Left-Handed People: More Lawless Or Just A Myth?

There is a long-standing perception that left-handed people are more likely to engage in criminal behaviour. However, this is not supported by scientific research. While some studies suggest a small association between left-handedness and criminal behaviour, the evidence is inconclusive. Left-handed people make up about 10-13% of the general population, while the percentage of left-handed criminals is estimated to be around 15-25%. Overall, left-handedness alone does not determine criminality, and social, biological, and environmental factors also play a role.

Historically, left-handed people have faced social stigma and marginalisation, which could potentially lead to antisocial tendencies. Additionally, left-handed people may face challenges due to the prevalence of right-handed tools and objects, which can impact their performance in certain tasks. However, in sports that involve aiming at a target in an opponent's control area, left-handed people have an advantage as their opponents are more accustomed to the right-handed majority.

While the research on the link between left-handedness and criminal behaviour is mixed, it is clear that handedness alone is not a reliable predictor of criminality.

Criminal behaviour

There is a common perception that left-handed people are more likely to engage in criminal behaviour. However, this perception is not supported by research. While some studies have found a small association between left-handedness and criminal behaviour, the evidence is mixed and inconclusive.

Left-handed people make up about 10-13% of the general population, while the percentage of left-handed criminals is estimated to be around 15-25% according to some studies. However, it is important to note that handedness alone does not determine criminality. Social, biological, and environmental factors also play a role.

Several studies over the past few decades have explored the potential link between left-handedness and criminal conduct. Some of the earliest evidence came from studies of prison populations, which suggested that left-handed people may be over-represented in prisons compared to the general public. For example, a 1989 study of prisoners in New York found that 15% of inmates were left-handed, compared to 10% of the general population. Similarly, a 1992 study of prisoners in Canada found that 25% of violent criminals were left-handed.

However, prison studies alone cannot determine causality, and there are many factors that influence criminality beyond handedness. Researchers have also looked at handedness and criminal tendencies within the general population, with mixed results. For instance, a 2009 study found that left-handed people were significantly more likely to report stealing or vandalizing property, while a 2014 study using data from over 25,000 people found no relationship between left-handedness and rule-breaking or violent behaviour.

Meta-analyses, which combine and statistically analyse the results of multiple studies, have also been conducted. A 1993 meta-analysis found a statistically significant but small association between left-handedness and criminality, while a 2013 meta-analysis of 27 studies found no overall association between the two. Overall, while there may be a weak correlation between left-handedness and criminal activity, the results are mixed, and the association is likely minor.

If left-handed people are slightly more likely to engage in criminal conduct, what could explain this association? Researchers have proposed several potential factors, including neurological and biological differences, social marginalization, and poor school performance. However, it is important to note that handedness itself does not directly determine someone's proclivity to commit crimes, and promoting the notion that left-handedness is linked to criminality could reinforce unfair stereotyping.

In conclusion, while some studies suggest that left-handers may be slightly over-represented among criminals and prison populations, conclusive evidence of robust links between handedness and criminality is lacking. Most left-handed people are law-abiding citizens, and handedness has, at best, an extremely weak predictive relationship with criminality.

Social marginalisation

Left-handed people have historically faced social stigma and marginalisation. In many societies, they have been considered unlucky or even malicious by the right-handed majority. In some cultures, the use of the left hand is considered disrespectful. The Latin word 'sinister' means 'left' as well as 'unlucky', and this double meaning survives in European derivatives of Latin. In many languages, the word for ''right' also means 'correct' or 'proper'.

In the past, left-handed children were often forced to write and eat with their right hand. This conversion can cause multiple problems in the developing left-handed child, including learning disorders, dyslexia, stuttering and other speech disorders. In the Soviet Union, all left-handed students were forced to write with their right hand. In Taiwan, about 59.3% of naturally left-handed children studied had been forced to become right-handed.

Left-handed people have also been disadvantaged by the design of tools and everyday objects, which are often created with right-handed users in mind. This can make these items inconvenient, painful, or even dangerous for left-handed people to use. For example, right-handed scissors tend to force the blades apart in the left hand, making them ineffective. School desks, kitchen implements, power tools, machinery, and musical instruments are often designed for right-handed users, and can be difficult or uncomfortable for left-handed people to use.

