Tennessee's Anti-Evolution Law: The Scopes Trial

In 1925, John T. Scopes, a teacher in Dayton, Tennessee, was charged with violating Tennessee's Butler Act, which prohibited the teaching of human evolution in state-funded schools. The trial, known as the Scopes Trial, was a highly publicised and sensational case that attracted intense national publicity and media attention. Scopes was found guilty and fined $100, but the verdict was later overturned on a technicality. The trial sparked a debate between fundamentalists, who prioritised the word of God and the Bible, and modernists, who believed that evolution could be consistent with religion. It also raised questions about the constitutionality of the Butler Act and the separation of theology from scientific education.

John T. Scopes taught evolution in a Tennessee school

In 1925, John T. Scopes, a 24-year-old teacher at a public high school in Dayton, Tennessee, was indicted for teaching the theory of evolution in his science class. This was a violation of Tennessee's Butler Act, which prohibited the teaching of human evolution in state-funded schools.

The Butler Act, passed in March 1925, made it illegal to teach any theory contradicting the Biblical version of creation as presented in the Book of Genesis. While substituting as a biology teacher, Scopes used a textbook that promoted the theory of human evolution, introduced by English naturalist Charles Darwin in his 1871 book, 'The Descent of Man'.

The Scopes Trial, as it became known, was a highly publicised event, drawing intense national publicity and media attention. It was deliberately staged to attract attention to the small town of Dayton, Tennessee, where it was held. The trial was also broadcast live on the radio across the United States.

During the trial, Scopes urged his students to testify against him, and he was indicted when three students testified that he had taught evolution. Scopes himself was unsure whether he had actually taught evolution, but he incriminated himself deliberately so the case could have a defendant. He was charged with teaching evolution from a chapter in George William Hunter's textbook, 'Civic Biology: Presented in Problems' (1914), which described the theory of evolution, race, and eugenics.

The Scopes Trial became a cultural and intellectual clash between traditional values and contemporary science, and between rural fundamentalism and worldly urban sophistication. It was also seen as a theological contest and a trial on whether evolution should be taught in schools. The trial ended with Scopes being found guilty and fined $100, but the verdict was later overturned on a technicality.

The ultimate outcome of the trial was far-reaching. The Butler Act was never enforced again, and over the next two years, laws prohibiting the teaching of evolution were defeated in 22 states. The trial brought about a greater awareness of the need to separate the teaching of theology from scientific education, and anti-evolution laws became a laughingstock.

The Butler Act made teaching evolution illegal

The Butler Act, passed in Tennessee in March 1925, made it illegal for teachers to teach human evolution in any state-funded school. The Act was lobbied for by State Representative John Washington Butler, a Tennessee farmer and head of the World Christian Fundamentals Association.

The Act was passed into law by Tennessee governor Austin Peay, who believed it would neither be enforced nor interfere with education in the state's schools. The law stated that it was unlawful to teach:

> "...any theory that contradicts the Divine Creation of man as taught in the Bible, and instead teaches that man descended from a lower order of animals..."

The Act was passed in the context of a growing chasm in American Christianity between fundamentalists and modernists. The fundamentalists argued that the word of God as revealed in the Bible took priority over all human knowledge, while the modernists believed that evolution could be consistent with religion.

The Butler Act set off alarm bells across the country. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) responded by offering to defend any teacher prosecuted under the law. John Scopes, a young and popular high school science teacher, agreed to stand as a defendant in a test case to challenge the law. He was arrested on May 7, 1925, and charged with teaching the theory of evolution.

The Scopes trial, as it became known, was a watershed moment in American history and a litmus test for evolution education in public schools. The trial became a public spectacle, viewed by many as a cultural and intellectual clash between traditional values and contemporary science.

The trial ended with Scopes being found guilty and fined $100. However, the ultimate result of the trial was pronounced and far-reaching: the Butler Act was never enforced again and, over the next two years, laws prohibiting the teaching of evolution were defeated in 22 states. Americans largely viewed the religious fundamentalist cause as the loser in the trial and became more aware of the need to separate the teaching of theology from scientific education.

