Paper Bag Legalities: Closed Container Law Explained

The use of paper bags to carry alcohol purchased from liquor stores is a common practice in the United States. Many people believe that concealing alcoholic beverages in a paper bag allows them to drink in public without violating open container laws. However, this is a misconception, and drinking alcohol from a paper bag does not shield an individual from criminal charges. Open container laws vary across different states, counties, and cities, but the majority of states prohibit possessing or consuming open containers of alcohol in public areas. While a paper bag may provide a level of privacy and make it difficult to visually identify the contents, it does not provide legal protection. Law enforcement officers can still enforce open container laws if they have reasonable suspicion that an individual is consuming alcohol in public, regardless of whether it is concealed in a paper bag.

Paper bags and open container laws

Open container laws prohibit people from having an alcoholic beverage in an open container in public. These laws vary from state to state, with each county and city having its own specific statute. For example, in New York City, a violation of the open container law can result in a $25 fine or even up to 5 days in jail. In North Carolina, open container laws apply to both motor vehicles and public places, and a violation is considered a Class 1 misdemeanor.

Despite the iconic brown paper bag often wrapped around drinks, it does little to protect a person from being ticketed for carrying an open container in public. In fact, attempting to conceal an alcoholic beverage in a paper bag can even draw more attention to the individual, increasing their chances of being arrested. While it may provide plausible deniability by making it impossible to identify the contents as alcohol by sight, law enforcement officers can still use other means, such as smell, to suspect the presence of alcohol.

Additionally, the paper bag itself is not considered a "closed container" under the law. The term "container" typically refers to the original packaging, such as the can or bottle, and not the bag used to carry it. This distinction is important, as it further clarifies that a paper bag does not provide legal protection under open container laws.

While the use of paper bags for alcohol purchases may be a common practice or even a store policy, it is not a legal requirement in any state. Some stores may have their own bagging policies for proof of purchase or to protect fragile glass bottles. However, it is important to note that unnecessary bagging can have negative environmental impacts.

State-specific open container laws

Open container laws in the United States prohibit the possession and consumption of open alcoholic beverages in public spaces and vehicles. While these laws are largely similar across the US, there are some state-specific variations. Here is a look at some state-specific open container laws:

Illinois

In Illinois, it is illegal to possess or consume an open alcoholic beverage in public. The Illinois Liquor Control Commission clarifies that a paper bag is not considered a "closed container," and drinking from an open container inside a paper bag is still a violation of the law. Additionally, it is illegal to transport open containers of alcohol in vehicles, with exceptions for unopened containers in the trunk or the back of a van.

New York

New York City and Long Island have specific open container laws, with each county and city having its own statute. In New York City, for example, a violation of the open container law can result in a $25 fine or even up to 5 days in jail. It is important to note that drinking from an open container concealed in a brown paper bag is still considered a violation if a police officer has reasonable suspicion.

North Carolina

North Carolina's open container laws apply to both motor vehicles and public places. The Alcohol and Beverage Control (ABC) Commission of North Carolina categorizes alcoholic beverages based on their type and alcohol content, with specific regulations for each category. Additionally, brown-bagging, or concealing an open container in a paper bag, does not provide protection from open container charges in North Carolina.

California

California has specific regulations regarding the use of bags for alcohol purchases. Some counties and cities, such as Hyde, Currituck, and Dare, have banned the use of plastic bags by retailers, and some retailers charge extra for bags.

It is important to note that open container laws can change and evolve, and state laws may be subject to updates through new legislation, court decisions, or other means. Always verify the specific laws and regulations of your state or location to ensure compliance.

Paper bag requirements for alcohol sales

While paper bags are often used for alcohol sales, there are no specific requirements for their use. In fact, the use of paper bags for alcohol sales is often based on misconceptions about "open container" laws.

In the United States, "'open container' laws" prohibit individuals from possessing or consuming alcoholic beverages in open containers in public places or vehicles. These laws vary across states, counties, and cities, but they generally do not specify the type of bag or container used. Instead, the focus is on preventing the public consumption of alcohol and ensuring that alcohol is transported in its original, sealed packaging.

