reservations.

The TLOA recognises that Native American tribes are separate political entities and aims to strengthen their authority to prosecute and punish criminals. It encourages the hiring of more law enforcement officers for Indian lands and provides additional tools to address critical public safety needs. The Act also expands the access of Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) and Tribal police officers to criminal information-sharing databases.

The TLOA authorises new guidelines for handling sexual assault and domestic violence crimes, including training for law enforcement and court officers, improved evidence collection, and enhanced services for victims. It also encourages the development of more effective prevention programmes to combat alcohol and drug abuse among at-risk youth.

While the TLOA has been praised for its efforts to revitalise tribal justice systems and address deficiencies in previous legislation, there have been challenges in its implementation. Enforcement has been difficult due to a lack of funding and cultural sensitivity, and the Act has also exacerbated confusion over jurisdictional authority between federal, state, and tribal governments.

Despite these challenges, the TLOA represents a significant step towards recognising tribal sovereignty and improving public safety in Native American communities. It is important to note that the effectiveness of the Act may vary depending on the specific context and resources available to each tribe.

Tribal police have more authority to prosecute non-tribal members

Tribal police have the authority to temporarily detain and search non-tribal members on public rights-of-way through American Indian lands. They can investigate and hold non-Native Americans while waiting for backup from state police or federal officers. However, tribal police typically lack jurisdiction to arrest, charge, and prosecute non-tribal members.

In the United States, local governments have the authority to investigate and prosecute misdemeanour and felony crimes. Local police can detain and search individuals suspected of state and federal crimes, at least until they are handed over to the appropriate authorities. Tribal governments, on the other hand, do not have the same authority when it comes to non-tribal members. In 1978, the Supreme Court ruled that tribal governments could not prosecute non-tribal members for any crimes in Indian country. This means that tribal governments must rely on state and federal governments to prosecute non-tribal members, which doesn't happen often. As a result, non-tribal members have been able to commit crimes in Indian country with impunity.

However, tribal police are often the first responders to reported crimes on tribal lands, regardless of whether the victims or alleged perpetrators are tribal members or not. In June 2021, the Supreme Court clarified that tribal police can search non-tribal members suspected of state or federal crimes in Indian country and detain them until they can be handed over to federal or state authorities. This decision affirms the authority that tribes have on their lands and acknowledges the vital role that tribal governments play in keeping their communities safe.

Tribal police have inherent authority to exercise criminal jurisdiction over tribal members and to arrest and detain non-tribal members for delivery to state or federal authorities for prosecution. These powers are generally limited to the reservation. Tribal police are often critical to resolving criminal cases referred to state and federal agencies because they usually discover the crime, interview witnesses, and understand the circumstances involved.

Frequently asked questions