Gas Pump Installation: Understanding Legal Requirements And Compliance

In the United States, there are laws that dictate who can pump gas and where. New Jersey is the only state that bans self-service gas stations, with a law dating back to 1949. This means that gas station owners can be fined up to $250 for a first offence and up to $500 for subsequent violations if drivers are caught handling the pump. Oregon recently lifted its 72-year ban on self-service gas stations, leaving New Jersey as the last state with this restriction.

New Jersey is the only state with a full ban on self-service gas stations

In the United States, laws regarding the installation and operation of gas pumps fall under the jurisdiction of individual states. Notably, New Jersey is the only state that maintains a full ban on self-service gas stations, requiring a professional to pump gasoline for customers. This unique characteristic has earned New Jersey the nickname the "mecca of full-service gas retailers."

The origin of this ban can be traced back to the middle of the 20th century, specifically the year 1949, when the New Jersey state legislature passed the Retail Gasoline Dispensing Safety Act. This statute prohibited gas retail customers from pumping their own gas, citing safety concerns such as fire hazards and rising costs to consumers as the primary reasons for implementing the ban. The law was also influenced by the interests of smaller gas station owners who wanted to protect themselves from the competition of larger mega gas stations that relied on self-service to be profitable.

Over the years, there have been several attempts to overturn the ban in New Jersey, but all efforts have been unsuccessful. The issue of self-service gas has become a "political third rail" in the state, with many politicians, including Gov. Phil Murphy, avoiding taking a stance on it. Additionally, public opinion polls show that a majority of New Jersey residents oppose a policy change to allow self-service gas stations.

While New Jersey is the only state with a complete ban, there are a few other states that have had similar restrictions in the past. Oregon, for example, had a long-standing ban on self-service gas stations until recently when it was lifted for counties with populations of less than 40,000 residents. Even with this change, Oregon still has stricter laws than most states, and some parts of the state continue to have full-service gas stations.

In summary, New Jersey's full ban on self-service gas stations is a unique aspect of the state's culture and has been a topic of legislative debate and public interest for several decades. With a combination of safety concerns, historical factors, and political dynamics at play, New Jersey remains the only state in the U.S. where drivers are legally prohibited from pumping their own gas.

Oregon recently lifted its ban on self-service gas stations

Oregon recently lifted its 72-year ban on self-service gas stations, allowing customers to pump their own gas. The new law, House Bill 2426, was signed by Governor Tina Kotek in August 2023 and took effect immediately. Oregon had previously been one of only two states, the other being New Jersey, with a full-service law that prohibited self-service at gas stations.

The new law does not completely phase out full service in Oregon's most populous counties. It requires that no more than half of the pumps at any service station be self-serve, and that at least one gas station employee be available at all times to assist customers who need or prefer full service. This change aims to address the challenges faced by rural gas station operators in hiring enough attendants and ensures that customers have the option of self-service or full service.

The debate around self-service gas in Oregon has been ongoing for years, with some arguing that it would provide more convenience and flexibility, especially during labour shortages. Others raised concerns about safety, citing the risk of accidents due to slippery surfaces during rainy weather, and the potential for careless customers to create dangerous situations. Additionally, opponents of the bill worried about potential job losses for gas station attendants and the impact on vulnerable communities, including older adults and people with disabilities, who may face challenges in accessing self-service options.

While the law now permits self-service in Oregon, full-service options will still be available at many stations, ensuring that customers have a choice based on their preferences and needs. This change brings Oregon in line with most other states in the US, where self-service gas stations are the norm.

Gas stations in Oregon can be fined for allowing self-service

In Oregon, gas stations can be fined for allowing self-service, with the State Fire Marshal imposing fines of up to $500 per instance of a customer pumping their own gas. This is, however, a rare occurrence. These fines are based on a complaint system, and the money collected goes to the Oregon State Fire Marshal's general fund. The law in Oregon is not as strict as in New Jersey, which is the only state that requires professional attendants at gas stations.

Oregon's law regarding self-service gas stations has evolved over time. In 2019, Oregon still banned self-service gas statewide, except for diesel customers and motorcycle and motorized scooter riders. In less populated counties, self-service was also allowed. However, in 2023, Oregon Gov. Tina Kotek signed a bill to legalize self-service gas statewide, leaving the decision to offer self-service to the gas station owners. This means that while self-service is now legal in Oregon, individual gas stations are not required to offer it, and drivers do not have the right to demand self-service at any station.

