Lawyer-Client Confidentiality: Can A Lawyer Turn You In?

Lawyers play a crucial role in the legal system, providing guidance, advice, and defence to their clients. However, a question that often arises is whether a lawyer can turn in their client to the authorities. While there is a general expectation of confidentiality between lawyers and their clients, this relationship is not without limits. In certain situations, lawyers may be faced with the ethical dilemma of whether to report their client's intentions or risk potential harm. So, can a lawyer turn you in?

Confidentiality between a lawyer and client

The concept of confidentiality between a lawyer and their client is a cornerstone of the legal profession. This privilege allows clients to speak freely and confidentially with their lawyer, enabling the lawyer to provide the best possible legal advice and representation. While lawyers typically maintain client confidentiality, there are exceptions where a lawyer may be ethically or legally obligated to disclose information or take action to protect others from harm.

In most jurisdictions, lawyers have a duty to report or take action if their client poses an imminent risk of harm to themselves or others. For example, if a client discloses plans to commit a violent act or harm another person, the lawyer may be required to notify the authorities to prevent the harm from occurring. This duty to report exists even when the lawyer believes the client may not be serious or intends to carry out the act. In such cases, the lawyer may disclose limited information to the authorities, such as the nature of the threat, while still protecting the client's confidentiality to the extent possible.

Additionally, lawyers may disclose confidential information to defend themselves against accusations of wrongdoing related to their representation of the client. This exception allows lawyers to protect their own interests and ensure they can continue practising law while upholding their ethical obligations.

It is important to note that the rules of confidentiality can vary between different legal systems and jurisdictions. For example, in the United States, each state may have specific rules regarding attorney-client confidentiality, with some states allowing for disclosure in cases of imminent harm. In Canada, solicitor-client privilege can be set aside for the protection of the public.

While lawyers uphold client confidentiality, they also have a duty to assist their clients within ethical boundaries. This includes advising clients on the legal path, guiding them through legal processes, and defending them from past actions. Lawyers can provide valuable guidance on navigating the legal system, protecting their rights, and achieving the best possible outcome within the bounds of the law.

Exceptions to confidentiality

Attorney-client privilege, or lawyer-client privilege, is a common law doctrine that protects most communications between clients and their lawyers. However, there are exceptions to this privilege where lawyers are allowed to disclose confidential information. Here are some detailed examples of these exceptions:

Crime-Fraud Exception

The crime-fraud exception is one of the most well-known exceptions to attorney-client privilege. This exception applies when a client's communication with their attorney is made with the intention of committing or covering up a crime or fraud. In such cases, the attorney may disclose confidential information to prevent or remedy the potential harm caused by the client's actions. This exception is not limited solely to crimes but may also apply to civil matters, such as unlawful eviction.

Probate of a Last Will and Testament

In the case of a deceased client, previously confidential communications between the lawyer and the client may be disclosed to prove the intent of the decedent, especially in cases where there are disputes over the interpretation of the will or other estate planning documents.

Initiating Proceedings Against the Lawyer

If a client initiates legal proceedings against their lawyer, they effectively waive their rights to confidentiality. This is to ensure procedural fairness, as the lawyer must be able to defend themselves and reveal relevant information related to the case.

Risk of Imminent Harm

In most jurisdictions, attorneys may disclose confidential information if their client poses a risk of imminent harm to themselves or others. This includes situations where there is a threat of death, serious injury, or bodily harm. Attorneys are typically only allowed to disclose limited information necessary to address the concern.

Self-Defence

Lawyers may disclose confidential information to defend themselves against accusations of wrongdoing connected to their representation of the client. This exception ensures that attorneys can protect themselves from potential legal consequences arising from their representation.

Surrendering to authorities

Surrendering to the authorities can be a daunting process, but there are several benefits to turning yourself in. Firstly, it demonstrates cooperation with the police, which can be seen as a mitigating factor and may help to reduce the severity of any penalties you may face. Voluntarily surrendering can also help you build an effective criminal defence and give you the chance to work with a criminal defence solicitor, who can guide you through the legal process and ensure you do not give up any of your constitutional rights.

