Resistance As Duty: Injustice, Law, And The Flag

The quote When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty is often misattributed to Thomas Jefferson, the third president of the United States. However, there is no evidence that he ever said or wrote this statement. The phrase is believed to have been popularized by social activists in Australia and first appeared in print in 1993. Despite its disputed origin, the quote remains a powerful statement that resonates with people across the political spectrum, often appearing on flags and apparel as a symbol of resistance and patriotism.

The quote is often misattributed to Thomas Jefferson

The quote in question, "When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty", is often misattributed to Thomas Jefferson, one of America's founding fathers and the principal author of the Declaration of Independence. While Jefferson's name is often invoked alongside this powerful statement, the words themselves cannot be found in his vast collection of writings, letters, or speeches. This misattribution is understandable, as the sentiment expressed in the quote aligns with many of Jefferson's philosophical and political beliefs.

Jefferson was a passionate advocate for individual liberty, limited government, and the natural rights of man. He believed that governments derive their power from the consent of the governed and that when a government becomes destructive of these inherent rights, it is the right and duty of the people to alter or abolish it. These beliefs are famously articulated in the Declaration of Independence, where Jefferson wrote, "That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness."

However, the phrase "When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty" takes this idea a step further, implying a more active and immediate form of resistance. It suggests that not only is it the right of the people to overthrow an oppressive government, but it is their duty to resist any laws that they perceive as unjust. This idea of active resistance to unjust laws has a long history in political thought, and while it aligns with many of Jefferson's beliefs, it is not a direct quote from his writings.

So, who originated this powerful statement? The true origin of the quote is often disputed, but it is commonly associated with the 19th-century German philosopher Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche. Nietzsche's writings frequently explored themes of power, morality, and the will to power. While he may have influenced the quote's philosophical underpinnings, the precise wording is likely a modern interpretation or synthesis of his ideas.

In conclusion, while the quote "When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty" captures the spirit of Thomas Jefferson's political philosophy, it cannot be found in his written works. This misattribution is understandable given Jefferson's advocacy for liberty and resistance to oppressive government. The phrase more accurately reflects a modern interpretation of Nietzsche's philosophical ideas, underscoring the complexity of accurately attributing quotes across history.

It captures ideas expressed in the Declaration of Independence

The quote "When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty" is often misattributed to Thomas Jefferson, the author of the Declaration of Independence. However, there is no evidence that he ever said or wrote this phrase. Despite this, the quote does capture some of the ideas that Jefferson expressed in the Declaration of Independence.

The Declaration of Independence was written by Jefferson in 1776 and is considered one of the most important documents in American history. In it, Jefferson outlined the reasons why the thirteen American colonies were declaring their independence from Great Britain. One of the key ideas in the Declaration of Independence is the belief that people have certain natural rights, including "Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness". When a government fails to protect these rights, or worse, infringes upon them, it is the right and duty of the people to overthrow such a government.

This idea is echoed in the quote "When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty". The quote suggests that when a government enacts unjust laws, it is the responsibility of the people to resist and overthrow that government. This sentiment is in line with Jefferson's belief in the right of revolution, as expressed in the Declaration of Independence.

In addition to the right of revolution, the Declaration of Independence also touches on the idea of consent of the governed. Jefferson argued that just governments derive their power from the consent of the governed, and that it is the people's right to alter or abolish a government that does not protect their natural rights. This notion of consent implies a certain level of resistance or non-compliance when faced with unjust laws, as the people have the inherent right to choose their form of government.

Furthermore, the Declaration of Independence highlights the importance of equality and the belief that all men are created equal. When a government enacts laws that treat people unequally or infringe upon their natural rights, it is a form of injustice. Thus, the quote "When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty" can be seen as a call to action for people to stand up against oppressive and unjust laws that violate the principles of equality and natural rights.

While the quote "When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty" may not have originated from Thomas Jefferson, it nonetheless captures the spirit of the ideas expressed in the Declaration of Independence. It serves as a reminder that resistance and revolution are sometimes necessary to uphold the values of liberty, equality, and justice.

It has been used in anti-government sentiment

The "When Injustice Becomes Law, Resistance Becomes Duty" flag has become an iconic symbol of dissent and has been embraced by those who wish to express their discontent with the government and its policies. This phrase has a long history, often attributed to Thomas Jefferson, and it resonates with those who feel their government has overstepped its mark and is infringing on their rights and freedoms. The sentiment "resistance becomes duty" implies a call to action and a sense of obligation to stand against perceived injustices.

This flag has been waved at protests and rallies, often alongside other symbols of anti-government sentiment, such as the "Don't Tread On Me" flag. It represents a defiance of authority and a belief that the government is no longer serving the best interests of its citizens. Those flying this flag see themselves as patriots, willing to stand up for their rights and what they believe is just, even if it means going against the established power.

In modern times, this flag and its message have been particularly prominent in the United States, with the rise of political polarization and an increasing sense of discontent with the political establishment. It has been flown by those on the political right, often associated with libertarian or conservative ideologies, who feel that their freedoms are being eroded by government overreach and that their traditional values are under threat.

