Understanding Merchant Guarantee Legalities: Which Law Applies?

The implied warranty of merchantability is a legal concept that protects consumers from losing money on defective products. This warranty, outlined in the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) § 2-314, guarantees that goods sold are fit for their intended purpose and meet certain quality standards. It applies to most consumer products on the market and holds merchants accountable for ensuring their products' quality before placing them up for sale. This warranty exists independently of any explicit promises made by the seller and serves to protect consumers from financial loss due to defective or mislabelled products.

Implied warranty of merchantability

The implied warranty of merchantability is a type of warranty defined in U.C.C. § 2-314. It is a merchant's basic promise that the goods sold will do what they are supposed to do and that there is nothing significantly wrong with them. In other words, it is an implied promise that the goods are fit to be sold. The law says that merchants make this promise automatically every time they sell a product they are in business to sell. For example, if a retailer sells an oven, they are promising that the oven is in proper condition for sale because it will do what ovens are supposed to do—bake food at controlled temperatures selected by the buyer. If the oven does not heat, or if it heats without proper temperature control, then the oven is not fit for sale as an oven, and the implied warranty of merchantability would be breached. In such a case, the law requires the merchant to provide a remedy so that the buyer gets a working oven.

The implied warranty of merchantability is not a written warranty. It exists without a retailer saying or writing it, unlike an express warranty. A seller doesn't have to tell the customer that its product will work on a basic level, nor must they include it in a sales contract. Instead, the law creates this warranty for most consumer products on the market.

Under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) § 2-314, as adopted in state laws, this warranty guarantees that the product purchased will:

• Pass without objection in the trade by meeting general industry standards
• Be of uniform quality and quantity
• Be fit for its ordinary purposes, such as a microwave being fit to heat food
• Be adequately packaged and labelled
• Conform to its labels

The implied warranty of merchantability might not apply to all consumer purchases. Some states allow merchants to avoid this warranty by using disclaimers or selling the product "as is". In most states, the disclaimer must be visible in writing to be valid. The buyer must know that the warranty won't cover the product. A seller can do this by listing the product for sale as is in its advertisement or label.

Express warranties

While oral warranties are important, only written warranties on consumer products are covered by the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. This Act is the federal law governing warranties on consumer products, passed by Congress in 1975. It requires warrantors to provide detailed information about warranty coverage, enabling consumers to compare warranty coverage before purchasing.

Section 2-313 of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) covers express warranties. The UCC is the model for most state laws on consumer protection. It is important to note that express warranties are not "read into" sales contracts by state law but are instead explicitly offered by the merchant.

An example of an express warranty is a merchant promising that an appliance they are selling is in proper condition for sale and will perform its intended function, such as baking food at controlled temperatures. If the appliance fails to heat or heats without proper temperature control, the merchant has breached the express warranty, and the law requires them to provide a remedy to the customer.

Written warranties

The Act requires warrantors to meet specific standards and provide consumers with clear and concise warranty information. Written warranties must be titled as either "full" or "limited", with the coverage meeting federal minimum standards for comprehensive warranties. This distinction helps consumers understand the level of protection offered.

Additionally, warrantors must disclose specific information about the warranty coverage, including any limitations or restrictions. This information should be presented in a single, easy-to-read document to ensure consumers can make informed decisions.

The Act also addresses the pre-sale availability of written warranties, mandating that they are accessible to consumers before they make a purchase. Retailers are responsible for ensuring that written warranties are readily available, either by displaying them near the product or providing them upon request.

Moreover, the Act prohibits deceptive or misleading warranty terms. Warrantors cannot offer a warranty that appears to provide coverage but, in reality, provides none. For instance, a warranty covering only "moving parts" on an electronic product with no moving parts would be considered deceptive and unlawful.

In summary, written warranties are a vital aspect of consumer protection, ensuring that consumers have the necessary information to make informed purchases and understand their rights and protections under the law. The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act sets clear standards for written warranties, promoting transparency and fairness in the marketplace.

Unwritten warranties

There are two types of implied warranties: the warranty of merchantability and the warranty of fitness for a particular purpose. The warranty of merchantability is a basic promise that goods sold will do what they are supposed to do and that there is nothing significantly wrong with them. In other words, it is a guarantee that the goods are fit to be sold. This type of warranty exists in every sale made by a merchant who deals in such goods. For example, if you buy a toaster, the warranty of merchantability guarantees that it will toast your bread effectively without becoming a fire hazard.

The warranty of fitness for a particular purpose, on the other hand, is a promise that the seller makes when a customer relies on their advice about how to use a product. For instance, if a customer asks for a washing machine that can handle 15 pounds of laundry at a time, and the seller recommends a particular model, the seller is making a warranty of fitness for a particular purpose. If the recommended model cannot handle the specified load, the warranty is breached.

It is important to note that implied warranties are not a guarantee that a product will last for a specific length of time. They also do not cover problems arising from abuse, misuse, ordinary wear, failure to follow directions, or improper maintenance. In most states, sellers can disclaim implied warranties, but they must do so in a conspicuous manner, usually in writing.

State laws

The implied warranty of merchantability is not a written warranty and does not need to be included in a sales contract. It is based on the idea that the seller should know best whether a product will perform properly and encourages them to ensure product quality.

The implied warranty of merchantability covers both new and used goods, with used goods expected to function based on their current state. Merchants of used goods also give implied warranties.

To disclaim implied warranties, merchants must inform consumers in a clear and conspicuous manner, generally in writing, that they will not be responsible if the product malfunctions or is defective. However, this varies by state, and some states do not allow the sale of consumer products "as is".

In summary, state laws regarding the implied warranty of merchantability are based on the UCC and guarantee that goods sold will be fit for their intended purpose, meet quality standards, and be properly packaged and labelled. Merchants can disclaim implied warranties in most states but must do so in a clear and conspicuous manner.

Frequently asked questions