Who Really Controls Abortion Laws In America?

The legality of abortion in the United States is decided by individual states, with no uniform federal law in place. In June 2022, the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, which had protected the federal constitutional right to abortion since 1973. This ruling gave states the power to restrict or ban abortion, resulting in a complex web of laws, regulations, and court decisions at the local, state, and federal levels. As a result, abortion laws vary significantly across the country, with some states prohibiting abortion entirely, while others permit it with varying restrictions and time limits. Public opinion is divided, with a majority disagreeing with the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, yet also opposing second and third-trimester abortions.

The Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade in 2022

In 2022, the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, the 1973 ruling that had guaranteed a constitutional right to abortion, gave states the authority to set their own abortion policies. The decision sparked controversy, as it was the first case to formally rescind a fundamental constitutional right.

The Supreme Court's ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022) overturned Roe v. Wade, which had ensured a federal right to an abortion for nearly 50 years. The decision gave states the power to restrict or prohibit abortion, with several states enacting stricter abortion laws or enforcing pre-1973 laws. The Supreme Court's decision was influenced by Justice Samuel Alito, who argued that the right to privacy is not guaranteed in the Constitution and that unenumerated liberty rights must be "deeply rooted in the Nation's history and tradition".

The impact of the decision was significant, with abortion becoming illegal in 13 states and restricted in many others. The public reaction to the ruling was mixed, with a majority of Americans disapproving of the decision and protests occurring outside the Supreme Court. The decision also had political implications, with partisan differences on the legality of abortion widening.

The Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade had far-reaching consequences, reshaping the landscape of reproductive rights in America and sparking debates about the role of the government in protecting or restricting abortion access. The decision highlighted the importance of state-level politics in determining abortion policies, with states becoming divided into "abortion deserts" and "abortion havens". The ruling also raised questions about the future of other rights that rely on the same constitutional logic as Roe, such as the right to contraception and same-sex marriage.

The impact of Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization on abortion laws

The 2022 Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization case was a landmark decision by the U.S. Supreme Court, which held that the U.S. Constitution does not confer a right to abortion. The ruling overturned Roe v. Wade (1973) and Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992), giving federal and state legislatures the power to regulate abortion. This decision has had a significant impact on abortion laws and access across America.

The Dobbs ruling has had a profound impact on abortion laws in America, as it removed the constitutional protection for abortion and allowed states to implement their own regulations. Here are some key ways in which the decision has affected abortion laws:

• Returning Power to the States: The Dobbs ruling returned the decision-making power regarding abortion regulations to the states. This has resulted in a patchwork of varying abortion laws across the country, with some states banning abortion outright, while others continue to protect abortion rights.
• Trigger Laws and Pre-Roe Bans: Several states had enacted "trigger laws," which automatically banned abortion if Roe v. Wade was overturned. Additionally, some states had pre-Roe abortion bans that were unenforceable under Roe but have now been revived or are in the process of being revived.
• New Abortion Restrictions: In the wake of the Dobbs decision, several states have introduced new abortion restrictions or tightened existing ones. These restrictions vary widely among the states, creating a complex landscape of abortion laws across the nation.
• Legal Challenges: The Dobbs decision has sparked numerous legal challenges and court rulings as states navigate the new landscape of abortion regulations. These legal battles often centre around the interpretation of state constitutions and the extent to which they protect or restrict abortion rights.
• Impact on Other Rights: The Dobbs decision has also raised concerns about the potential impact on other rights, such as the right to contraception, same-sex marriage, and privacy. While the majority opinion in Dobbs asserted that its ruling only applied to abortion, some worry that the reasoning could be used to challenge these other rights.
• Federal Legislative Efforts: The decision has prompted legislative efforts at the federal level to protect or restrict abortion access. For example, the Women's Health Protection Act, which aims to protect abortion access nationwide, passed the House but has not yet passed the Senate.
• State Legislative Efforts: At the state level, there has been a flurry of activity, with some states moving to restrict abortion access further, while others are working to protect and expand abortion rights. These efforts have resulted in a highly polarised landscape, with some states becoming "abortion havens" and others becoming "abortion deserts."
• Impact on Marginalised Communities: The loss of constitutional protection for abortion has disproportionately affected marginalised communities, including people of colour, people with disabilities, people in rural areas, young people, undocumented immigrants, and low-income individuals. These groups often face additional barriers to accessing healthcare, and the abortion restrictions have exacerbated these challenges.

The Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization decision has had a profound and far-reaching impact on abortion laws and access in America. It has shifted the power to regulate abortion from the federal level to the states, resulting in a highly varied landscape of abortion laws and a significant reduction in abortion access in many parts of the country. The decision has also sparked legal battles, political debates, and social movements as Americans navigate this new era of abortion rights and restrictions.

State-by-state abortion laws and restrictions

In June 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, allowing states to ban abortion outright. Currently, abortion is illegal in 13 states.

Alabama

Abortion is illegal in Alabama, with exceptions to preserve the pregnant individual's life or physical health. There are no exceptions for rape, incest, or fatal fetal abnormalities. Performing an abortion is a Class A felony with up to 99 years in prison, and attempted abortion is a Class C felony punishable by 1 to 10 years in prison.

