Dating Your Sister-In-Law's Brother: Is It Okay?

In the context of relationships, the term in-laws refers to people who are related by marriage. A sibling-in-law is the spouse of one's sibling or the sibling of one's spouse. In the case of a sister-in-law and a brother-in-law, they are the siblings of each other's spouses. While there are no universal cultural or legal prohibitions against a sister-in-law dating her brother-in-law, it is worth noting that in certain cultures and legal systems, such as Islamic law (Sharia) and Jewish law (halakha), sexual relations between siblings-in-law are considered incestuous and prohibited unless the spouse is no longer married.

Is it legally incestuous?

In-laws are people you are related to by marriage, but not by blood. A sibling-in-law is the spouse of one's sibling or the sibling of one's spouse. In common usage, a sibling-in-law is referred to as a brother-in-law for a male and a sister-in-law for a female.

In most countries, incest laws apply to blood relatives, such as a parent and child, siblings, or grandparents and grandchildren. For example, in the United States, incest laws vary by jurisdiction, but most states penalize sexual activity between lineal relatives, such as parents and children, and siblings. In New York, incestuous marriages are considered void and prohibited by law. Similarly, France's penal code includes incest as a criminal offense, and Iceland's penal code imposes imprisonment for incestuous relations between relatives of the ascending and descending lines, including siblings.

However, it is worth noting that in some cultures and legal systems, incest laws may extend to relationships by marriage. For instance, in Islamic law (Sharia) and Jewish law (halakha), sexual relations between siblings-in-law are prohibited as incestuous unless the spouse is no longer married. On the other hand, in Judaism, there was a custom of yibbum, where a man had the duty to wed his deceased brother's childless widow.

Therefore, while it is generally understood that incest laws apply to blood relatives, there may be cultural or legal variations that include certain in-law relationships. It is important to consider the specific cultural, religious, and legal context when discussing the legality of incestuous relationships involving siblings-in-law.

Cultural context and acceptance

While there are no blood relations between a person and their sibling-in-law, cultural norms and acceptance vary across different societies and communities. In some cultures, it may be considered socially acceptable for a sister-in-law to date her brother-in-law, while in others, it may be frowned upon or even prohibited.

For example, in Islamic law (Sharia) and Jewish law (halakha), sexual relations between siblings-in-law are prohibited as incestuous unless the spouse is no longer married. On the other hand, in Judaism, there was a custom called yibbum, where a man had the non-obligatory duty to marry his deceased brother's childless widow. This custom allowed for a special type of kinship called affinity, which is similar to all in-law relationships.

In Indian culture, there seems to be a general disapproval of siblings from one family marrying siblings from another. However, it is important to note that cultural norms and practices can vary within a country and among different communities and families. Therefore, it is always advisable to consider the specific cultural context and the views of the individuals and families involved.

In Western cultures, there may be less of a cultural stigma associated with a sister-in-law dating her brother-in-law. However, it is still essential to consider the dynamics of the specific family and community involved, as personal beliefs and values can vary widely.

Ultimately, the cultural context and acceptance of a sister-in-law dating a brother-in-law depend on a multitude of factors, including religious beliefs, societal norms, and individual perspectives. While some cultures may have more permissive views on such relationships, others may consider them taboo or inappropriate. As such, it is crucial to approach these situations with sensitivity and respect for the cultural norms of the individuals and communities involved.

Are they blood-related?

A sibling-in-law is the spouse of one's sibling or the sibling of one's spouse. In common usage, a sibling-in-law is referred to as a brother-in-law for a male and a sister-in-law for a female. This terminology also refers to the reciprocal relationship between a person's spouse and their sibling's spouse. In Indian English, this can be referred to as a co-sibling. For example, the wife of one's sibling-in-law is a co-sister, and the husband of one's sibling-in-law is a co-brother.

