Tucker's Legal Troubles: What Laws Did He Break?

Scott Tucker is an American businessman and former race car driver who was convicted of multiple felonies, including racketeering, mail fraud, and making false statements to a bank. Tucker's illegal activities centred around a payday lending scheme that exploited loopholes in state lending laws and charged illegal interest rates, defrauding millions of customers. He was sentenced to 16 years and 8 months in federal prison for his crimes.

Racketeering, business and payday loans

Scott Tucker was convicted of racketeering, a form of fraud that involves running an illegal enterprise through a pattern of extortion, threats, or other forms of force or fraud. In Tucker's case, he was found guilty of running a payday lending enterprise that exploited legal loopholes to charge illegal interest rates as high as 1000%.

Payday loans are a form of short-term, high-interest, unsecured loans, usually issued in small amounts and meant to be repaid on the customer's next paycheck. While these loans can provide quick funds for urgent or unexpected expenses, they often come with extremely high interest rates and fees, making them a risky option for borrowers.

Tucker's payday lending enterprise, which operated under names such as Ameriloan, Cash Advance, and United Cash Loans, charged undisclosed and inflated fees, with interest rates as high as 700% per year. These loans were often issued to low-income individuals who were struggling to pay basic living expenses, and in many cases, the loans were made in states where such high-interest loans were restricted or illegal.

To evade state regulations and continue his illegal business, Tucker devised a scheme to claim that his lending businesses were protected by sovereign immunity by forming partnerships with Native American tribes. He entered into agreements with several tribes, including the Santee Sioux Tribe of Nebraska and the Miami Tribe of Oklahoma, and claimed that his businesses were owned and operated by these tribes. In reality, Tucker continued to own and control the businesses, reaping the profits while hiding behind the tribes' sovereign immunity.

In addition to racketeering, Tucker was also convicted of wire fraud, money laundering, and Truth-In-Lending Act (TILA) offenses. He was sentenced to 16 years and 8 months in federal prison.

Fraudulent loan disclosures

Scott Tucker was convicted of several charges, including fraudulent loan disclosures, in October 2017.

TILA (Truth in Lending Act) is a federal statute that ensures credit terms are disclosed to consumers in a clear and meaningful way. It protects customers from inaccurate and unfair credit practices and enables them to compare credit terms.

TILA requires lenders to disclose the finance charge, the annual percentage rate, and the total of payments that reflect the legal obligation between the parties to the loan.

Tucker's payday lending businesses, which operated under names like Ameriloan and OneClickCash, claimed to inform borrowers of the cost of the loan in a clear and simple manner as required by TILA. For example, for a loan of $500, the "finance charge" would be $150, and the "total of payments" would be $650. However, in reality, Tucker and his co-defendant, Timothy Muir, structured the repayment schedule to automatically withdraw only the interest payment on the borrower's payday, leaving the principal balance untouched. This process continued for several pay periods, with none of the money going towards repaying the principal. As a result, the total amount paid by the borrower was significantly higher than the disclosed amount in the TILA box. For the $500 loan example, the actual finance charge was $1,425, resulting in a total payment of $1,925.

By understating the true cost of the loans, Tucker and Muir defrauded borrowers out of hundreds or thousands of dollars each.

Sham tribal ownership

Scott Tucker is an American convicted racketeer, loan shark, fraudster, and money launderer. He was convicted of 14 counts, including making illegal payday loans and racketeering. He is currently serving a sentence of 16 years and 8 months in federal prison.

Tucker's payday lending business, which generated over $3.5 billion in revenue from 2008 to June 2013, made loans to at least 4.5 million Americans. When state regulators tried to shut down his operations, Tucker entered into agreements with several Native American tribes, including the Santee Sioux Tribe of Nebraska, the Miami Tribe of Oklahoma, and the Modoc Tribe of Oklahoma. The purpose of these agreements was to cause the tribes to claim they owned and operated parts of Tucker's payday lending enterprise, so that when states sought to enforce laws prohibiting Tucker's loans, his lending businesses would claim to be protected by sovereign immunity. In return, the tribes received payments from Tucker, typically one percent of the revenues from the portion of Tucker's payday lending business that the tribes purported to own.

To create the illusion that the tribes owned and controlled Tucker's payday lending business, Tucker and his co-defendant, Timothy Muir, an attorney, engaged in a series of lies and deceptions. Among other things, they prepared false factual declarations from tribal representatives that were submitted to state courts, falsely claiming that tribal corporations substantively owned, controlled, and managed the portions of Tucker's business targeted by state enforcement actions. Tucker also opened bank accounts to operate and receive the profits of the payday lending enterprise, which were nominally held by tribally owned corporations but which were, in fact, owned and controlled by Tucker.

These deceptions succeeded for a time, and several state courts dismissed enforcement actions against Tucker's payday lending businesses based on claims that they were protected by sovereign immunity. However, in reality, the tribes neither owned nor operated any part of Tucker's payday lending business. The tribes made no payment to Tucker to acquire the portions of the business they purported to own, and Tucker continued to operate his lending business from a corporate headquarters in Kansas, reaping the profits of the payday lending businesses.

Money laundering

Tucker was the CEO of AMG Services, a payday loan company that charged undisclosed and inflated fees. He also owned several other payday loan companies, including Ameriloan, Cash Advance, and United Cash Loans. These companies made payday loans to individuals in states where such loans were restricted or illegal.

To conceal the true nature of his business, Tucker entered into agreements with several Native American tribes, including the Santee Sioux Tribe of Nebraska and the Miami Tribe of Oklahoma. He claimed that his lending businesses were owned and operated by these tribes, allowing him to invoke sovereign immunity and avoid state laws. In reality, Tucker continued to own and control the businesses, reaping the profits.

Tucker used various deceptive tactics to create the illusion that the tribes owned and operated his lending companies. He opened bank accounts in the names of tribally-owned corporations, but he actually owned and controlled these accounts, using the funds for personal expenses such as luxury cars, a private jet, and a vacation home. Additionally, employees of Tucker's companies were instructed to tell borrowers that they were operating in states where the tribes were located, when in fact, they were operating out of Kansas.

Tucker's money laundering activities allowed him to conceal the true nature and source of his income from payday lending operations, which were often illegal and exploitative in nature. By laundering money through tribal accounts, he was able to evade law enforcement and continue his predatory business practices for many years.

Tax fraud

Scott Tucker, a Kansas-based businessman and race car driver, was convicted of tax fraud in 2022. The conviction was related to his failure to report income from his payday lending business, which was operated through various shell companies and affiliated with Native American tribes.

Tucker's tax fraud was part of a larger scheme to evade state laws and regulations governing the payday lending industry. He was found guilty of filing a false or fraudulent tax return with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) in 2010, reporting substantially less income than he actually earned. Tucker owned a professional auto racing business called Level 5 Sports, which he used as a front for his illegal activities.

In addition to his tax fraud conviction, Tucker was also found guilty of racketeering, wire fraud, money laundering, and violating the Truth-In-Lending Act (TILA). He was sentenced to a total of 200 months in prison, including a 36-month sentence specifically for tax fraud, to be served concurrently with his other convictions. He was also ordered to pay $40 million in restitution to the IRS.

The investigation into Tucker's financial dealings revealed a complex web of shell companies, false associations with Native American tribes, and deceptive practices aimed at exploiting regulatory loopholes and avoiding taxes. Tucker's payday lending business generated over $3.5 billion in revenue from 2008 to 2013, charging exorbitant interest rates of up to 1,000% on loans to struggling individuals across the United States.

Frequently asked questions