Scopes was fined $100

John T. Scopes was a teacher in Dayton, Tennessee, who was charged with violating Tennessee's Butler Act. This law prohibited the teaching of human evolution in Tennessee schools.

The trial, known as the Scopes Trial, began on July 10, 1925, and ended on July 21, 1925, with a verdict of guilty and a $100 fine for Scopes. This fine, which would be equivalent to $1737 in 2023, was a significant sum of money at the time. It is important to note that Scopes may have been innocent of the crime, as he later admitted to skipping the evolution lesson and coaching his students to testify against him.

The Scopes Trial attracted intense national publicity and media attention, with approximately 1000 people and over 100 newspapers packing the courtroom daily. It was the first trial to be broadcast live on the radio in the United States, and it brought attention to the small town of Dayton, Tennessee, where it was held. The trial also sparked a larger debate about the validity of Darwin's theory of evolution versus the authority of the Bible, with the defense arguing that the Butler Act itself was unconstitutional.

The Butler Act remained in effect until May 18, 1967, when it was repealed by the Tennessee legislature. The trial had a significant impact on Scopes' personal and professional life, and he later became a chemical engineer in the oil industry.

The Butler Act was never enforced again

The Butler Act, which was passed in March 1925, made it illegal to teach any theory that contradicted the Biblical version of creation as presented in the Book of Genesis. The Act also made it a misdemeanour for any educator to violate the law.

John T. Scopes, a 24-year-old teacher, was the defendant in the famous "Monkey Trial", indicted for teaching the theory of evolution in his high school science class. He was arrested on May 7, 1925, and charged with teaching the theory of evolution. The trial, which took place in July 1925, was the first ever to be broadcast live on the radio.

The trial was a showdown between evolution and the Church, with thousands of visitors, including journalists and prominent academics, pouring into the small town of Dayton, Tennessee, to witness the proceedings. The defence team, led by Clarence Darrow, made no attempt to maintain their client's innocence. Instead, they argued that the Butler Act itself was unconstitutional.

The jury found Scopes guilty of violating the Butler Act and he was fined $100. However, the ultimate result of the trial was pronounced and far-reaching: the Butler Act was never enforced again, and over the next two years, laws prohibiting the teaching of evolution were defeated in 22 states. Americans largely viewed the religious fundamentalist cause as the loser in the trial, and anti-evolution laws became the laughing stock of the country.

The Butler Act remained in effect until May 18, 1967, when it was repealed by the Tennessee legislature. In 1968, the Supreme Court ruled in Epperson v. Arkansas that such bans contravene the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment because their primary purpose is religious.

The trial was a clash of evolutionism versus creationism

The trial of John T. Scopes, known as the Scopes Monkey Trial, was a highly publicised and sensational legal case that took place in July 1925. It was a deliberate spectacle, staged to attract publicity to the small town of Dayton, Tennessee, where it was held.

The trial was a showdown between two opposing worldviews: rural fundamentalism and worldly urban sophistication. It brought together some of the biggest legal names in the nation, with Clarence Darrow serving as the defence attorney for Scopes, and William Jennings Bryan, a three-time presidential candidate and former secretary of state, arguing for the prosecution.

The defence team, led by Darrow, did not attempt to maintain Scopes' innocence of the charges. Instead, they argued that the Butler Act itself was unconstitutional. As a result, the trial became a larger debate over the validity of Darwin's theory of evolution versus the authority of the Bible. Darrow took the unusual step of calling Bryan, his opponent, to the stand as an expert on the Bible, and publicly humiliated him by questioning his literal interpretation of the Bible.

The trial ended with Scopes being found guilty and fined $100, but the verdict was later overturned on a technicality. The ultimate result of the trial was far-reaching: the Butler Act was never enforced again, and over the next two years, laws prohibiting the teaching of evolution were defeated in 22 states. The trial brought to the fore the need to legally separate the teaching of theology from scientific education.

Frequently asked questions