The bill, HB 2426, states that the number of self-service pumps at a gas station cannot be higher than the number of pumps run by attendants. Gas stations offering a mix of self-service and attendant service must clearly label the pumps and cannot charge different prices for the two services. In urban counties, gas stations must continue to offer attendant service on at least half of their pumps during all hours of operation. In contrast, rural stations are exempt from this rule and can operate almost entirely as self-service, except when an on-site convenience store is present during daytime hours.

While the law now allows for self-service in Oregon, the state's history and the current legislation show a continued emphasis on the option of attendant service, particularly in more populated areas.

Full-service gas stations lobbied for self-service bans in the 1940s

In the United States, the laws that apply to installing a gas pump can vary at the state level, with some states imposing bans on self-service gas stations. Notably, full-service gas stations lobbied for self-service bans in the 1940s to protect their interests against the emergence of mega gas stations that relied on self-service to be profitable. This lobbying effort resulted in the Retail Gasoline Dispensing Safety Act, passed by the New Jersey state legislature in 1949, which prohibited customers from pumping their own gas.

The history of self-service gas stations in the US is a fascinating one, with the concept first emerging in 1947 when a Los Angeles station owner named Frank Ulrich opened the first self-service filling station. This new business model offered cost savings for both station owners and customers, as owners needed fewer attendants, and customers were incentivized with lower gas prices. However, the introduction of self-service stations threatened the existence of full-service gas stations, which relied on providing various services such as oil and battery checks, windshield wiping, and vehicle repairs to make a profit.

Fearing that the cheaper self-service model would undercut their prices, full-service gas station owners lobbied state legislators in the 1940s to pass bans on self-service, citing safety concerns and the potential for rising costs to consumers. By playing up the safety hazards of untrained drivers overfilling their tanks and causing fires, full-service stations gained the support of local fire marshals, which led to the passage of self-service bans in multiple states. By 1968, putting fuel in your own car was banned in 23 states.

However, as full-service stations lost their dominance in the auto service and repair market in the 1970s and 1980s, their position on self-service began to change. They recognized that self-service could reduce labor costs and increase fuel sales, and they also diversified into selling food, tobacco, coffee, and other items with higher profit margins. As a result, operators started pushing states to repeal their self-service bans. By 1992, around 80% of all gas stations nationwide were self-service, a significant shift from just 8% two decades prior.

Despite these changes, a handful of states, notably New Jersey and Oregon, have maintained their self-service bans, with New Jersey being the only state that still requires a professional to pump gasoline. These bans have become part of the culture and a source of pride for many residents, as evidenced by New Jersey's popular bumper sticker, "Jersey Girls Don't Pump Gas." While there have been frequent legislative attempts to lift these bans, they have faced strong opposition and are considered a "political third rail" by politicians.

Self-service gas stations are cheaper to operate

In the United States, self-service gas stations are cheaper to operate than full-service stations. As of November 2024, New Jersey is the only state that prohibits customers from pumping their own gas. This is due to a 1949 statute called the Retail Gasoline Dispensing Safety Act, which was passed to protect the interests of smaller gas station owners and address safety concerns. However, there have been recent struggles to hire workers, leading to renewed attempts to lift the ban in New Jersey.

The cost of operating a self-service gas station is lower as there is no need to employ attendants to pump gas for customers. This reduction in labour costs can result in higher profits for gas station owners. Additionally, self-service stations can increase the amount of fuel sold as customers can refuel their vehicles more efficiently without having to wait for an attendant.

Furthermore, self-service gas stations can diversify their offerings by selling food, tobacco, coffee, snacks, and other items with higher profit margins. This additional revenue stream can further reduce the operating costs of the gas station.

While some states, like Oregon, have recently lifted their self-service gas station bans, New Jersey's ban remains in place due to cultural and safety reasons. However, with the changing landscape of the industry, it is unclear how long this ban will remain in effect, especially as gas stations face challenges in hiring enough workers.

In conclusion, self-service gas stations have a clear economic advantage over full-service stations due to reduced labour costs, increased fuel sales, and the potential for additional revenue streams. While New Jersey currently upholds its full-service law, the trend towards self-service stations across the country may eventually reach this lone holdout state.

Frequently asked questions