Theoretical Limits: Laws Remain, Theories Evolve

There is a common misconception that theories and laws are part of a scientific hierarchy, with laws representing the most evidence-backed and widely accepted ideas. However, this is not the case. Theories and laws serve different purposes: theories are a set of ideas that explain how or why natural phenomena occur, while laws are usually mathematical descriptions of what happens. For example, the Gas Laws are mathematical formulas that predict with great accuracy that if the temperature of a sealed gas is doubled, the pressure will also double. However, to explain why gases behave this way, we need to use the kinetic molecular theory, which describes the behaviour of gas particles. In this case, the theory is more useful than the law because it tells us why something happens, not just that it does happen.

Theories and laws have different purposes

Theories and laws have distinct purposes and meanings in the language of science. Theories are a set of ideas that explain how and why natural phenomena occur, while laws are simple facts and formulas that describe what happens in the natural world. Theories provide a "why" and a "how", whereas laws are usually mathematical relationships that tell us "what".

For example, the Gas Laws are mathematical formulas that predict with accuracy that if the temperature of a sealed gas is doubled, the pressure will also double. However, to explain why gases behave this way, we need the kinetic molecular theory. This theory explains that gas particles bounce off each other like billiard balls in 3D, so when the temperature is doubled, the particles move twice as fast and collide with the container with double the force, resulting in double the pressure.

The theory of evolution is another example. Darwin's theory of natural selection explains how species evolve, but it is often dismissed as "just a theory". However, a theory is the most accepted, empirically supported way to explain a phenomenon. It is not a step below a law but rather serves a different purpose and is often more useful.

In summary, theories and laws have different purposes and are both essential in science. Theories provide explanations and understanding, while laws provide simple descriptions and formulas. Theories do not become laws; they are separate elements of the scientific method.

Theories explain why and how something happens

Theories and laws are two distinct concepts in science, each serving a different purpose. While laws are simple descriptions or facts, often mathematical, that explain what happens in the natural world, theories go a step further and explain why and how something happens.

Theories are a set of ideas that provide an explanation for natural phenomena. They are supported by evidence, can be tested, and can be used to make predictions. For example, the theory of general relativity explains what gravity is and how it works.

In contrast, laws are usually mathematical relationships that describe a natural phenomenon without explaining why it occurs. For instance, the law of gravity describes the attraction between two objects mathematically but does not explain what gravity is or why it works the way it does.

The distinction between theories and laws is important because it highlights the different roles they play in scientific understanding. Laws provide a basic framework for understanding the world, while theories offer a more comprehensive explanation that incorporates laws, facts, inferences, and tested hypotheses.

Theories and laws are not part of a hierarchy where one evolves into the other. They are separate elements of the scientific method, each contributing to our understanding of the natural world in its own way.

Laws are simple facts and formulas

In science, laws are simple facts and formulas that are so basic that they apply universally. For example, Ohm's Law can be represented by the formula I=V/R, which tells us that in an electrical circuit, the amperage is equal to the voltage divided by the resistance. This is important to know if you're working with electricity, but it doesn't explain what amperage is, why it equals voltage divided by resistance, or what we can do with this information.

Laws are descriptions, often mathematical, of natural phenomena. For instance, Newton's Law of Gravity mathematically describes how two different bodies in the universe interact with each other. However, it doesn't explain what gravity is or how it works. That's where theories come in.

Theories are a set of ideas that help to explain how or why natural phenomena occur. The theory of general relativity, for example, explains what gravity is and how it works. According to the National Academy of Sciences, a scientific theory is a "well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world that can incorporate facts, laws, inferences, and tested hypotheses."

Theories and laws are separate elements of the scientific method. They each serve a different purpose and are not interchangeable. Laws tell us what happens, while theories explain how and why something happens.

Theories are supported by evidence and can be tested

Theories and laws are distinct concepts in science, and they serve different purposes. Theories are supported by evidence and can be tested, while laws are simple descriptions or facts that apply universally.

Theories are a set of ideas that explain how or why natural phenomena occur. They are supported by evidence and can be tested. For example, the kinetic molecular theory explains why gases behave the way they do. The particles of a gas bounce off each other in elastic collisions, like billiard balls in 3D. If the temperature is doubled, the tiny spheres move twice as fast and collide with the container with double the force, resulting in double the pressure. This explanation is supported by evidence and can be tested through experiments.

The National Academy of Sciences defines a scientific theory as a "well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world that can incorporate facts, laws, inferences, and tested hypotheses." Theories are the end goal of science, and they are the most empirically supported and scientifically accepted way to explain phenomena. They are not "upgraded" to laws but are instead used to make predictions and guide further research.

In contrast, laws are simple descriptions or facts about natural phenomena, often expressed mathematically. For example, Ohm's Law states that in an electrical circuit, the amperage is equal to the voltage divided by the resistance. This law tells us nothing about what amperage, voltage, or resistance are, but it is a basic principle that applies universally. Laws tell us what happens, while theories explain how and why something happens.

The distinction between theories and laws is important, and it is not a matter of hierarchy or the amount of supporting evidence. Both theories and laws are essential in science, but they serve different purposes and provide different types of understanding about the natural world. Theories explain why things happen, while laws describe what happens.

Theories and laws are separate elements of the scientific method

Theories and laws are distinct elements of the scientific method. They are separate concepts that serve different purposes and functions in the pursuit of scientific knowledge and understanding.

A scientific law is a description, often mathematical, of a natural phenomenon. It is a simple statement of fact or a formula that applies universally. For example, the law of gravity describes the attraction between two objects. However, it does not explain what gravity is or why it works. That is the realm of theory.

A scientific theory, according to the National Academy of Sciences, is a "well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world that can incorporate facts, laws, inferences, and tested hypotheses." Theories provide an explanation for observed phenomena and can be used to make predictions. For example, the theory of general relativity explains the phenomenon of gravity by providing a theoretical framework that helps us understand what gravity is and how it works.

Theories and laws have distinct roles and purposes. Theories are a set of ideas that explain how or why natural phenomena occur, while laws are typically mathematical relationships that describe what happens. For instance, the Gas Laws are mathematical formulas that accurately predict the behaviour of gases. However, to understand why gases behave in this way, we need the kinetic molecular theory, which explains the underlying mechanisms.

The relationship between theories and laws is not hierarchical or evolutionary. The level of evidence supporting a theory does not determine whether it becomes a law. Instead, they are separate tools used by scientists to understand and explain the natural world. Theories and laws work together to provide a comprehensive understanding of the universe, each contributing unique insights and perspectives.

In summary, theories and laws are separate elements of the scientific method, each serving a distinct purpose. Theories explain how and why things happen, while laws describe what happens. Both are essential in the pursuit of scientific knowledge, providing a deeper and more nuanced understanding of the natural world.

Frequently asked questions