The Uncertainty Of Physics Laws: When Do They Not Apply?

Scientific laws are statements based on repeated experiments or observations that describe or predict a range of natural phenomena. Physics laws are considered fundamental, though many refer to idealized or theoretical systems that are hard to replicate in the real world. These laws are based on empirical observations and experiments that are repeated under different conditions to reach inferences accepted worldwide. However, the question of whether these laws are truly universal and unchanging is an intriguing one. While the cosmos has played by the same rules since the Big Bang, it is not entirely implausible to consider that the laws could have been different in the past or might change in the future. The mutability of physical laws remains a subject of ongoing investigation, with physicists scrutinizing the rulebook for clues about potential changes at a level beyond our current perception.

Laws derived from symmetry principles

Spacetime and other symmetries result in mathematical consequences that are approximated to create fundamental physical laws. For instance, when the symmetry of time shifts, the conservation of energy is born as a consequence. The symmetry of space gives birth to the conservation of momentum.

The speed of light is the same in all frames of reference, as described in special relativity by a group of transformations of spacetime known as the Poincaré group. This is an example of a physical law derived from a symmetry principle.

In physics, a symmetry is a physical or mathematical feature of a system that remains unchanged under some transformation. For example, a uniform sphere rotated about its centre will appear exactly as it did before the rotation. This is called spherical symmetry.

Symmetries are frequently amenable to mathematical formulations and can be used to simplify problems. They are the foundation for the fundamental theories of modern physics.

Symmetries can be classified as global or local. A global symmetry is one that keeps a property invariant for a transformation that is applied simultaneously at all points of spacetime. A local symmetry is one that keeps a property invariant when a possibly different symmetry transformation is applied at each point of spacetime.

Continuous symmetries can be described by Lie groups, while discrete symmetries are described by finite groups.

The Standard Model of particle physics has three related natural near-symmetries:

• C-symmetry (charge symmetry), where every particle is replaced with its antiparticle.
• P-symmetry (parity symmetry), where everything is mirrored along the three physical axes.
• T-symmetry (time-reversal symmetry), where the direction of time is reversed.

These are near-symmetries because each is broken in the present-day universe. However, the Standard Model predicts that the simultaneous application of all three transformations (known as CPT symmetry) must be a symmetry.

Laws due to mathematical symmetries

The symmetries found in nature, such as the rotational symmetry of space-time, are reflected in the laws of physics. For example, the Lorentz transformation reflects the rotational symmetry of space-time, the conservation laws reflect the homogeneity of space, and the Pauli exclusion principle reflects the uniqueness of electrons.

The homogeneity of space and time gives rise to the conservation of momentum and energy, respectively. The invariance of physical laws under arbitrary differentiable coordinate transformations is an important idea in general relativity.

The speed of light, for instance, remains constant in all frames of reference, as described in special relativity by the Poincaré group. This is an example of a continuous symmetry, which can be described mathematically by Lie groups. On the other hand, discrete symmetries, such as reflection of a bilaterally symmetric figure, are described by finite groups.

Symmetries can be classified as global or local. A global symmetry is one that preserves a property when a transformation is applied simultaneously at all points in spacetime. In contrast, a local symmetry keeps a property invariant when a possibly different symmetry transformation is applied at each spacetime point.

The fundamental theories of modern physics, such as the Standard Model, are based on these mathematical symmetries. The study of symmetry in physics has led to important discoveries and a deeper understanding of the natural world.

Laws derived from definitions

A few laws of physics are derived from mathematical definitions. For example, the uncertainty principle, the principle of stationary action, or causality. These laws are not purely mathematical, as they are empirical and explain what we perceive through our senses. They are derived from repeated experiments or observations and describe or predict a range of natural phenomena.

The uncertainty principle, for instance, is a consequence of the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics, where the position and momentum of a particle cannot be simultaneously determined with perfect accuracy. This principle is not a mathematical theorem but an empirical observation that has been validated through experiments.

The principle of stationary action is another example of a law derived from a definition. It states that the true path of a physical system is the one that minimises the action, which is a quantity that combines the system's kinetic and potential energy. This principle provides a powerful framework for understanding classical and quantum mechanics and is derived from the calculus of variations.

