Mayors And Laws: Who Holds The Power?

In the United States, the mayor is the executive of a town or city and typically controls local law enforcement. However, the powers of a mayor vary from state to state and city to city. In some cities, the mayor has a strong government, while in others, they act more like a city-wide councilor. While mayors can propose legislation, it is usually the city council that creates and passes laws. Once a bill is passed by the council, it is presented to the mayor, who can sign it into law, veto it, or take no action. Therefore, a mayor typically cannot pass a law by themselves.

Mayoral approval of a bill

The powers of a mayor vary from state to state and city to city in the United States. While mayors typically control local law enforcement, they do not have the power to pass a law or a bill by themselves. The process of passing a bill involves multiple stakeholders and steps.

Once a bill is passed by the Council, it is presented to the Mayor. The Mayor has the authority to approve or veto the bill. If the Mayor approves the bill, it becomes a law and is added to the City's Administrative Code. If the Mayor vetoes the bill, it is sent back to the Council, which can override the Mayor's veto with a two-thirds vote. In some cities, such as Seattle, the Council needs at least six members to vote to override the Mayor's veto.

The Council is responsible for creating and passing laws that govern the city. They write and pass local laws that impact the day-to-day lives of residents, workers, and visitors to the city. The Council also has the power to pass resolutions on state and federal issues relevant to the city. These resolutions allow the Council to express the collective voice of the city and can influence public policy and law development at the state and national levels.

In addition to passing laws, the Council also controls the budget for local law enforcement and votes on the laws governing their actions. The Council Committees play a crucial role in studying specific issues and ensuring that differing community needs are acknowledged. They make recommendations for the entire Council body to consider and vote on at Stated Meetings. Each Council Committee is supported by a team of staff attorneys and analysts, who assist in arranging public hearings and providing legal and policy research.

While the Mayor has a significant role in approving or vetoing bills, the ultimate decision-making power lies with the Council. The Mayor's approval is essential, but it is the Council that has the authority to pass laws and override a Mayor's veto if necessary. Therefore, it requires a collaborative effort between the Mayor and the Council to pass a bill successfully.

Mayoral veto power

In the United States, the president can use the veto power to prevent a bill passed by Congress from becoming law. Similarly, mayors in a mayor-council government often have a veto power over local ordinances passed by the city council. This power is a typical feature of "strong mayor" systems, where the mayor is the chief executive and the council is limited to legislative matters. These systems are more common in large cities.

Mayors in the early 19th century were often appointed and served one-year terms. However, as cities grew, the mayoral role evolved into an independently elected office with multi-year terms, strengthening the position. This shift towards a more robust mayoral role led to mayoral veto powers becoming more common, especially after 1850.

The mayor's veto power allows them to reject or block a decision or piece of legislation passed by the city council. This power applies to ordinances, orders, bylaws, resolutions, contracts, awards, and claims. For example, the mayor of New York has the power to veto bills passed by the council. If the mayor vetoes a bill, it is sent back to the council, which can override the veto with a two-thirds vote.

It is important to note that not all mayors have veto power. The mayor of Houston, for instance, does not possess this authority. Additionally, the proportion of council votes required to override a veto varies; while a two-thirds vote is most common, some cities, like San Diego, require a higher threshold of five-eighths.

The role of the City Council

The Council also has the power to pass resolutions on state and federal issues, including State Legislation Resolutions (SLRs), where they can request the state legislature to pass special laws affecting the city. These resolutions allow the Council to express the collective voice of the city and influence law and public policy development beyond the local level.

The Council's legislative process typically involves committees that study specific topics and make recommendations for the full Council to consider and vote on. These committees ensure that diverse community needs are considered, and they are supported by staff attorneys and analysts who facilitate public hearings and provide necessary research.

Once a bill is passed by the Council, it is presented to the Mayor for approval. The Mayor can sign the bill into law, veto it, or take no action. If vetoed, the bill returns to the Council, which has the power to override the Mayor's veto with a supermajority vote, typically two-thirds of the Council members. This process demonstrates the checks and balances between the Mayor and the City Council in the law-making process.

The City Council also plays a crucial role in deciding how taxes are spent. While they don't typically levy taxes, they vote on the budget for local law enforcement, ensuring that the Mayor's powers are balanced and that the city's finances are allocated according to the community's needs.

The Mayor's power over the police

A mayor cannot pass a law by themselves. Once a bill is passed by the Council, it is presented to the Mayor, who has 30 days to either sign the bill into law, veto it, or take no action. If the Mayor does not sign or veto the bill within 30 days, it becomes law.

In other cities, the Mayor's power to direct and control the police force is more limited. For example, in Jacksonville, the Mayor has the power to "'preserve the peace within the city' and 'take care that all laws and ordinances concerning the city are duly respected.' The Mayor's power over the police force is subject to rules and regulations prescribed by the city commission.

In some cases, the city commission has placed the chief of police as the head of the police department, with the authority for the internal management of the department. The Mayor's power to oversee the faithful execution of the laws may be exercised through the office of the chief of police.

Overall, while the Mayor has some influence over the police through their executive powers, their specific powers regarding the police force vary depending on the city's charter and the policies prescribed by the city council.

The Mayor's power to spend taxes

While the mayor does not have the power to pass a law by themselves, they do have a role to play in the legislative process. The mayor's power to spend taxes is limited and subject to the approval of the City Council. The mayor is responsible for spending the taxes collected in a way that is decided on by the City Council, which votes on the budget for different departments.

In the United States, the federal system diffuses power among different layers of government, with states devolving powers and responsibilities to local governments. The structure of local governments varies, but mayors generally have considerable formal and informal powers. They often act as the CEOs of local governments, responsible for the overall management of city agencies and departments, as well as the appointment of board members and senior staff.

Mayors typically do not have the power to levy taxes, as this falls under the legislative branch's purview, usually the City Council. However, they do have some influence over certain taxes, particularly property taxes, and can propose or support initiatives to raise taxes or seek dedicated tax sources through ballot initiatives. The mayor's role in the budgetary process is crucial, as they work with the City Council to pass a balanced budget and lobby for aid in areas like housing, transportation, and schools.

In some cases, the mayor's power to spend taxes may be constrained by external factors, such as the need to borrow funds during economic downturns or the intervention of higher levels of government to address financial crises, as seen in the case of New York City in the 1970s. Additionally, the mayor's power can be checked by the City Council, which can override a mayoral veto with a supermajority vote.

While the specifics may vary depending on the city and state, the mayor's power to spend taxes is an essential aspect of their role in local governance. It allows them to influence the allocation of resources and shape the city's vision and strategy, often in collaboration with other stakeholders.

Frequently asked questions