Mendel's Law Of Dominance: When It Fails

Mendel's Law of Dominance states that in a heterozygote, one trait will conceal the presence of another trait for the same characteristic. However, since Mendel's experiments with pea plants, researchers have found that this law does not always hold true. Mendel's law is not applicable to all living organisms, as it is only valid for diploid organisms and those that undergo sexual reproduction. In addition, dominance is not the only mode of inheritance, as other modes such as blending inheritance have been discovered. Furthermore, dominance does not occur in all contrasting characters, and conditions of co-dominance or incomplete dominance may take place.

The law is not applicable to all living organisms

Mendel's Law of Dominance states that, in heterozygotes, one trait will conceal the presence of another trait for the same characteristic. In other words, the dominant allele will be expressed exclusively, while the recessive allele will remain hidden but will still be transmitted to offspring. Mendel's laws of dominance are based on the work of Gregor Mendel, who studied the inheritance of traits in pea plants.

However, the law of dominance does not apply to all living organisms. It is only valid for diploid organisms and those that undergo sexual reproduction. Mendel himself warned that his patterns might not apply to other organisms or traits. Many organisms have traits whose inheritance works differently from the principles he outlined. These traits are called non-Mendelian.

For example, Mendel focused on traits with only two alleles, but many genes have multiple alleles. He also focused on traits determined by a single gene, but some traits, like height, depend on multiple genes. These are called polygenic traits.

In addition, dominance does not occur in the case of all contrasting characters. There are cases of codominance or incomplete dominance. For example, a cross between two four o'clock (Mirabilis jalapa) plants shows an exception to Mendel's principle, called incomplete dominance. The flowers of heterozygous plants have a phenotype somewhere between the two homozygous genotypes.

Furthermore, while Mendel's laws form the basis of classical genetics, new experiments on genetics have revealed that other patterns of inheritance exist. More complex forms of inheritance have been discovered, and dominance is not inherent. One allele can be dominant over a second allele, recessive to a third, and codominant to a fourth.

There are different modes of inheritance

Gregor Mendel's work on the inheritance of traits in pea plants led to the formulation of his laws of inheritance, which include the law of dominance, the law of segregation, and the law of independent assortment. Mendel's law of dominance states that when an organism has two different alleles for a trait, the dominant allele will be expressed, and the recessive allele will be masked. However, this law has some limitations and does not always hold true. There are different modes of inheritance that have been discovered and studied.

Different Modes of Inheritance:

While Mendel's laws of inheritance provide a foundational understanding of genetics, they do not encompass all possible modes of inheritance. Here are some of the different modes of inheritance that have been identified:

• Blending Inheritance: This mode of inheritance suggests that traits from both parents blend together to create a new phenotype in the offspring. This theory was proposed before Mendel's work and has since been disproven, but it represents an alternative mode of inheritance.
• Codominance: In some cases, both alleles in a heterozygote can be expressed simultaneously, resulting in an intermediate phenotype. This is known as codominance. For example, in humans, the ABO blood group system involves codominance, where both the A and B alleles are expressed together, resulting in type AB blood.
• Incomplete Dominance: In contrast to complete dominance, where the dominant allele completely masks the recessive allele, incomplete dominance occurs when the heterozygote displays an intermediate phenotype between the two homozygous genotypes. An example of this is seen in four o'clock plants, where the flowers of heterozygous plants have a phenotype that is a blend of the two homozygous genotypes.
• Multiple Alleles: Mendel primarily focused on traits with two alleles, such as "A" and "a". However, many genes have more than two alleles. For example, the ABO blood group system in humans has three alleles: A, B, and O.
• Polygenic Inheritance: Some traits are influenced by multiple genes rather than just one. These are known as polygenic traits. Height in humans is an example of a polygenic trait, as it is determined by the interaction of multiple genes.
• Non-Mendelian Inheritance: Mendel himself acknowledged that his laws might not apply universally to all organisms or traits. Non-Mendelian inheritance refers to traits that do not follow Mendel's principles, such as those determined by multiple genes or exhibiting different patterns of dominance.

These different modes of inheritance highlight the complexity of genetics and the various ways in which traits can be passed down from one generation to the next. They also demonstrate the ongoing evolution of our understanding of genetics since Mendel's pioneering work in the 19th century.

Dominance doesn't occur in all contrasting characters

Mendel's Law of Dominance states that in a heterozygote, one trait will conceal the presence of another trait for the same characteristic. The dominant allele will be expressed exclusively, while the recessive allele will remain latent. Mendel's law of dominance, however, does not always hold true. There are several instances where dominance doesn't occur in all contrasting characters.