Brain differences

Research has shown that the brains of left-handed people are structured differently from those of right-handed people. This difference in brain structure may be linked to a higher likelihood of engaging in criminal behaviour. For example, reduced lateralization between the brain's hemispheres has been associated with impulse control issues and rule-breaking behaviour. Additionally, differences in limbic neural circuits could be a factor, as these regions influence emotions and motivation. However, it is important to note that conclusive evidence directly linking brain differences to criminality is still lacking.

The brain hemisphere division of labour theory suggests that most people use their non-speaking (right) hemisphere for perception and gross motor skills, while the specialised fine motor areas controlling speech are used to control fine motor movement in the dominant hand. As the right hand is controlled by the left hemisphere, and vice versa, most people are right-handed. However, this theory does not fully explain left-handedness, as the majority of left-handers have been found to have left-hemisphere language dominance, just like right-handers.

Genetic factors also play a role in handedness. Research suggests that evolutionary natural selection has resulted in a majority of individuals with speech and language control in the left hemisphere of the brain. As the left hemisphere also controls the movements of the right hand, this has contributed to a population biased towards right-hand preference. Additionally, there are two alleles associated with handedness: the D gene, which promotes right-hand preference, and the C gene, which results in a 50% chance of being either left- or right-handed.

Some studies have found a link between left-handedness and certain mental illnesses, such as schizophrenia. For example, a study by Yale University and the University of Texas found that the prevalence of left-handedness was average for mood disorders but rose to 40% for more serious forms of psychosis. However, other studies have produced mixed results, and the overall association between left-handedness and mental illness is not well understood.

While there may be a weak correlation between left-handedness and criminal activity, it is important to note that handedness alone does not determine criminal behaviour. Social, biological, and environmental factors also play a significant role.

School performance

While the relationship between left-handedness and school performance is complex and influenced by various factors, multiple studies have found that left-handed children may face unique challenges in academic settings.

One of the primary challenges left-handed children encounter relates to handedness preferences in the classroom. Many classrooms are designed with right-handed students in mind, from desk arrangements to the positioning of writing utensils and other equipment. This right-handed bias can create ergonomic challenges for left-handed students, potentially impacting their comfort and performance.

Research suggests that left-handed children may experience disadvantages in certain academic areas, particularly in the early years of schooling. Some studies have found that they tend to have lower scores on standardised tests, specifically in reading and writing. This disparity may be attributed in part to the dominant use of right-handed tools and methods in teaching, which can hinder the performance of left-handed students until they develop the necessary adaptations.

However, it is important to note that the relationship between handedness and school performance is not universally negative for left-handed individuals. Some studies suggest that left-handed children may excel in certain areas, such as creativity and spatial abilities. They may demonstrate stronger visual-spatial skills, which can be advantageous in fields like architecture, art, and engineering. Additionally, left-handed children might exhibit enhanced divergent thinking abilities, enabling them to approach problems from multiple perspectives and generate a wider range of solutions.

The impact of handedness on school performance may also be influenced by other factors, such as gender and age. Some research indicates that left-handed girls tend to outperform their right-handed counterparts in mathematics during their early school years, while left-handed boys may face more significant challenges in this subject area. Age can also play a role, as the differences in performance between left- and right-handed children tend to diminish as they progress through school, suggesting that left-handed individuals may overcome initial challenges as they adapt to the educational environment.

In conclusion, the relationship between left-handedness and school performance is multifaceted. While left-handed children may encounter challenges due to the prevalence of right-handed tools and methods in the classroom

Mental health

Left-handedness has been associated with an increased risk of certain mental health conditions, including psychotic disorders such as schizophrenia. Research suggests that the same brain differences that contribute to left-handedness may also contribute to these mental health disorders. For example, people with psychotic disorders may exhibit subtle brain damage during development due to maternal or childhood stress, which can also lead to less brain lateralization. This can result in abnormal processing of stimuli or thoughts, leading to psychosis.

Left-handedness has also been linked to an increased risk of other mental health conditions, such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression. A study by Choudhary and O'Carroll found that left-handed individuals were more likely to develop PTSD, possibly due to differences in how their brains process emotional events. Another study found that left-handers were about 5% more likely to experience depressive symptoms compared to right-handers.

However, it is important to note that being left-handed does not necessarily mean an individual will develop these mental health disorders. While there may be a correlation, the majority of left-handed people do not experience these issues. Additionally, left-handedness has been associated with certain benefits, such as increased creativity and verbal performance.

Frequently asked questions