Towns' Legal Power: Creating Their Own Laws?

In the United States, the federal government makes laws by passing a bill. However, the country uses a shared governance system, which means that smaller levels of government, including state, county, and local governments, also play a crucial role in the legal system. Municipalities, such as villages, towns, and cities, can make their own laws, often called ordinances, when there are specific reasons to do so. These laws are usually created to address local issues or conditions that differ from other municipalities. Towns within a county may have their own local laws and government, with the power to make laws for specific purposes and geographic areas.

Towns can make their own laws, but state laws override them

Municipalities, such as villages, towns, and cities, can make their own laws when there are specific good reasons for doing so. This could be due to unique conditions in that municipality or because the local council has decided to create a law to address a specific local issue. For example, zoning laws are typically decided by municipalities, and they may also have the right to raise taxes to fund local services.

The process of creating a new ordinance at the city level involves several steps. First, a proposed ordinance is drafted, and the new language is presented in a document that outlines how the law will look after passage by the council. Once the first draft is ready, it is included in a city council meeting agenda, which is publicly available. During the council meeting, the topic is presented for public comment, allowing residents to provide their perspectives. After public comment, the council votes on whether to move forward. If the vote passes, the ordinance is approved and organized as part of the city's Municipal Code.

While towns can make their own laws, state laws take precedence in the event of a conflict between state and local laws. The Supremacy Clause in the Constitution grants the federal government the power to override some state laws, but this power has its limits. States generally have the authority to create and enforce their own laws as long as they are constitutional and do not conflict with federal laws.

Towns can pass different types of ordinances, like creating or amending them

In the United States, the federal government makes laws by passing a bill. At the city level, the term "ordinance" is used to refer to a law. Cities and towns can pass different types of ordinances, like creating or amending them. An ordinance that is being proposed is called a "proposed ordinance". Approved ordinances are organized as the city's Municipal Code, with various chapters and sections. For instance, the City of Santa Cruz adopted ordinance No. 2023-14 to amend Part 16 of Chapter 24.12 of their Municipal Code to address housing density requirements.

Towns can create new ordinances or amend existing ones. A new ordinance is created when a town wants to address an issue that is not already covered by an existing ordinance. For example, a town may create a new ordinance to address a specific issue, such as e-bike regulations. The first step in creating a new ordinance is for the town council to propose it and include it in a council meeting agenda, which is publicly available. During the council meeting, the topic is presented for public comment, allowing residents to provide their perspectives. Once public comment is finished, the council votes on whether to move forward with the proposed ordinance. If the vote passes, the clerk or an attorney drafts the new legal language, considering research on preemption and neighbouring ordinances.

Amending an ordinance involves changing an existing law. This can be done for various reasons, such as updating outdated language or addressing unintended consequences of the original ordinance. For example, a town may amend an ordinance to align with new federal or state laws or to make changes based on feedback from committees or the public. The process for amending an ordinance is similar to creating a new one, including public comment and a vote by the town council.

It is important to note that while towns can create and amend their own ordinances, they must still comply with state and federal laws. In the case of a conflict between a town ordinance and a state or federal law, the state or federal law takes precedence. Additionally, towns are usually allowed to make their own laws when there are specific reasons for doing so, such as unique conditions or local issues that need to be addressed.

Towns can make laws for specific purposes and geographic areas

In the United States, the federal government makes laws by passing a bill. At the city level, these are called "ordinances". Cities can pass different types of ordinances depending on their purpose, such as creating a new ordinance or amending an existing one. Towns, which fall under the category of municipalities, can indeed make their own laws for specific purposes and geographic areas.

Municipalities, which include villages, towns, and cities, can make their own laws when there are specific reasons to do so. This could be due to unique conditions in that municipality or to address a specific local issue. For example, zoning laws are typically decided by municipalities, and they may also have the right to raise taxes to fund local services.

Counties are another layer of government that sits between state governments and municipalities. They often have a municipal charter and provide local ordinances that dictate the powers of the government. The cities, towns, or villages within a county may have their own local laws and governments. Local disputes can involve various legal issues, including zoning, taxation, criminal and civil courts, and business law.

The process of creating a law at the city level involves several critical steps that ensure public involvement and careful stewardship by clerks and councils. The first step is the "First Reading", where the first draft of the proposed ordinance is read aloud during a city council meeting. The agenda for this meeting is publicly available, and all citizens can attend. Once the first reading is complete, the council will vote on whether to move forward with the proposal. If the vote passes, the proposal moves to the "Second Reading".

Between the first and second readings, committees may be asked to review and comment on the potential impacts of the new ordinance. If significant impacts are identified that were not previously considered, changes to the legal language may be required, and the new ordinance will need to be reintroduced. This process ensures that unintended consequences are avoided. Once the proposal has been aligned with federal and state law, the ordinance can be passed.

Towns can make laws about zoning, taxation, and business

Towns can indeed make their own laws, but only when there are specific reasons for doing so. Towns are part of a shared governance system, which includes federal, state, county, and local governments. Towns, as municipalities, can pass laws, or ordinances, concerning various aspects of local life. These laws are made by the local council to address issues pertinent to the locality.

Towns can make laws about zoning, which is a common use of municipal power. Zoning laws can apply to businesses and residential areas, addressing public safety, land use, and real estate. For example, a town may designate an area for industrial use only, with regulations for dimensions, placement of utilities, parking, and types of buildings. These laws can be very specific and are often created to deal with a unique issue in the town.

Taxation is another area where towns can make their own laws. Municipalities may have the right to raise taxes to fund their administrative tasks and services, such as libraries, lighting, parks, and garbage removal. This ability to raise taxes gives towns a degree of financial autonomy and the ability to provide for their residents.

Business law is also a local issue. Towns can create laws that affect businesses within their jurisdiction, such as local zoning ordinances that apply to commercial areas. These laws can impact the operation of businesses and the local economy. Towns can also pass laws to address specific concerns or opportunities that may arise, such as the City of Santa Cruz's ordinance change in response to housing density requirements.

Towns can raise taxes to fund local services and administrative tasks

In the United States, the federal government and smaller levels of government, including state, county, and local governments, coexist in a shared governance system. While the federal government has the power to override some state laws under the Supremacy Clause in the Constitution, states are generally free to create and enforce their own laws as long as they are constitutional. Similarly, towns within a county may have their own local laws and governments.

Local governments, including towns, collect taxes to support essential services such as education, infrastructure, public health, and public safety. Property taxes are the most common source of revenue for local governments, accounting for about three-fourths of their funding. Consumption, income, and other taxes, such as business license taxes, license fees, and corporate license taxes, make up the remaining portion. Local governments have limited discretion over the transactions they can tax, and they may be restricted to adopting the same tax base as their state.

While raising taxes can help towns fund local services, it is essential to consider the impact on residents, especially those with lower incomes. Property taxes, for instance, have been criticized for disproportionately affecting lower-income residents and communities of color due to biased tax administration practices and resource gaps. Policymakers play a crucial role in ensuring that towns have the fiscal flexibility to weather economic downturns and maintain financial stability without unduly burdening their residents.

Frequently asked questions