Hillary's Email Scandal: What Laws Were Broken?

which law did hillary break with her personal email server

Hillary Clinton's use of a personal email server to conduct government business while Secretary of State has been the subject of much scrutiny. A report by the US State Department's Office of the Inspector General (OIG) found that Clinton did breach record-keeping laws and put national security at risk. Clinton's defence has been that she was unaware of the classification of the emails at the time they were sent or received.

Characteristics Values
Law broken Federal Records Act
Reason Using a personal server for work emails
Other rule broken State Department rules requiring personal email systems to be checked out for security

lawshun

Breach of record-keeping laws

Hillary Clinton breached record-keeping laws by using a personal server for work emails. A report by the US State Department's Office of the Inspector General (OIG) found that Clinton, along with Colin Powell and Scott Gration, had broken the rules by using personal email accounts for departmental business. The Federal Records Act allows for the occasional use of a personal email account for official business, but Clinton's use of a private server for all of her public business while Secretary of State did not fall within this exception.

Clinton's primary defence has been that she was unaware of the classification of the emails at the time they were sent or received. However, the State Department had rules that any personal email systems used for work must be checked out for security, and Clinton did not take advantage of this. On 9 January 2011, Clinton's email server came under attack, raising serious concerns about the security of her personal email system.

Clinton's use of a private server located in her home without the same protections as a government server put sensitive communications and potentially some of the nation's secrets at risk.

lawshun

Sending and receiving classified information

While serving as Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton sent and received classified information via email on a private, non-governmental server. There are strict laws governing the accessing and storage of classified government information. Clinton's primary defence was that she was unaware of their classification at the time the emails were sent or received.

The Federal Records Act allows for the occasional use of a personal email account for official business where necessary. However, Clinton's use of a private server located in her home did not provide the same protections as a government server. This meant that her sometimes-sensitive communications were at risk of being hacked.

The State Department had rules that any personal email systems had to be checked out for security, but Clinton did not take advantage of this. When two staff members questioned the security of her email system, they were told that the server had been reviewed and approved and that they should "never speak of the Secretary's personal email system again".

Clinton's use of a personal email server broke record-keeping laws, as found by the US State Department's Office of the Inspector General (OIG). The OIG report also found that three senior State Department figures had broken the rules by using personal email accounts for departmental business: Colin Powell, Hilary Clinton, and Scott Gration, the US ambassador to Kenya.

lawshun

Security concerns

Hillary Clinton's use of a personal email server to conduct government business raised serious security concerns. As Secretary of State, Clinton was responsible for handling sensitive and classified information. By using a private server located in her home, Clinton's emails were potentially vulnerable to hacking and other security breaches.

Clinton's server lacked the same protections and security measures as a government server. Computer security experts warned that her use of a personal email system may have put national security secrets at risk. On January 9, 2011, Clinton's email server came under attack, underscoring the validity of these concerns.

Clinton's defence has been that she was unaware of the classification of the emails at the time they were sent or received. However, strict laws govern the accessing and storage of classified government information. The Federal Records Act, which was in place at the time, allowed for the occasional use of personal email accounts for official business, but only when necessary and as a practical matter.

The State Department had rules requiring personal email systems to be checked for security, but Clinton did not take advantage of this. When staff members raised concerns about the security of her email system, they were told that the server had been reviewed and approved and were instructed never to speak of it again.

lawshun

Lack of automatic security

Hillary Clinton's use of a personal email server during her time as Secretary of State has been the subject of much scrutiny, with questions arising over whether it broke the law and compromised national security.

Clinton's private email server lacked the same automatic security protections as a government server, leaving her sometimes-sensitive communications vulnerable to hacking attempts. This was a significant concern, as any good hacker could have potentially accessed her emails and put national secrets at risk.

Clinton's primary defence has been that she was unaware of the classification of the emails at the time they were sent or received. However, strict laws govern the accessing and storage of classified government information. While the Federal Records Act does allow for the occasional use of personal email accounts for official business, it does not absolve the responsibility to ensure proper security measures are in place.

The State Department had rules during Clinton's time in office that required any personal email systems to be checked out for security. However, Clinton did not take advantage of this, and when staff members questioned the security of her email system, they were told that the server had been reviewed and approved and to "never speak of the Secretary's personal email system again." This lack of transparency and failure to prioritise security highlights a significant oversight in Clinton's handling of sensitive information.

Teachers' Breaks: What Does the Law Say?

You may want to see also

lawshun

Federal Records Act

Hillary Clinton's use of a personal email server while Secretary of State was found to have breached record-keeping laws. Specifically, she was found to have broken the Federal Records Act, which requires that any personal email systems used for government business must be checked out for security. Clinton's server was found to have been attacked in January 2011, and it was later revealed that staff members had previously raised concerns about the security of her email system.

The Federal Records Act is a US federal law that governs the management and preservation of records created or received by federal agencies. It requires agencies to maintain complete and accurate records of their activities, including emails, and to make those records available to the public upon request. The Act also establishes the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) as the agency responsible for overseeing the management of federal records.

In the case of Clinton's personal email server, the issue was not just the use of a personal email address and server for public business, but also the fact that classified information was sent and received via this unsecured channel. Strict laws govern the accessing and storage of classified government information, and Clinton's use of a private server located in her home without the same protections as a government server put some of the nation's secrets at risk.

The Federal Records Act allows for the occasional use of a personal email account for official business where necessary, such as when a secretary of state must deal with a crisis around the world in the middle of the night. However, Clinton's use of a personal email server for all of her public business while Secretary of State went beyond what was allowed by the Act.

Frequently asked questions

Yes, according to a report by the US State Department's Office of the Inspector General (OIG), Clinton did breach record-keeping laws by using a personal server for work emails.

Clinton broke the Federal Records Act.

Clinton sent and received classified information via email on a private, non-governmental server while she was serving as Secretary of State. Strict laws govern the accessing and storage of classified government information.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment