Who Backed Abortion Law Change: Political Divide

The topic of abortion laws has been a highly contested issue in the United States, with recent developments adding fuel to the fire. In 2022, the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, a landmark 1973 ruling that guaranteed a constitutional right to abortion. This decision sparked widespread protests and pushed reproductive rights to the forefront of political debates. The ruling shifted the power to individual states, allowing them to create their own laws regarding abortion, including bans or restrictions. This shift has led to a stark divide, with conservative states moving to ban abortions and liberal states protecting abortion rights. The impact of these varying laws has been significant, with abortion access becoming restricted or prohibited in several states, and the number of clinics providing abortion services declining. The debate surrounding abortion laws continues to be a pivotal issue in elections, with voters and politicians alike advocating for their respective stances.

The Supreme Court's 2022 overturning of Roe v. Wade

The year 2022 witnessed a significant shift in abortion laws in the United States with the Supreme Court's overturning of Roe v. Wade, a landmark 1973 decision that had guaranteed a constitutional right to abortion for nearly five decades. This decision had far-reaching implications, and the political and social landscape surrounding abortion changed drastically.

The Decision and Its Immediate Aftermath

The Supreme Court's ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization effectively overturned Roe v. Wade, holding that abortion was not a legitimate unenumerated right protected by the Constitution. The Court's conservative majority, led by Justice Samuel Alito, argued that only those rights ""deeply rooted in the Nation's history and tradition" were protected, and abortion did not fall within this category. The decision sparked widespread protests and pushed reproductive rights to the forefront of political debates.

Impact on State Laws and Abortion Access

The overturning of Roe v. Wade resulted in a state-by-state approach to reproductive rights, with varying outcomes across the country. Some states, like Kansas and Ohio, voted to protect abortion rights, while others moved swiftly to ban the procedure, often with few or no exceptions. This led to a patchwork of abortion laws across the nation, with abortion access becoming heavily restricted or banned in more than a dozen states.

Political Reactions and Electoral Implications

The decision had significant political ramifications, with Democrats and Republicans sharply divided over the issue. Democrats criticized the ruling and sought to frame the protection of abortion rights as a key electoral issue, especially for independent and moderate women voters. Republicans, on the other hand, celebrated the decision, arguing that states should have the power to decide on abortion laws. However, there were some dissenting voices within the Republican Party, with a notable number of Republicans in states like Florida supporting abortion rights amendments.

Legal Challenges and Uncertainty

The Supreme Court's decision triggered a wave of legal challenges and uncertainty. State courts grappled with interpreting their constitutions regarding abortion rights, with some recognizing explicit references to "privacy" or broadly protecting personal autonomy. The validity of "trigger laws," designed to ban abortion immediately upon Roe v. Wade being overturned, also came into question. The complex web of state laws and court decisions left many abortion providers and patients confused and concerned about their legal standing.

Shifting Landscape of Reproductive Health

The overturning of Roe v. Wade had a profound impact on the provision of reproductive health services. Abortion clinics closed or relocated to states with protective laws, and physicians faced difficult choices, with some leaving restrictive states or even the medical profession altogether. Access to abortion pills became heavily restricted, and there was a rise in pregnancy-related prosecutions, often unrelated to abortion. The decision also had ripple effects on other areas of gynecological care, as obstetricians fled restrictive states, straining access to essential healthcare services.

State-level abortion laws

In the US, abortion laws vary significantly from state to state. While some states prohibit abortion at all stages of pregnancy, others permit it up to a certain point, and some allow abortion throughout a woman's pregnancy.

In June 2022, the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, which had protected the federal Constitutional right to abortion for nearly 50 years. This ruling gave states total leeway to restrict abortion or prohibit it altogether. As a result, abortion is now illegal in 13 states, with varying exceptions. For example, in Alabama, abortion is illegal with exceptions to preserve the pregnant individual's life or physical health, while in Arkansas, abortion is illegal with the exception of saving the pregnant individual's life.

In contrast, some states have chosen to protect abortion rights at the state level. Citizens in six states (California, Michigan, Ohio, Vermont, Kentucky, and Kansas) have already voted on abortion measures, with four approving amendments to protect abortion rights. In November 2024, 10 states will have measures to amend their constitutions to protect abortion rights on the ballot. These states are Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Maryland, Nevada, New York, South Dakota, Missouri, Montana, and Nebraska.

In addition to these state-level efforts, there are also movements to pass new federal legislation guaranteeing the right to abortion. However, as of October 2024, no new federal laws have been successful in rewinding abortion in America to pre-2021 access.

The role of state supreme courts

In the United States, the Supreme Court's decision in Roe v. Wade (1973) established a constitutional right to abortion, holding that the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment protects a pregnant woman's liberty to choose whether to have an abortion without excessive government restriction. This landmark ruling struck down many abortion laws and sparked ongoing debates about the legality and extent of abortion rights.

However, in 2022, the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, eliminating the constitutional right to abortion. This decision shifted the authority to regulate abortion back to the states, allowing them to impose any restrictions as long as they satisfy rational basis review and do not conflict with federal law.

The impact of this shift is evident in the varying abortion laws across different states. Some states have chosen to protect reproductive rights by enshrining them into their state constitutions, while others have enacted strict abortion bans with limited exceptions. State supreme courts play a crucial role in interpreting and enforcing these laws, shaping the legal landscape of abortion access.

For example, in Florida, the state supreme court declined to stay a law outlawing abortion after 15 weeks of pregnancy, and subsequently approved an amendment allowing abortion up to fetal viability. In contrast, the Georgia Supreme Court reinstated a 6-week abortion ban that had been struck down by a lower court, demonstrating the differing approaches taken by state supreme courts.

State supreme courts also address legal challenges to abortion laws, such as the lawsuit filed by abortion advocacy groups in Alabama seeking to prevent prosecutions of those who help Alabamians access abortions in other states. Additionally, state supreme courts interpret and apply their state constitutions, which may offer stronger protections for abortion rights than the federal constitution, as seen in Kansas and Montana.

The impact of gerrymandering

Gerrymandering has had a significant impact on abortion laws in the United States, as it has allowed political parties to manipulate voting districts to their advantage and pass legislation that may not truly represent the will of the people.

In 2019, the US Supreme Court ruled that it would not intervene to restrain partisan gerrymandering, allowing Republicans and Democrats to redraw district boundaries and gain an electoral edge for their candidates. This has resulted in legislatures that are more heavily partisan than the state's population as a whole.

For example, in swing states like Michigan and Wisconsin, gerrymandering has been cited as the primary reason abortion restrictions have been enacted. By concentrating voters of one party into specific districts, the other party can gain a disproportionate number of legislative seats. In Michigan, Republicans created an advantage for their party through gerrymandering, which may have helped them maintain control of the closely divided House. However, in 2022, a voter-approved citizens' redistricting commission reduced the GOP's edge, potentially improving Democrats' chances of influencing abortion policy.

Similarly, in Georgia, Alabama, Missouri, and Ohio, Republicans have used gerrymandering to establish a stranglehold on state legislatures. By concentrating black voters into a few districts, they have maximised the number of heavily white Republican seats. As a result, they have been able to pass near-total abortion bans despite opposition from a significant portion of the population.

Gerrymandering has also been used to block abortion policies that the public wants. In Texas, aggressive gerrymandering transformed a once competitive state legislature into a safely Republican one, making it difficult for Democrats to gain control. Meanwhile, in states like Michigan and North Carolina, independent commissions or state courts have created more balanced legislative maps, making it harder for a single party to dominate and pass extreme legislation.

Public opinion on abortion

The breakdown of public opinion on abortion varies across different demographics. For instance, 86% of religiously unaffiliated Americans say abortion should be legal in all or most cases, compared to 73% of White evangelical Protestants who think it should be illegal in all or most cases. Among Republicans and Republican leaners, 57% say abortion should be illegal in all or most cases, while 85% of Democrats and Democratic leaners say it should be legal in all or most cases.

Majorities of both men (61%) and women (64%) express support for legal abortion, and support is higher among younger age groups, with 76% of adults under 30 saying abortion should be legal in all or most cases, compared to 57% of those in their 50s and early 60s.

Frequently asked questions