The flag represents a rejection of what is seen as an oppressive government, with protesters co-opting the phrase to express their belief that the government is no longer upholding the values and principles upon which the nation was founded. It has been used by those who feel marginalized and believe that the government is no longer responsive to their needs or concerns. This sentiment has been particularly strong in rural and conservative areas, where there is a sense of disconnect from the urban, liberal centers of power.

The "When Injustice Becomes Law, Resistance Becomes Duty" flag serves as a visual reminder of the discontent and frustration felt by a significant portion of the population. It symbolizes a willingness to challenge the status quo and a belief in the duty to resist and overturn what is seen as an unjust system. This flag has become a powerful tool for those wishing to express their anti-government sentiments and to unite others around a common cause.

Those who fly this flag see it as a symbol of their commitment to defend their rights and liberties, often feeling that the government has become a force of oppression rather than a protector of freedom. It represents a fundamental rejection of the current political order and a call for a return to what is believed to be the true principles of liberty and justice.

It has been used to criticise Thomas Jefferson's own injustices

The "When Injustice Becomes Law, Resistance Becomes Duty" flag has been a symbol of protest against perceived injustices throughout history, and one notable figure who has faced criticism through this phrase is Thomas Jefferson. The third President of the United States, Jefferson is often celebrated as a founding father and the principal author of the Declaration of Independence, a document espousing the rights of man and self-governance. However, the flag and its message have been used to highlight the contradictions between Jefferson's words and his actions.

One of the most significant injustices associated with Jefferson is his ownership of slaves. Despite writing about the equality of men and their unalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, Jefferson himself owned slaves, a clear contradiction of the ideals he espoused. The flag's message of "resistance" becomes a critique of Jefferson's hypocrisy, suggesting that his failure to extend the same rights and freedoms to enslaved people justifies resistance to his legacy and the systems he helped create.

Another criticism levelled at Jefferson through this flag is the discrepancy between his words and actions regarding the power of the federal government. Jefferson advocated for a limited federal government, believing that states should retain significant power. However, as President, he signed into law measures that expanded federal power, such as the Embargo Act of 1807, which restricted trade and impacted states' rights. The flag's message can be interpreted as a resistance to this perceived injustice, where Jefferson's own actions went against his stated beliefs, leading to a concentration of power at the federal level that he had purportedly sought to avoid.

Furthermore, the flag's message can be applied to the broader context of Jefferson's time, where the founding fathers, including Jefferson, established a nation based on principles of freedom and democracy while simultaneously excluding certain groups, such as women and Indigenous peoples, from those very freedoms and rights. The phrase "when injustice becomes law" resonates with those who recognise the injustices perpetuated against these marginalised communities, and "resistance becomes duty" becomes a call to action to challenge the foundations of a nation built on such contradictions.

Through this flag and its powerful message, critics highlight the inconsistencies between Thomas Jefferson's words and deeds, particularly regarding slavery and federal power. The phrase "When Injustice Becomes Law, Resistance Becomes Duty" serves as a reminder that resistance is not only a right but a duty when faced with such injustices, and it has been effectively employed to challenge the legacy of one of America's most revered founding fathers.

It has been used to promote a sense of patriotism

The "When Injustice Becomes Law, Resistance Becomes Duty" flag has become an iconic symbol of protest and civil disobedience. The phrase itself is a powerful statement that resonates with people across a range of social and political movements. The flag has been adopted by those seeking to promote a sense of patriotism, and it is used to great effect in rallying support and inspiring a sense of national pride.

This sense of patriotism is born from a desire to see a nation's highest ideals upheld and protected. The phrase on the flag suggests that when a country's laws are unjust, it is the duty of its citizens to resist and strive for a better, more equitable society. This sentiment is a powerful motivator, encouraging active participation in the democratic process and a willingness to stand up for what is right.

The flag's design often incorporates patriotic colors and symbols, further emphasizing the connection between resistance and love for one's country. The stars and stripes of the American flag, for example, are often incorporated to remind people of the nation's founding principles of liberty and justice. By invoking these powerful symbols, the flag becomes a visual reminder of the country's core values and the responsibility of its citizens to hold true to them.

In times of social and political unrest, this message of patriotic duty can be a powerful unifier. It reminds people of their shared values and the common goal of creating a better nation for all its citizens. The flag becomes a symbol of hope and a call to action, encouraging people to engage with the political process and make their voices heard.

The phrase "When Injustice Becomes Law, Resistance Becomes Duty" serves as a powerful reminder that patriotism is not just about blind loyalty to a country or its leaders. True patriotism, as the flag suggests, involves holding one's nation to the highest standards of justice and equality, and being willing to speak out and resist when these ideals are threatened. This sense of patriotic duty encourages an active and engaged citizenry, which is essential for a healthy democracy.

By flying this flag, individuals and organizations can promote a sense of patriotic duty and inspire others to join them in their pursuit of a more just and equitable society. It serves as a visual reminder of the power and responsibility that citizens hold in shaping the future of their nation.

Frequently asked questions