Rebellion Losses Bill: A Historical Law's Journey

The Rebellion Losses Bill became law on April 25, 1849, when it was signed by Governor General Lord Elgin. The bill was enacted to compensate Lower Canadians who lost property during the Rebellions of 1837-38, with measures similar to those providing compensation in Upper Canada. The enactment of the bill sparked violent disturbances in Montreal, known as the Montreal Riots, which culminated in the burning of the Parliament building on the same day the bill was signed.

The Rebellion Losses Bill was enacted to compensate Lower Canadians who lost property during the Rebellions of 1837-38

The Rebellion Losses Bill was a controversial law enacted by the legislature of the Province of Canada in 1849. It was designed to compensate Lower Canadians who lost property during the Rebellions of 1837-38, with measures similar to those providing compensation in Upper Canada. The bill's passage and subsequent assent by the Governor General, Lord Elgin, marked a landmark in Canadian political history, affirming the concept of responsible government in the colony.

The bill's origins can be traced back to February 1845, when the Legislative Assembly adopted an address requesting Governor Metcalfe to compensate Lower Canadians for property losses during the armed conflict of 1837-38. However, no funds were disbursed due to an empty provincial treasury. In 1846, a report estimated the rebellion losses in Lower Canada at approximately £100,000.

In February 1849, Louis-Hippolyte Lafontaine, co-leader of Canada's Reform government, introduced the Rebellion Losses Bill in the legislature. Lafontaine envisioned the bill as a means to foster reconciliation and empower French Canadians in the political landscape. The bill authorised total payments of £90,000 in compensation.

The bill faced fierce opposition from the Tories, who argued that it rewarded rebels and signalled French domination in the union. They perceived it as a concession to disloyalty and a threat to their political power. The controversy intensified with physical violence and duels between opposing members of parliament.

Despite the intense opposition, the bill was passed by the Reform-dominated legislature. It was then submitted to Lord Elgin for assent, sparking further outrage among English-speaking Canadians who urged him to reject it. On April 25, 1849, Lord Elgin, committed to the principle of responsible government, signed the bill into law. This decision was met with violent riots in Montreal, where his carriage was attacked, and the Parliament building was burned down.

The Rebellion Losses Bill stands as a pivotal moment in Canadian history, solidifying the notion of responsible government and shaping the country's political infrastructure.

The bill was controversial as it was seen as giving money to the rebels

The Rebellion Losses Bill was a controversial law enacted by the legislature of the Province of Canada in 1849. The bill was introduced by Louis LaFontaine in February 1849 to compensate Lower Canadians whose property had been damaged during the Rebellions of 1837-38. The bill was based on Upper Canadian legislation and was designed to heal the wounds of the rebellion and promote equality and power for French Canadians in the Canadas.

However, the bill was highly controversial and seen as giving money to the rebels. This perception was shaped by two factors. Firstly, sympathy for the Rebellion was more widespread in Lower Canada, so compensation in this region was viewed as rewarding the rebels. Secondly, the army's damage far exceeded that of the rebels, so providing compensation for damages caused by the army was considered an act of disloyalty to the Crown.

The Tories, traditionally associated with people of British descent, strongly opposed the bill, arguing that it rewarded individuals who had committed treason just a decade earlier. They urged Lord Elgin, the Governor General, to reject the bill. However, despite his personal misgivings, Lord Elgin assented to the bill on April 25, 1849, respecting the principles of the new system of responsible government.

The passage of the Rebellion Losses Bill angered Montreal's Tory citizens, sparking violent disturbances known as the Montreal Riots. The unrest culminated in the burning of the Parliament building in Montreal on the same day the bill became law. The rioting lasted for two days, causing thousands of dollars in damage and underscoring the deep divisions and remaining prejudices in the aftermath of the 1837-38 Rebellions.

The bill's enactment provoked weeks of violent disturbances known as the Montreal Riots

The Rebellion Losses Bill was a controversial law enacted by the legislature of the Province of Canada in 1849. The bill was designed to compensate Lower Canadians who had lost property during the Rebellions of 1837-1838. However, its enactment angered some of Montreal's Tory citizens, sparking weeks of violent unrest known as the Montreal Riots.

