Nonprofit Bylaws: Can They Prohibit Assistance?

Non-profit organisations are those that do not exist to make a profit but to promote, support or advance an issue, group, goal or idea. Non-profit bylaws are the main governing documents of the organisation and outline the rules and operating procedures. Non-profit bylaws can prohibit assistance in the form of indemnification, which limits the personal liability of board members. In some cases, nonprofits are prohibited from indemnifying directors and officers, and in other cases, they are required to do so. Non-profit bylaws can also outline compensation arrangements for directors, officers and employees, and the number of votes needed to terminate an executive director. Non-profit bylaws can also prohibit assistance by outlining conflict of interest policies, which require board members and key staff members to report any potential conflicts of interest. Non-profit bylaws must comply with state laws, and in some cases, city regulations. For example, non-profit bylaws in India prohibit the payment of any dividend to its members and prohibit discrimination against citizens on the grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth. Non-profit bylaws in the US relate to taxation and the prevention of charitable fraud.

Non-profit bylaws are legal documents that guide the board's actions and decisions

Non-profit bylaws are the main governing documents for a non-profit organisation. They are legally binding and are a requirement for incorporation. Bylaws are created by the board when the organisation is established and guide the board's actions and decisions. They are also referred to as the operating manual and outline rules regarding authority, rights, and processes.

The bylaws should be detailed enough to provide clear guidance but flexible enough to allow for changes and growth. They should be reviewed regularly to ensure they remain relevant and reflect how the organisation works. While bylaws are unique to each organisation, they generally have a similar structure and use. Non-profit bylaws are public record and are often made available by the board upon request.

The process of creating bylaws can be complex, and it is recommended to consult a lawyer to ensure compliance with state laws and regulations. State laws may dictate specific provisions, while others give more general guidelines. It is important to be aware of the applicable state law and any additional city regulations. Some states require nonprofits to file their bylaws, while others do not. Non-profit organisations should also be aware of any changes in their status, activities, or structure that may require amendments to their bylaws.

Overall, non-profit bylaws are essential for the effective functioning of a non-profit organisation, providing a framework for its operations and ensuring legal compliance.

Bylaws are the main governing document for a non-profit organisation

The board of directors creates bylaws when establishing the organisation. Bylaws supplement the rules already defined by the state corporations code and guide how the non-profit runs. They define the fundamental rules governing the non-profit and should not include information that changes frequently, such as staff job descriptions, fundraising or marketing guidelines, and charters. Instead, this type of information is better suited for procedure or policy manuals. Bylaws should be reviewed regularly and amended as necessary as the organisation evolves.

State nonprofit laws usually address nonprofit governance matters, and it is possible to choose different rules as long as they do not violate state law and are included in the bylaws. If following state law, restating them in the bylaws ensures that all operating rules are in one document. While the IRS does not require specific language in the bylaws of exempt organisations, many state laws dictate that tax-exempt organisations must have a clear operating procedure, often outlined in the bylaws. Some cities have further regulations for non-profits.

Bylaws are not public documents, but making them readily available increases an organisation's accountability and transparency and encourages the board to pay closer attention to them. They also raise the level of accountability, transparency, and effectiveness of all non-profit organisations, fostering excellence in their service and inspiring trust.

Non-profits must comply with state laws and regulations

Non-profit organizations are subject to federal, state, and local laws and regulations. While they are exempt from paying taxes, they must comply with various legal requirements to maintain their tax-exempt status. Non-profits are generally required to reinvest profits back into their organization to support their tax-exempt purpose, rather than distributing profits to owners or shareholders.

Non-profits must adhere to specific regulations depending on their type, such as 501(c)(3) entities, which are prohibited from endorsing or opposing political candidates by the Johnson Amendment. They must also comply with minimum wage laws, workers' compensation insurance requirements, and liability insurance is recommended. Additionally, non-profits should be mindful of lobbying restrictions, as 501(c)(3) organizations can only lobby to a limited extent, while 501(c)(4) and 501(c)(6) organizations face no such limitations.

State laws and regulations play a crucial role in governing non-profit organizations. Most states require Federal tax exemption approval, often in the form of a "determination letter," to grant State tax exemption. Non-profits must comply with state laws regulating charitable fundraising and ensure their activities align with their charter or trust instrument's specified tax-exempt purpose. The attorney general's office or another state government entity typically maintains a list of registered non-profits and investigates complaints of fraud and abuse.

Non-profits should also be aware of state-specific variations in laws and regulations. For example, some states have laws prohibiting minors from serving on boards or signing binding contracts, which can impact the eligibility of young people to serve in certain roles within the organization. Additionally, state laws may dictate the governance structure and policies outlined in the non-profit's bylaws, which provide detailed guidelines for effective and ethical functioning.

To summarize, non-profits must navigate a complex landscape of federal, state, and local laws and regulations to maintain compliance and their tax-exempt status. While they enjoy certain privileges, such as tax exemption, they must carefully manage their funds, activities, and governance structures to remain within legal boundaries. Seeking legal expertise and staying informed about applicable laws are essential steps for non-profits to operate sustainably and fulfill their missions.

Non-profit bylaws must outline compensation arrangements for directors, officers, and employees

Non-profit bylaws are a non-profit organisation's operating manual and main governing document. They are crucial in preventing and resolving conflicts and disagreements, providing rules around authority levels, rights, and expectations. While the IRS does not require specific language in the bylaws of exempt organisations, many state laws dictate that tax-exempt organisations must have a clear operating procedure, often outlined in bylaws.

The bylaws should also consider the culture of the organisation, the number of people involved in managing it, and the expectations and attitudes of the members and directors. The use of the words "shall" and "may" is crucial: "shall" should be used when board members are required to do something, and "may" when a task is optional. This will help to avoid ambiguity. It is also important to only include provisions that are realistic. For example, do not require a 2/3 approval of every member eligible to vote if you have not been able to get 2/3 of members to vote in practice.

Bylaws should be reviewed approximately every two years. They should be amended when there are major changes in the organisation's status, activities, or structure. The bylaws should also be in accordance with state laws, and a qualified professional experienced in non-profit matters should be consulted when drafting or amending them.

Non-profits must be vigilant about potential conflicts of interest

A conflict of interest policy should require those with a conflict to disclose the conflict and prohibit interested board members from voting on any matter in which there is a conflict. It is important to create a culture of candour, where board directors can express conflicts of interest without fear of judgment. Many non-profits circulate a questionnaire each year to find out whether any board or staff members have a conflict of interest. Some states, such as New York, require non-profit organisations to have a conflict of interest policy and provide guidance for drafting the policy.

In addition to state laws, it is important to be aware of federal laws governing non-profit organisations. For example, the inurement prohibition law describes the act of an insider unfairly benefiting from the actions and/or resources of a non-profit. Non-profits must also be aware of laws regarding their tax-exempt status. For example, political activity is strictly prohibited for charities, and a violation of this law may result in an organisation losing its tax-exempt status.

To avoid conflicts of interest, non-profits should keep board composition diverse and board size adequate to encourage robust discussion and bring all viewpoints to the table. It is also important to discuss potential conflicts and how they will be dealt with when recruiting new board members. Non-profits should also be aware of the potential for conflicts of interest when staff members are involved in board meetings and voting.

Frequently asked questions