If you believe you are wanted by the authorities, the first step should be to contact a criminal defence lawyer, who can advise you on your next steps and ensure you do not make any incriminating statements. Your lawyer may also be able to help facilitate your surrender and be on alert as to the progress of your arrest. They can also help you obtain a bondsman and contact your family.

There are two main ways to surrender to the authorities. The first is to go to the authorities after consultation with your lawyer and be met by a bondsman, or have the authorities collect you and be met by a bondsman at the jail. The second option is to arrange a court appearance if there is a complaint on file and surrender on the warrant before an arrest is made.

When you turn yourself in, you will need a form of government-issued photo identification so that officials can confirm your identity and ensure the correct person is being booked for the correct charges.

Lawyers assisting in the legal process

Lawyers play a crucial role in assisting individuals navigate the complex legal landscape, ensuring they understand their rights and make informed decisions. While lawyers cannot disclose what their clients have done, they may reveal information about future intentions if it poses a risk of harm to others. In such cases, lawyers can assist clients in surrendering to authorities in a controlled manner.

When facing criminal charges, individuals have the right to legal representation, and lawyers can provide critical support throughout the legal process. They can help clients understand their Miranda Rights, which include the right to remain silent, the right to have an attorney present during questioning, and the right to a court-appointed attorney if they cannot afford one. Lawyers can also assist in filing motions to protect their client's rights, such as ensuring that any statements made without legal representation cannot be used against them in court.

In the event of an arrest, lawyers can guide clients through the bail process, helping them understand the amount of bail required and the options for posting bail. They can also provide advice on dealing with the booking process and representing their clients in court. Additionally, lawyers can review case details and advise on potential mishandling, which may result in getting a warrant cleared without a court appearance.

For those with existing warrants, seeking legal counsel is advisable. Lawyers can assist in organising a discreet arrest, minimising potential embarrassment, and may even help resolve lesser charges without the need for a court visit. They can also provide guidance on surrendering to authorities, ensuring the process is handled smoothly and with the client's best interests in mind.

In conclusion, lawyers play an essential role in assisting individuals through the legal process, ensuring their rights are protected and providing strategic guidance tailored to their specific circumstances. While confidentiality is paramount, lawyers may break it in extreme cases where there is a serious threat to self or others.

Lawyers defending clients from past actions

Lawyers play a crucial role in defending clients from past actions, ensuring that the legal process is followed and their clients' rights are protected. While the specifics of lawyer-client confidentiality vary across jurisdictions, there are generally accepted guidelines that lawyers adhere to when defending clients from past actions.

Firstly, it is essential to understand the distinction between "legal guilt" and "factual guilt". Legal guilt refers to whether the prosecution can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused committed the crime. On the other hand, factual guilt pertains to whether the defendant actually committed the act in question. A criminal defence lawyer's primary role is to ensure that the prosecution meets the high standard of proving legal guilt, regardless of the defendant's factual guilt.

In most jurisdictions, lawyers are not required to disclose past actions confessed by their clients. Instead, they focus their defence strategies on the government's failure to prove all the elements of the crime. For example, a lawyer might challenge the reliability of evidence, raise doubts about witness credibility, or argue for mitigating circumstances that reduce the severity of punishment.

Additionally, lawyers can assist clients in obtaining character references, apology letters, and medical or psychological reports to bolster their defence. They may also advise clients to enrol in rehabilitation programs or traffic offender programs to demonstrate remorse and increase the chances of a favourable outcome.

While lawyers typically maintain client confidentiality, there are exceptions. In some jurisdictions, lawyers may break confidentiality if their client poses an imminent risk of harm to themselves or others. In such cases, lawyers may notify the authorities or take steps to ensure the safety of those at risk. Nonetheless, competent attorneys will usually assist clients in arranging a surrender or court appearance rather than directly turning them in.

Frequently asked questions