Mendel's law of dominance is not applicable to all living organisms. It is only valid for diploid organisms and those that reproduce sexually. Mendel's law of dominance also does not account for other modes of inheritance, such as blending inheritance. In addition, dominance does not occur in all contrasting characters, and conditions of co-dominance or incomplete dominance may take place.

Gregor Mendel, a nineteenth-century Moravian monk, formulated the principles of Mendelian inheritance after conducting experiments on pea plants. Mendel's laws of inheritance include the law of dominance, the law of segregation, and the law of independent assortment. The law of dominance states that in a heterozygote, the dominant allele will be expressed, while the recessive allele will be masked. The law of segregation states that during the formation of gametes, the two alleles for a trait separate, so that each gamete carries only one allele, resulting in offspring inheriting one allele from each parent. The law of independent assortment states that a pair of traits segregates independently of another pair during gamete formation, giving different traits an equal opportunity to occur together.

Mendel's laws of inheritance were formulated based on experiments with pea plants, which have distinct, easily observable traits. He studied traits such as the length of the stem, colour of the seed, and shape of the cotyledon. Mendel's experiments involved crossing purebred white flower and purple flower pea plants (the P generation). The offspring (F1 generation) had purple flowers, indicating that the trait for purple flowers was dominant. When Mendel self-fertilised the F1 generation, he obtained a purple-to-white flower ratio of 3:1 in the F2 generation. Mendel's experiments also included studying other contrasting characters, such as green peas vs yellow peas and round vs wrinkled peas.

In summary, while Mendel's Law of Dominance states that one trait will conceal the presence of another in a heterozygote, this law does not always hold true. There are exceptions, including cases where dominance doesn't occur in all contrasting characters. Mendel's laws of inheritance were formulated based on experiments with pea plants, and they include the law of dominance, the law of segregation, and the law of independent assortment.

Conditions of co-dominance or incomplete dominance

Co-dominance and incomplete dominance are conditions where Mendel's law of dominance does not apply.

Co-dominance occurs when both alleles of a gene are expressed in the phenotype. For example, in humans, the AB blood type shows co-dominance, where both blood types A and B are expressed.

Incomplete dominance, also known as partial dominance, is a form of gene interaction where both alleles of a gene locus are partially expressed, resulting in an intermediate or different phenotype. This occurs when neither of the two alleles is completely dominant over the other. For example, in roses, the allele for red is dominant over the allele for white, but the heterozygous flowers with both alleles are pink in colour.

It only applies to diploid organisms and those that undergo sexual reproduction

Mendel's Law of Dominance states that when an organism has two different alleles for a trait, the dominant allele will be expressed, while the recessive allele will be masked. The dominant allele determines the phenotype (observable characteristics), while the recessive allele is hidden. Mendel's laws of dominance are based on the work of Gregor Mendel, who studied the inheritance of traits in pea plants.

Mendel's Law of Dominance has a few limitations. One of them is that it is only applicable to diploid organisms and those that undergo sexual reproduction. This is because the law of dominance is based on the concept of alleles, which are different versions of a gene, and diploidy, which refers to the presence of two copies of each chromosome in an organism. In diploid organisms, each chromosome in a pair comes from a parent, resulting in two alleles for each trait. During sexual reproduction, these alleles segregate and recombine, leading to the expression of certain traits.

Diploidy is a characteristic of many familiar animals and some plants. These organisms have two versions of each chromosome, with one contributed by the female parent in her ovum and the other by the male parent in his sperm. These gametes, or sex cells, are haploid, meaning they have only one copy of each chromosome. During fertilization, the two gametes join to form a diploid zygote, which will develop into a new organism.

The concept of dominance applies specifically to heterozygous pairs of alleles, where one factor dominates the other. In the case of homozygous pairs, where both alleles are the same, there is no dominant or recessive relationship because both alleles are identical. The law of dominance explains that the dominant allele will be expressed exclusively in the phenotype of the heterozygote, while the recessive allele will remain unexpressed or latent. However, the recessive allele can still be transmitted to offspring during reproduction.

It is important to note that Mendel's Law of Dominance does not apply to all living organisms. It is specifically relevant to diploid organisms that undergo sexual reproduction, as these are the conditions under which the principles of dominance and recessiveness were derived and observed.

Frequently asked questions