Common-Law Marriage: Insurance Benefits Eligibility

Common-law marriage is a legally recognized form of marriage in certain states and countries. It is formed when a couple lives together for a certain period and holds themselves out as a married couple. Common-law marriages are generally recognized by employers and insurers, and common-law spouses are entitled to the same benefits as traditionally married spouses, including health insurance and leave benefits. However, the recognition of common-law marriage varies across different states and countries, and some may require additional documentation or proof of the marriage. This raises questions about the eligibility of common-law spouses for insurance benefits, especially when crossing state or country borders.

Common-law marriage and insurance benefits across different US states

In the US, common-law marriage is a legally recognised form of marriage in certain states. However, the recognition of common-law marriage varies across different states, which can impact insurance benefits for spouses and dependents. Here is an overview of how common-law marriage affects insurance benefits in different US states:

States Recognising Common-Law Marriage

In states that recognise common-law marriage, such as Texas, a common-law spouse is generally entitled to the same insurance benefits as a traditionally married spouse. This includes health insurance and leave benefits. For example, under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), an employee in Texas has the right to enrol their common-law spouse and dependent children for health coverage. Additionally, according to the Texas State Library, a common-law marriage may be proven by evidence that the couple lives together as a married couple, with the intention to have an exclusive relationship similar to a traditional marriage.

States Not Recognising Common-Law Marriage

Some states, like New York, do not recognise common-law marriage within their own state. However, New York will recognise a common-law marriage established in another state that does validate it. In this case, a common-law spouse from another state may be eligible for insurance benefits in New York. This is in accordance with the Full Faith and Credit Clause of the US Constitution, which requires states to respect the laws and legal decisions of other states, including those pertaining to common-law marriage.

Self-Insured Plans and COBRA Rights

Self-insured plans are not subject to state regulation and may choose to exclude common-law spouses from their definition of a spouse. However, doing so carries the risk of an employee challenging the exclusion as a violation of state law. Additionally, under COBRA, both common-law and statutory marriages have identical rights. This means that upon divorce or separation, a former common-law spouse may continue health coverage under certain plans, just like in a traditional marriage.

In conclusion, while common-law marriage can qualify for insurance benefits, the specific benefits available depend on the state in which the common-law marriage was established and the insurance provider's policies. It is important for employers to have clear plan terms and for individuals to understand the requirements and recognition of common-law marriage in their respective states.

Common-law marriage and health insurance

A common-law marriage is a valid and legal way for a couple to marry in certain states. However, it can create complexities when it comes to health insurance benefits. While all states recognize a valid common-law marriage, insurers are subject to state regulations and must adhere to the definition of "spouse" as established by the state.

The deciding factor in recognizing a common-law marriage for health insurance enrollment is the state in which the marriage was established. If a couple with a common-law marriage moves to another state, their marriage will be recognized even if the new state does not typically allow common-law marriages. Some employers or insurers may require proof of the common-law marriage, such as a signed affidavit, joint tax returns, or lease agreements, before enrolling a spouse in a health plan.

Under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), employees have the right to enroll their new spouse and dependent children for health coverage. These rights extend equally to common-law spouses and children. The children of a common-law spouse, born before or after the marriage, can be eligible for insurance coverage as dependents under a family medical plan.

Employers that sponsor insured health and welfare plans generally cannot exclude common-law spouses from those plans. However, a self-insured plan may choose to exclude common-law spouses if they cannot substantiate the marriage under applicable state law. It is important to note that the dissolution of a common-law marriage requires a divorce decree, and COBRA rights to continue health coverage may apply after a divorce.

Common-law marriage and employer-provided insurance

In the US, common-law marriage is a valid and legal way for a couple to marry in certain states. However, not all states recognise common-law marriage, and this can cause issues when it comes to employer-provided insurance benefits.

Recognition of Common-Law Marriage

The Full Faith and Credit clause of the US Constitution requires a state to accept as valid a common-law marriage established in a state that recognises it, even if the couple then moves to a state that does not recognise common-law marriage. This means that, for insurance purposes, the deciding factor in recognising a common-law marriage is the state in which the marriage was established.

