Non-Profit Organizations: Law Enforcers Or Not?

Non-profit organizations are generally subject to the same laws as for-profit businesses, with some exceptions, such as tax exemptions and certain anti-discrimination laws. Non-profits are organized under state law and must comply with state requirements for non-profits, which vary across different states. For example, some states exempt non-profits from state taxes and state employment programs, while others give immunity or limit tort liability. Non-profits must also comply with federal laws and can be held accountable by the state attorney-general's office and the IRS. While non-profits can engage in revenue-generating activities, their purpose must be charitable, educational, religious, or scientific, and any profits must be reinvested into the organization. Non-profits can have their own bylaws, which are legally binding, and any violations can result in legal consequences, including fines, penalties, disbandment, or loss of tax-exempt status.

Characteristics of Non-Profit Organizations and Their Enforcement of Laws

Non-profit organizations and tax laws

Non-profit organizations are formed for purposes other than generating profit, and no part of the income is distributed to members, directors, or officers. Non-profit corporations are often termed "non-stock corporations" and can take the form of a corporation, an individual enterprise, an unincorporated association, a partnership, or a foundation.

Non-profit organizations are generally exempt from federal income taxes under subsection 501(c) of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) tax code. To qualify for tax exemption, non-profits must be organized for a charitable purpose, such as educational, religious, or other specified purposes. These include social welfare organizations, civic leagues, social clubs, labor organizations, and business leagues. Non-profits can engage in revenue-generating activities, but any income generated must be reinvested back into the organization to support its tax-exempt purpose.

To attain tax-exempt status, non-profit organizations must meet certain requirements and apply to the IRS and relevant state agencies. For example, in Texas, non-profit organizations must file a certificate of formation with the secretary of state, which includes a required purpose clause and a dissolution of assets provision. Non-profit organizations that engage in activities unrelated to their primary purpose may be required to pay income taxes on that income. Additionally, non-profits are subject to greater oversight by authorities and regulators, and their tax-exempt status can be revoked if they fail to submit required annual filings.

Some states exempt non-profit organizations from state taxes and state employment programs, while others provide immunity or limitations on tort liability. However, non-profits can still be held liable for injuries caused by their employees or volunteers to third parties. While non-profits are generally exempt from federal income taxes, they may still be subject to other taxes, such as state sales tax or property tax, depending on the specific state laws and the organization's activities.

Non-profit organizations and employment laws

Non-profit organizations are subject to many of the same employment laws as for-profit companies. For example, non-profits must withhold and pay employees' state, federal, and local income taxes. They are also responsible for providing employees with written guidance in the form of a human resources handbook or employee manual. This manual should reflect the nonprofit's philosophy, values, and culture, while also notifying employees of their rights, responsibilities, and benefits.

In the United States, the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) sets the minimum wage, overtime, record-keeping, and child labor standards. The FLSA applies to employees of non-profit organizations that engage in ordinary commercial activities resulting in at least $500,000 in annual sales. These activities include operating a gift shop or providing veterinary services for a fee. Employees of non-profit organizations that do not meet these criteria may still be protected by the FLSA if they are individually engaged in interstate commerce or the production of goods for interstate commerce. Volunteers, on the other hand, are generally not considered employees for FLSA purposes if they freely volunteer without the expectation of compensation.

Additionally, non-profit organizations must comply with state and federal employment laws, such as providing reasonable accommodations to disabled employees under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the requirement to implement and distribute a policy on lactation accommodations. Non-profits may also be exempt from certain laws, such as state taxes and state employment programs like unemployment compensation contributions. Some states also exempt non-profits from tort liability.

It is important to note that each state in the US may have different definitions and laws regarding non-profit organizations. Therefore, it is essential for non-profits to be familiar with the specific laws and regulations in the state(s) in which they operate.