Siblings-in-law are related by a type of kinship called affinity, which is the same for all in-law relationships. These relationships are not related directly by blood. Like the children of one's siblings, the children of one's siblings-in-law are called nieces and nephews, and if necessary, it is specified whether they are "by marriage", "by blood", or "by adoption". If one pair of siblings is married to another pair of siblings, the siblings-in-law are doubly related, with each of the four being related through their spouse and their sibling. In this case, the children of the two couples are double cousins, so they are twice as related as a normal pair of cousins, similar to half-siblings.

In Islamic law (Sharia) and Jewish law (halakha), sexual relations between siblings-in-law are prohibited as incestuous unless the spouse is no longer married. However, in Judaism, there was a custom called yibbum, where a man had the non-obligatory duty to wed his deceased brother's childless widow so that she might have progeny by him.

To answer the question, a brother-in-law and sister-in-law are not blood-related. They are related by affinity, or in other words, by marriage.

Are they already married?

It is important to note that a sibling-in-law is the spouse of one's sibling or the sibling of one’s spouse. In this context, if a person is already married to their sibling-in-law, it implies an existing affinity or kinship. This type of relationship is not directly related by blood but is established through marriage.

Now, if we consider the scenario where a brother-in-law and a sister-in-law are already married, it would be unusual for them to start dating, as they are already in a marital relationship. However, in certain cultures and historical contexts, there are traditions where such relationships are accepted or even expected. For example, in Old Tibet, it was customary for a woman to marry her deceased spouse's brother, and polygamy, including marrying two brothers, was also permitted. Similarly, in Judaism, there was a custom called "yibbum," where a man had the option to marry his deceased brother's childless widow.

That being said, in the present day, it is generally uncommon and may be considered socially inappropriate in many cultures for a brother-in-law and sister-in-law to date or marry if they are already married. Social norms and legal frameworks in most societies view such relationships as incestuous and prohibited. However, it is worth noting that societal attitudes can vary, and there may be exceptions where certain family structures or cultural traditions allow for more flexibility in these relationships.

Ultimately, if a brother-in-law and sister-in-law are already married and considering dating each other, it is essential to consider the legal, cultural, and ethical implications within their specific context. It may be helpful to seek guidance from relevant authorities or experts in their particular cultural or social setting to navigate this complex situation.

In conclusion, while it is uncommon and may be socially or legally prohibited in many places, there are cultural and historical contexts where dating or marrying one's sister-in-law or brother-in-law, even if already married, has been accepted or even expected. Each situation is unique, and navigating these relationships requires careful consideration of the surrounding factors.

What are the implications of this relationship?

The implications of a romantic relationship between a sister-in-law and a brother-in-law depend on cultural, religious, and personal beliefs. From a legal standpoint, such a relationship is generally not prohibited by civil law, as these individuals are not related by blood. However, cultural and religious norms may influence how such a relationship is perceived and accepted within a particular community.

In some cultures, such as India, it may not be acceptable for siblings from one family to marry siblings from another family. This could lead to social disapproval or familial tension if the couple chooses to pursue a relationship. On the other hand, in certain communities, this type of relationship may be seen as strengthening familial bonds and fostering closer ties between the two families.

From a religious perspective, Islamic law (Sharia) and Jewish law (halakha) prohibit sexual relations between siblings-in-law as incestuous, unless the spouse is no longer married. However, in Judaism, there was a custom called yibbum, where a man had the non-obligatory duty to marry his deceased brother's childless widow. This custom allowed for a form of sibling-in-law marriage to ensure the widow had progeny.

On a personal level, the implications of this relationship depend on the individuals involved and their family dynamics. Some families may be open and accepting of such a relationship, while others may have concerns due to cultural, religious, or personal beliefs. It is essential to consider the potential impact on family relationships, especially if there are children involved, as the dynamics of the extended family will be altered.

Ultimately, while there may be cultural, religious, or personal implications, the decision to pursue a relationship between a sister-in-law and a brother-in-law depends on the individuals involved and their willingness to navigate any potential challenges that may arise.

Frequently asked questions