The bill's passage and subsequent royal assent were seen as a landmark affirmation of responsible government in the colony. Governor General James Bruce, the 8th Earl of Elgin, gave royal assent to the bill on April 25, 1849, despite his own misgivings and pressure from Tories to reject it. This decision angered Montreal's English-speaking population, who saw it as a sign of French domination and a loss of power for the Tories.

On the evening of April 25, the public protest escalated into a full-scale riot. Thousands of people participated in the riot, which lasted for two days. The rioters threw stones and rotten eggs at Lord Elgin's carriage and eventually invaded and set fire to the Parliament building. The riots also included attacks on the private property of several Reform leaders, including LaFontaine and Hincks.

The Montreal Riots occurred during a period of serious economic and political crisis in the Province of Canada. The Reformers had formed the government, while the Tories, who were largely Anglophones and supported British rule and economic ties with Britain, were relegated to the opposition. Montreal, the capital city with a bilingual population, was a focal point of resentment and tension.

The bill was introduced by Louis LaFontaine in February 1849

The Rebellion Losses Bill was introduced by Louis LaFontaine in February 1849. LaFontaine was a Canadian politician who served as the first Premier of the United Province of Canada and the first head of a responsible government in Canada. He was born in Boucherville, Lower Canada, in 1807 and was a jurist and statesman. LaFontaine was first elected to the Legislative Assembly of Lower Canada in 1830.

The Rebellion Losses Bill was modelled on Upper Canadian legislation and aimed to compensate Lower Canadians whose property had been damaged during the Rebellions of 1837-38. The bill totalled approximately £100,000 and was similar to legislation for Upper Canada. LaFontaine viewed the bill as a symbolic means to heal the wounds of the rebellion and strengthen French Canadian claims to equality and power in the Canadas by testing the strength of responsible government. He believed that the growing influence of Louis-Joseph Papineau could be curbed in this way.

The bill was introduced following the general election of January 1848, which changed the composition of the House of Assembly in favour of the opposition party, the moderate reformists led by Robert Baldwin and Louis-Hippolyte Lafontaine. On January 29, 1849, Lafontaine moved to form a committee of the whole House on February 9 to address the losses incurred by certain inhabitants in Lower Canada during the political troubles of 1837 and 1838, and to provide for their compensation. The debates surrounding the bill were intense and, at times, led to physical violence. The opposition party denounced the bill as "paying the rebels" and proposed various amendments to delay or prevent its passage.

Despite the opposition, the bill was eventually passed by the Legislative Assembly on March 9, 1849, with a vote of 47 to 18. It was then approved by the Legislative Council on March 15, 1849, with a vote of 20 to 14. The bill became law when it received royal assent from Governor General James Bruce, the 8th Earl of Elgin, on April 25, 1849. This assent was significant as it affirmed the principle of responsible government in the Province of Canada.

The bill was signed into law by Governor General Lord Elgin on April 25, 1849

The Rebellion Losses Bill was signed into law by Governor General Lord Elgin on April 25, 1849. The bill was enacted to compensate Lower Canadians who had lost property during the Rebellions of 1837-1838. The bill was modelled on Upper Canadian legislation and was introduced by Louis LaFontaine in February 1849. The total compensation amounted to approximately £100,000.

The passage of the bill was controversial. While it was supported by LaFontaine's majority government and passed with a majority of votes in the House of Assembly, it was opposed by the Tories, who saw it as a reward for rebels and a sign of French domination of the union. The bill's enactment angered some of Montreal's Tory citizens, who saw it as an insult to "loyal" subjects and an act of disloyalty to the Crown.

Despite his misgivings about the bill, Lord Elgin understood the significance of local responsibility and signed it into law. He was committed to upholding the decision of the elected assembly, even in the face of intense pressure to veto the law. Elgin's decision was a triumph for Canada's fledgling democracy but sparked violent opposition from English-speaking mobs in Montreal, who attacked his carriage and set fire to the Parliament building.

The Rebellion Losses Bill was a landmark piece of legislation in Canadian political history. It established the principle of responsible government in the Province of Canada and demonstrated that Canada had achieved self-governance. The bill's passage also confirmed the acceptance of French as an official language of Parliament.

Frequently asked questions