Insurance Coverage for Common-Law Spouses

Insurers are subject to state regulation and must adhere to the definition of "spouse" established and accepted by the state. This means that a common-law spouse would be viewed as the legal spouse of the insured, and an insurer may extend coverage to them under a family medical plan.

Documentation

Some employers or insurers may require a signed affidavit from an employee to recognise the common-law marriage before enrolling a common-law spouse on the health plan. Employers may also require proof of the common-law marriage, such as joint tax returns, checking accounts, mortgage or lease agreements, or other requirements specified under the state law that recognises common-law marriage.

Children of Common-Law Spouses

The children of a common-law spouse, even those born prior to the marriage, are not precluded from being covered as dependents under a family medical plan. This is because children have a presumption of legitimacy and would be considered dependents eligible for health coverage.

Exclusions

Self-insured plans may choose to exclude common-law spouses from their definition of a spouse. However, employers that sponsor insured health and welfare plans generally cannot exclude common-law spouses from those plans.

Common-law marriage and family medical plans

In the United States, common-law marriage is a valid and legal way for a couple to marry in certain states, such as Texas. Although the act of living together as a married couple may establish a common-law marriage in these states, it is important to note that cohabitation is not the only requirement. A common-law marriage typically requires living together as a married couple for a sufficient period and with the intention of having an exclusive relationship akin to a formal marriage.

The recognition of common-law marriage can have implications for employer-sponsored health and welfare plans. Under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), employees have the right to enroll a new spouse and dependent children for health coverage. This right extends equally to common-law spouses and their children, who are presumed to be legitimate and are considered eligible dependents.

However, common-law marriage can raise complex issues for employer-sponsored benefits. Insurers and employers must adhere to the definition of "spouse" established by the state in which the common-law marriage was established. While some states recognize common-law marriage, others may not, creating challenges when a couple moves to a new state. Some employers or insurers may require proof of common-law marriage, such as a signed affidavit, joint tax returns, or lease agreements, before enrolling a common-law spouse in a health plan.

In the context of family medical plans, a common-law spouse would typically be viewed as the legal spouse of the insured, provided that a valid common-law marriage exists. This means that an insurer may extend coverage to a common-law spouse and their children under a family medical plan. The specific laws and provisions governing this vary by state, and it is essential to refer to the relevant state laws and insurance regulations.

Common-law marriage and leave benefits

Common-law marriage and its impact on leave benefits can be a confusing topic for employers and employees alike. While common-law marriage is recognised in eight states and Washington, D.C., it can still be challenging to determine the rights and responsibilities of these spouses regarding employee benefits.

The Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) provides some clarity on this issue. Under the FMLA, employers of a certain size are required to offer up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave for specific reasons, including caring for a spouse with a serious health condition or addressing issues related to a spouse's military service. Importantly, the FMLA defines "spouse" as including common-law spouses, as recognised by the state where the marriage was established. This definition also applies to same-sex marriages.

Additionally, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) grants employees the right to enrol their spouse and dependent children in health coverage. This right extends equally to common-law spouses and their children. In the context of health insurance, employers that offer spousal coverage must include common-law spouses in their definition of "spouse" and allow their enrolment, just as they would for a traditionally married couple. Furthermore, under a common-law marriage, children are presumed to be legitimate dependents and are thus eligible for health coverage.

However, it's worth noting that not all states recognise common-law marriage, and the laws surrounding it can be complex. Some self-insured plans may choose to exclude common-law spouses from their definition of "spouse," creating challenges for employees seeking to enrol their spouses in these plans. In such cases, employees may need to provide documentation to validate their common-law marriage, such as joint tax returns, checking accounts, or other evidence specified by the state.

To summarise, while common-law marriage is recognised for leave benefits, the specific laws and requirements can vary by state. Employers should aim for clear and consistent policies regarding the recognition of common-law marriages to ensure fair treatment for all employees and avoid potential legal complications.

Frequently asked questions