Non-profit organizations and liability laws

Non-profit organizations are generally subject to the same laws as for-profit businesses, with some exceptions. Non-profits are often exempt from taxation, provided they are organized and operated exclusively for charitable, religious, or educational purposes. However, they must comply with minimum wage laws and obtain workers' compensation insurance if they have paid staff. Non-profits can also be held vicariously liable for injuries caused by their employees or volunteers to third parties.

While non-profits don't have shareholders, their staff, board members, and officers may be concerned about limited liability protection. Once incorporated, a non-profit's directors, trustees, officers, employees, and volunteers are usually shielded from personal liability for the organization's debts or liabilities. However, directors and officers can be held personally liable if they engage in fraudulent or illegal activities, fail to ensure tax compliance, or breach their fiduciary duties.

To mitigate the risk of lawsuits, non-profits are encouraged to obtain liability insurance. The increase in lawsuits against non-profits has led to a rise in insurance coverage litigation as organizations seek to recover legal costs from their insurers. Additionally, some states have enacted laws granting immunity or protection to volunteers of non-profits, provided they acted in good faith and in the organization's best interests.

Non-profit organizations must also navigate state-specific laws and regulations. Some states exempt non-profits from state taxes and unemployment compensation contributions, while others provide immunity from tort liability. Each state defines a non-profit differently, and organizations must meet the specific requirements set by their state to maintain their non-profit status.

In conclusion, while non-profit organizations enjoy certain exemptions and protections, they are still subject to various liability laws and must take steps to protect themselves from legal risks, including obtaining insurance coverage and complying with state and federal regulations.

Non-profit organizations and anti-discrimination laws

Non-profit organizations are generally subject to the same anti-discrimination laws as for-profit entities. These laws are primarily governed by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, which prohibits employment discrimination based on race, colour, religion, sex, pregnancy, sexual preference, transgender status, and national origin. Non-profits with 15 or more employees are required to comply with Title VII.

However, there are some exceptions to these rules. Religious organizations and certain educational organizations affiliated with a religion are exempt from Title VII when making hiring and employment decisions based on an individual's religion. Additionally, some states have enacted their own anti-discrimination laws, and the specific definitions and requirements of non-profit organizations may vary across states.

It is important to note that discrimination laws also apply to other aspects of non-profit operations. For example, non-profits that receive federal funding or contracts can lose these privileges if they engage in discriminatory practices. Furthermore, discrimination is a civil offense, and victims can sue for lost wages, damages, and attorney's fees. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission investigates allegations of discrimination and may initiate legal action on behalf of employees.

While non-profits may have certain exemptions from taxation and specific state laws, they are generally subject to the same anti-discrimination laws as for-profit entities. Non-profits must be vigilant in complying with applicable anti-discrimination laws to avoid legal consequences and maintain their commitment to social impact and public benefit.

Non-profit organizations and bylaws

Non-profit organizations are subject to the laws that govern for-profit businesses, except for some tax and First Amendment-related exceptions. Non-profit corporations are formed under state law, and each state defines non-profits differently. Some states have adopted the Revised Model Nonprofit Corporation Act (1986), while others have adopted the Uniform Unincorporated Nonprofit Association Act.

Bylaws are a non-profit organization's operating manual, defining the size of the board and how it will function, the roles and duties of directors and officers, and the rules and procedures for holding meetings. They are the internal rules and regulations that guide the board's activities. While bylaws are not public documents, making them readily available increases an organization's accountability and transparency and encourages the board to pay closer attention to them.

When filing for tax-exempt status, it is good practice to include the bylaws if they have already been drafted. Even if they are not considered public, distributing them to anyone who requests a copy increases transparency and accountability. The bylaws should be regularly reviewed and amended as the organization evolves. If changes are made, they must be reported to the IRS on the next annual report (990).

In the case of a missing or lost copy of the original bylaws, a non-profit can file a Form 4506-B to request an original copy of their exemption application from the IRS, which can take up to 12 months. In the meantime, the board can adopt new bylaws, noting in the minutes the efforts made to find the previous version.

Frequently asked questions