Causality, or cause and effect, is a fundamental concept in physics that underlies many laws. It implies that there is a causal relationship between the elements of a physical system, and changes in one element will affect the others. This concept is essential for understanding how forces, such as gravity, or external factors influence the behaviour of objects.

These laws, derived from definitions, provide a foundation for understanding the natural world and the behaviour of everything from subatomic particles to celestial bodies. They are subject to ongoing scrutiny and refinement as new observations and experiments provide further insights.

Laws derived from approximations

Physical laws are conclusions drawn from scientific observations and experiments. They are continuously validated by the scientific community over time. Sometimes, general laws are modified or changed to form some of the physical laws. For example, Special Relativity under low-speed approximations is Newtonian dynamics. Newtonian dynamics is based on Sir Isaac Newton's groundbreaking work in physics, first published in 1687 in his book "The Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy," commonly known as "The Principia." In this book, Newton outlined his three laws of motion and his physical law of gravity.

Another example of a law derived from approximation is General Relativity in a low mass approximation, which is Newtonian Gravitation. When a situation that factors in large distances comes into play, Quantum Electrodynamics is approximated into Coulomb's law. Coulomb's law states that the force between two point charges is directly proportional to the magnitude of each charge and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between their centres.

In addition to these examples, there are other techniques and methods that involve the use of approximations to solve physics problems. These include the Method of Successive Approximations, assuming that the change is small, and using linear approximations.

The Method of Successive Approximations involves assuming an approximate value for a variable that simplifies an equation, solving for the variable, and then using the answer as the next approximate value to solve the equation again. This process is repeated until a constant value for the variable is obtained.

Assuming that the change is small is another technique used in solving equilibrium problems. This approach is applicable when K and Q, the reaction quotient and the equilibrium constant, are very close in size or lie on opposite sides, with one being much larger or smaller than the other. By making certain assumptions, such as 100% conversion into products or reactants, the change in concentration can be calculated.

Linear approximations are used when we want to find the tangent line to a function. The tangent line can be used as an approximation to the function near a specific point. For example, in optics, the linear approximation of sin(x) ≈ x for small x is often used to simplify formulas.

Laws of thermodynamics

The laws of physics are fundamental, but they refer to idealized or theoretical systems that are challenging to replicate in the real world. Physics laws are stated facts deduced and derived from empirical observations. They are conclusions drawn from years of scientific observations and experiments repeated under different conditions.

The laws of thermodynamics are a set of scientific laws that define a group of physical quantities, such as temperature, energy, and entropy, that characterize thermodynamic systems in thermodynamic equilibrium. They are specific manifestations of the law of conservation of mass-energy as it relates to thermodynamic processes. The laws of thermodynamics are as follows:

Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics

The Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics defines thermal equilibrium and forms the basis for the definition of temperature. It states that if two systems are each in thermal equilibrium with a third system, they are in thermal equilibrium with each other. This law makes the notion of temperature possible.

First Law of Thermodynamics

The First Law of Thermodynamics demonstrates the relationship between internal energy, added heat, and work within a system. It is a version of the law of conservation of energy, stating that when energy passes into or out of a system, the system's internal energy changes in accordance with the law of conservation of energy. In a closed system, the change in a system's internal energy is equal to the difference between the heat added to the system and the work done by the system on its surroundings.

Second Law of Thermodynamics

The Second Law of Thermodynamics relates to the natural flow of heat within a closed system. It states that in a natural thermodynamic process, the sum of the entropies of the interacting thermodynamic systems never decreases. This implies that heat does not spontaneously pass from a colder body to a warmer body. This law indicates the irreversibility of natural processes and the tendency of natural processes to lead towards spatial homogeneity of matter and energy.

Third Law of Thermodynamics

The Third Law of Thermodynamics states that it is impossible to create a perfectly efficient thermodynamic process. It also states that a system's entropy approaches a constant value as the temperature approaches absolute zero. This implies that as a system approaches absolute zero, it becomes increasingly difficult to extract energy from it.

Frequently asked questions