The misconception that paper bags are required for alcohol sales may stem from a desire for privacy or a belief that it provides legal protection. Some states, like California, charge extra for bags, while others, like Hyde, Currituck, and Dare counties in North Carolina, have banned plastic bags. Still, the use of paper bags does not exempt individuals from "open container" laws. For example, in North Carolina, Illinois, and New York City, individuals can be fined or face legal consequences for possessing open containers of alcohol, regardless of whether they are concealed in paper bags.

To comply with "open container" laws, it is essential to keep alcohol in its original, sealed container provided by the manufacturer when transporting it. This helps ensure that the alcohol is not considered "open" and subject to legal restrictions.

Public intoxication and open container laws

In North Carolina, for example, open container laws apply to both motor vehicles and public places. The Alcohol and Beverage Control (ABC) Commission of North Carolina provides the laws that govern the possession, sale, and consumption of alcohol within the state. The open container laws are further delineated according to the type of alcohol involved: malt beverages, unfortified wine, fortified wine, and spirituous liquor/mixed drinks.

In New York City, the open container law prohibits possessing an alcoholic beverage in an open container in public, with a fine of $25 for violating the law. Despite the common misconception, placing an alcoholic beverage in a brown paper bag does not shield an individual from violating the open container law. If a police officer has a reasonable suspicion that the bag contains an open container with alcohol, the individual can still be in violation of the law.

Other states, like California, have unique open container laws. California prohibits possessing open alcoholic beverage containers in public places owned by a city, county, or city and county, or any recreation and park district, unless the container is intended for recycling or a similar activity.

Some cities and states have more relaxed open container laws. For instance, in 2020, New Jersey allowed public drinking in tourist spots like the beach and boardwalk of Atlantic City, while Michigan permitted cities to grant social district permits for the open consumption of alcohol. Similarly, the city of Butte in Montana only prohibits open containers between 2:00 a.m. and 8:00 a.m., allowing drinking in the street during the other 18 hours of the day.

In summary, public intoxication and open container laws vary across the United States, with different states and communities enacting their own regulations regarding the possession and consumption of alcoholic beverages in public spaces and vehicles.

Paper bag use in liquor stores

Paper bags are commonly used in liquor stores to provide customers with a sense of privacy and to protect glass bottles from breaking. However, it is important to note that in most places, there is no legal requirement to bag alcoholic beverages after they have been sold. The practice of using paper bags for liquor is more of a tradition and a way to provide discretion for customers.

The use of paper bags in liquor stores has been a common practice for a long time. Historically, paper bags were the only option available to store and carry liquor bottles, as plastic bags had not yet been invented. The opaque nature of paper bags provided "beverage anonymity," allowing customers to consume alcohol discreetly in public places without attracting attention. This practice was especially common among blue-collar workers, who would drink from paper bags in parking lots or on sidewalks after work.

However, it is important to understand that using a paper bag for liquor does not exempt individuals from open container laws. In the United States, each state, county, and city has its own regulations regarding alcohol possession and consumption in public spaces. Despite the common misconception, simply concealing a bottle of alcohol in a paper bag does not make it legal to drink in public. Law enforcement officers can still issue citations or fines if they have a reasonable suspicion that an individual is carrying an open container, regardless of whether it is in a paper bag or not.

While paper bags do not provide legal protection, they can serve other purposes in liquor stores. Firstly, they can be used as proof of purchase, indicating that the bottle has been paid for and reducing the chances of shoplifting. Additionally, paper bags can help protect fragile glass bottles from breaking during transport, especially when multiple bottles are purchased together. This practical use has likely contributed to the widespread adoption of paper bags in liquor stores.

In summary, paper bags are commonly used in liquor stores for customer privacy, tradition, and bottle protection. However, it is important to be aware of local laws and regulations regarding alcohol consumption, as paper bags do not exempt individuals from open container laws in public places.

Frequently asked questions