Martial Law: Can A President Seize Unchecked Power?

The question of whether a president can declare martial law and remain in office is a complex one, with no clear answer. While the U.S. Constitution does not explicitly define or grant the president the power to declare martial law, several presidents throughout history have done so. The Supreme Court has also never explicitly stated that the president can declare martial law, adding to the ambiguity surrounding this issue. Some scholars argue that the president has the executive power to declare it, while others believe congressional authorization is required. The Insurrection Act, a federal law, allows the president to deploy the military to enforce federal laws and maintain order, but this is not the same as declaring martial law. The power to declare martial law may lie with Congress, as they have the authority to declare war and pass laws essential to its prosecution. Ultimately, the question of whether a president can declare martial law and remain in office remains a subject of debate and interpretation of constitutional powers.

The US Constitution does not define martial law

Martial law refers to instances when a nation's armed forces step in and assume the governance of an area. Officials most often impose martial law when civilian authority over an area has stopped functioning, such as in the case of an insurrection or natural disaster. For example, during the American Revolutionary period, British authorities imposed martial law in Boston in response to the Boston Tea Party. More recently, in 1941, Hawaii was placed under martial law after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor.

There are two competing theories regarding the source of the power to declare martial law. One theory suggests that martial law does not come from any direct authority but rather "arises from the nature of things, being the law of paramount necessity." In other words, it stems from the government's right, power, and/or duty to "maintain public order" and keep the peace. The other theory argues that the Constitution's enumerated war powers of the legislative and executive branches give both Congress and the president the power to declare martial law.

Some scholars believe that the president has the executive power to declare martial law. Others argue that the president needs congressional authorization to impose martial law in a civilian area. According to the Brennan Center for Justice, the president lacks the authority to unilaterally declare martial law, and Congress might be able to authorize a presidential declaration of martial law. However, this has not been conclusively decided.

In conclusion, while the US Constitution does not define martial law, it is important to note that the power to declare martial law is ambiguous and has been exercised by both state officials and the president throughout American history.

The president can deploy troops to assist civilian law enforcement

While the president does not have the authority to declare martial law, they can deploy troops to assist civilian law enforcement in certain circumstances. The Posse Comitatus Act, a 143-year-old law, prohibits the use of the military as a domestic police force, viewing military interference in civilian affairs as a threat to democracy and personal liberty. However, there are exceptions to this Act that allow the president to deploy troops for civilian law enforcement.

The Insurrection Act, for example, permits the president to deploy the military to assist civilian authorities, not to take their place. This Act has been invoked numerous times throughout history, such as by President Abraham Lincoln at the start of the Civil War and by President Ulysses Grant to crush the Ku Klux Klan in the 1870s. Sections 252 and 253 of the Insurrection Act allow the president to deploy troops without a request from the affected state, even against the state's wishes, to enforce the laws of the United States or to suppress rebellions.

Another exception to the Posse Comitatus Act is when there is a need to enforce federal civil rights laws or suppress rebellions. Additionally, the Stafford Act allows the military to respond to natural disasters, public health crises, and similar events without waiving the restrictions of the Posse Comitatus Act.

The president can also call on the military to help local governments after a natural disaster, although this help is usually limited. In the case of a foreign invasion or civil war, if the courts are closed and criminal justice cannot be administered, martial law can be established by supreme political authority, as seen in the Ex parte Milligan case after the Civil War.

Martial law has been declared in the US at least 60 times

The United States Constitution does not define martial law and does not specify who can declare it. However, according to a modern interpretation, the president and state officials can declare "degrees of martial law" under specific circumstances. The Supreme Court has also never explicitly stated whether the president can unilaterally declare martial law, and Congress's ability to authorize a presidential declaration of martial law has not been conclusively decided.

Despite this ambiguity, several presidents throughout history have imposed or approved declarations of martial law. Martial law has been declared in the US at least 60 times, and some sources state that it has been declared at least 68 times. The historical use of martial law in the US is poorly documented and understudied, but it has been used in a limited number of circumstances. For example, martial law was declared in New Orleans during the Battle of New Orleans, after major disasters like the Great Chicago Fire of 1871, and during riots like the Omaha race riot of 1919.