Alaska

Abortion is legal in Alaska at all stages of pregnancy. Alaska does not require parental notification for minors seeking an abortion. In September 2024, an Alaska superior court judge struck down the requirement that only licensed physicians provide abortions, meaning that the procedure can now be legally performed by nurse practitioners and physician assistants.

Arizona

Abortion is legal in Arizona up until the 15th week of pregnancy. Patients must meet with a physician at least 24 hours before the procedure, and a licensed physician must perform the procedure. Minors under the age of 18 must receive parental consent.

Arkansas

Abortion is illegal in Arkansas, with an exception for abortions necessary to save the life of the pregnant individual; there are no exceptions for rape, incest, or fatal fetal abnormalities. Doctors who perform an abortion face up to 10 years in prison and fines up to $100,000.

California

Abortion is legal in California up to the point of fetal viability, or after that if necessary to preserve the life or health (including mental health) of the pregnant individual. California does not require parental notification for minors seeking an abortion. In November 2022, California voters passed Proposition 1, enshrining the right to legal abortion and contraception in the state constitution.

Colorado

Abortion is legal in Colorado at all stages of pregnancy. Minors' parents or legal guardians must receive notification before the procedure. In April 2022, Colorado passed the Reproductive Health Equity Act, which

Public opinion on abortion rights and the Supreme Court's decision

Public opinion on abortion rights in the US is divided along partisan lines. While public support for legal abortion has been relatively stable in recent years, there are some notable differences between groups. Overall, 63% of US adults say abortion should be legal in all or most cases, while 36% say it should be illegal in all or most cases.

A breakdown of these statistics reveals that 85% of Democrats and Democratic leaners support legal abortion, compared to 57% of Republicans and Republican leaners who say abortion should be illegal. Among conservative Republicans, 71% say abortion should be illegal, while 67% of moderate and liberal Republicans support legal abortion.

Religious affiliation also plays a role in shaping opinions on abortion. 73% of White evangelical Protestants believe abortion should be illegal in all or most cases, while 86% of religiously unaffiliated Americans, 71% of Black Protestants, 64% of White nonevangelical Protestants, and 59% of Catholics support legal abortion.

Age is another factor influencing views on abortion. 76% of adults under 30 say abortion should be legal, compared to 57% of those in their 50s and early 60s.

The Supreme Court's decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, which overturned Roe v. Wade, has had a significant impact on public opinion, particularly regarding the legitimacy of the Court. While it did not shift Americans' beliefs about abortion, the decision polarized attitudes toward the Court along partisan lines. Democrats' perceptions of the Court's legitimacy dropped after the leak of the draft decision and again after the final ruling, while more Republicans expressed a positive view of the Court.

The Dobbs decision also affected views on the Supreme Court's role in shaping public opinion and its ability to weather controversy. The ruling challenged the established understanding that Americans are swayed by the Court, even when it makes unpopular decisions, due to respect for its legitimacy. The study by Neil Malhotra and his colleagues found that there was no mass movement against abortion rights following the Dobbs decision, and the legitimacy of the Court among Democrats was significantly diminished.

The Supreme Court's ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization has had a profound impact on abortion access and reproductive rights in the United States, with far-reaching consequences that will likely persist for years or even decades. The decision has resulted in a patchwork of abortion laws and restrictions that vary significantly from state to state, with some states banning abortion outright, while others protect or expand access to abortion.

The role of politics and politicians in shaping abortion laws

The Southern Baptist Convention, once supportive of abortion rights, passed a resolution in 1980 opposing the procedure, marking a significant change. The election of Republican Ronald Reagan as president in the same year further bolstered the anti-abortion movement, granting them a powerful ally in the White House. Meanwhile, women's rights activists gained influence within the Democratic Party, pushing leaders to champion abortion rights.

The Supreme Court's Roe v. Wade decision in 1973 legalized abortion nationwide, but the subsequent Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization ruling in 2022 overturned this, allowing states to impose their own regulations. This shift has resulted in varying restrictions across the country, with some states implementing total bans, while others impose gestational limits or have minimal exceptions.

The influence of Christian morality on abortion laws is evident, with prominent figures such as Jerry Falwell and religious organizations like the Moral Majority advocating for traditional family values. This has contributed to a complex interplay between personal beliefs, religious devotion, and official church positions, shaping perspectives on abortion. The strength of one's belief in the Christian God is correlated with the depth of their conviction against abortion, and regular engagement with religious practices reinforces anti-abortion sentiments.

The language used by anti-abortion groups is also powerful, with slogans such as "I am the Pro-Life Generation" and "My Generation Rejects Abortion" unifying their movement. However, this language can be misleading, contributing to a distorted image of abortion and perpetuating misinformation.

The impact of politics and politicians on abortion laws in America has been significant, with the issue becoming deeply polarized along party lines. The conservative movement, influenced by religious values, has successfully framed abortion as a threat to traditional values, mobilizing activists and gaining political influence. This has resulted in varying abortion laws across the country, with states now having the power to impose their own regulations following the overturning of Roe v. Wade.

Frequently asked questions