During the West Virginia Coal Wars (1920-1921), martial law was declared in the state of West Virginia at the behest of Governor Cornwell, who dispatched federal troops to deal with striking miners. The army officer in charge acted under the Suspension Clause of Article I of the US Constitution, jailing only union miners. Miners were arrested, jailed, and released without any trial. This period of military occupation and "veritable military dictatorship" ended after the trial of Sid Hatfield began, and many miners were not released from jail.

The US also made extensive use of martial law during the Civil War, imposing it on border states like Missouri and Kentucky, where US forces clashed with Confederate insurgents. In 1878, Congress passed the Posse Comitatus Act, prohibiting US military involvement in domestic law enforcement without congressional approval. While the president can call on the military to help local governments after a natural disaster, federal laws usually prevent the military from acting within the country.

Although the president has ample authority to deploy troops to assist civilian law enforcement, the president lacks the authority to replace civilian authorities with federal troops. The Supreme Court has held that state declarations of martial law are conclusive and not subject to judicial review. However, state officials' actions under a declaration of martial law must abide by the US Constitution and are subject to review in federal court.

The Insurrection Act allows the president to deploy military forces domestically

While the U.S. Constitution does not define martial law, it is generally understood as the instance when a nation's armed forces assume the governance of an area, stepping in when civilian authority has ceased to function.

The Constitution does not specify who can declare martial law, and there is ambiguity surrounding the president's authority to do so. The Supreme Court has held that states can declare martial law, but it has never explicitly held that the president can. Several presidents throughout history have declared martial law, and some scholars argue that the Constitution's enumerated war powers grant the president this authority. However, others believe that congressional authorization is required for the president to impose martial law in a civilian area.

The Insurrection Act, enacted in 1792 and amended multiple times since, is a key exception to the Posse Comitatus Act, which generally prohibits the U.S. military from engaging in civilian law enforcement. The Insurrection Act grants the president the authority to deploy the U.S. military domestically and use it against Americans under specific conditions, such as suppressing rebellion, addressing domestic violence, or enforcing the law in certain situations. This authority is not without limits, and the act should ideally be invoked only as a last resort in a crisis that civilian authorities cannot manage.

The Insurrection Act has been invoked numerous times throughout history, including during labor conflicts in the late 19th and early 20th centuries and to enforce federally mandated desegregation. While the act provides the president with significant power to decide when and where to deploy military forces domestically, it has not been meaningfully updated in over 150 years, leading to concerns about its potential for abuse.

Congress may be the only governmental branch that can declare martial law

The US Constitution does not define martial law, nor does it specify who can declare it. However, several presidents and many state governors have imposed or approved declarations of martial law throughout American history. While the Constitution does not explicitly grant the president the power to declare martial law, there are two competing theories regarding the source of the power to do so. Some scholars believe that martial law does not come from any direct authority but rather "arises from the nature of things, being the law of paramount necessity". In other words, it comes from the government's right, power, and/or duty to "maintain public order" and keep the peace.

The other theory is that the Constitution's enumerated war powers of the legislative and executive branches give both Congress and the president the power to declare martial law. Articles I and II of the Constitution give each branch some control over America's military forces. Congress has the power to raise, support, and govern armies, as well as to declare war. This power necessarily extends to all legislation essential to the vigorous and successful prosecution of war. However, the power to command forces and conduct campaigns belongs to the president as Commander in Chief.

While the president has ample authority under current law to deploy troops to assist civilian law enforcement, the president lacks the authority to replace civilian authorities with federal troops. The Posse Comitatus Act, passed by Congress in 1878, forbids US military involvement in domestic law enforcement without congressional approval. Additionally, the Supreme Court has held that states can declare martial law, but it has never specifically held that the president can. Therefore, Congress may be the only governmental branch that can declare martial law, and the president can only act according to its actions.

Frequently asked questions