California Labor Laws: Are Scheduled Breaks Required?

In California, non-exempt employees are entitled to a 30-minute meal break for a shift longer than five hours and a second 30-minute meal break for a shift longer than ten hours. Additionally, they are entitled to a 10-minute rest break for every four hours worked. While employers are not required to ensure that employees take their breaks, they must provide suitable resting facilities and cannot impede or discourage employees from taking them. If an employer fails to provide the required meal and rest breaks, they may be liable for penalties, including paying the employee one additional hour of regular pay for each workday that a meal break was not provided.

Rest breaks and meal breaks must be separate

In California, rest breaks and meal breaks are distinct and must be provided separately. An employer cannot give a single one-hour break and claim that it counts as the employee's meal and rest break. This is a requirement under California labor laws, and employers who violate these rules may face costly consequences.

According to California labor laws, non-exempt employees are entitled to a 30-minute uninterrupted, duty-free meal break if they work more than five hours in a workday. This meal break must be off-the-clock and cannot be included in the calculation of work hours. Additionally, employees are entitled to a 10-minute uninterrupted, duty-free rest break for every four hours they work. In an eight-hour workday, this typically means having one rest break before and one after the meal break. However, this timing may be adjusted due to practical considerations, as ruled by the California Supreme Court in Brinker.

It is important to note that while employers are required by law to make timely meal and rest breaks available, they are not obligated to ensure that employees take these breaks. The decision to voluntarily skip, waive, or postpone a meal or rest break without pressure or encouragement from the employer is legally permitted. However, employers have the right to set the work schedule, including the break schedule, and may order employees to take their meal and rest breaks.

Employees who are denied their meal and rest breaks are entitled to receive penalties. For each day that an employee is denied a meal break, the employer owes an additional hour of pay at the employee's regular rate. If a rest break is not provided or is interrupted, the same penalty applies, resulting in a maximum penalty of up to two hours of wages per day. Employees have up to three years to file a claim for unpaid wages and meal and rest break violations.

Employers must provide breaks but don't have to ensure they're taken

In California, employers are required by law to provide rest and meal breaks to their employees. However, they are not legally required to ensure that their employees take these breaks. This means that while employers must offer breaks, they are not responsible for making sure their employees take them. The decision to take or skip a break rests with the employee.

The California Supreme Court clarified the obligations of employers regarding meal and rest breaks in Brinker Restaurant Corp. v. Superior Court. According to the ruling, employers satisfy their legal obligation by providing an off-duty meal period that relieves employees of all duties, gives them control over their activities, and allows a reasonable opportunity for an uninterrupted 30-minute break without any impediment or discouragement.

It's important to note that while employers don't have to ensure breaks are taken, they are still subject to specific guidelines. For example, rest breaks should ideally be provided in the middle of each four-hour work period, but practical considerations may require scheduling breaks at other times during the shift. Additionally, employers have the right to set the work schedule, including break schedules, and they may order employees to take their meal and rest breaks.

If an employer denies or interferes with an employee's right to take meal and rest breaks, there can be costly consequences. Employees who are deprived of their breaks can seek legal recourse, and employers may be required to pay penalties or additional wages. California law provides employees with several options to resolve disputes, including informal resolution with the employer or filing a wage claim with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE).

Employees can waive breaks

In California, employers are required by law to provide their employees with timely meal and rest breaks. However, employees are not obligated to take these breaks and can choose to waive them. This means that employees can legally opt to skip their meal or rest break or take them late, provided there is no pressure or encouragement from the employer to do so.

The California Supreme Court has clarified that employers satisfy their legal obligation to provide an off-duty meal period if they relieve their employees of all duties, relinquish control over their activities, permit them a reasonable opportunity to take an uninterrupted 30-minute break, and do not impede or discourage them from taking it. In other words, employers are not required to ensure that employees take their breaks.

It is important to note that there are specific rules and exemptions for certain industries, such as construction, healthcare, group homes, motion pictures, manufacturing, and baking. Additionally, there are different regulations for exempt employees, such as professionals, administrators, and executives, who may not be entitled to the same meal and rest breaks as non-exempt employees.

While employees can waive their breaks, employers in California have the right to set the work schedule, including the break schedule. This means that while employers are not required to do so, they can order employees to take their meal and rest breaks. Therefore, it is advisable for employees to discuss their intention to waive breaks with their employer beforehand.

The rules regarding meal and rest breaks in California aim to protect employee safety and well-being, and violations of these rules can result in costly consequences for employers, including financial fines and penalties.

Employers can be fined for not providing breaks

In California, employers are required by law to provide their employees with timely meal and rest breaks. However, they are not obligated to ensure that their employees take these breaks. If an employer fails to provide meal and rest breaks, they are subject to fines and penalties.

Meal Breaks

Non-exempt employees in California are entitled to a 30-minute uninterrupted, off-duty meal break when working more than five hours in a day. For shifts exceeding 10 hours, a second 30-minute meal break is required, provided that the first meal break was not waived. Employees can waive their meal breaks under strict conditions and with a mutual waiver agreement between the employer and employee. This typically applies when an employee works a shift of six hours or less.

If an employer fails to provide the required meal breaks, they are subject to penalties. For each workday that an employee is denied a meal break, the employer owes an additional hour of pay at the employee's regular rate, known as "premium pay". Employees have up to three years to file a claim for unpaid wages and penalties.

Rest Breaks

In addition to meal breaks, California employees are entitled to a 10-minute uninterrupted, duty-free rest break for every four hours worked. Rest breaks should typically fall in the middle of each four-hour work period but can be provided at other times during the shift if practical considerations make the general rule impractical. Employers must treat rest breaks as hours worked and pay employees for this time.

If an employer fails to provide rest breaks, they are subject to the same penalties as those for meal break violations. For each day that an employee is denied a rest break, they are owed an additional hour of pay at their regular rate.

Consequences of Non-Compliance

Non-compliance with California's break laws can result in costly consequences for employers, including lawsuits and financial losses. Fines and penalties may be influenced by factors such as the company's size and the number of workers affected. Employees can resolve disputes informally, file wage claims, or take legal action to seek compensation for denied breaks.

Employees can be compensated for missed breaks

In California, employers are required by law to make timely meal and rest breaks available to their employees. However, they are not obligated to ensure that their employees take these breaks. If an employee decides to voluntarily skip or waive their meal or rest break, or take them late, without any pressure or encouragement from their employer, this is legally permitted. Nevertheless, employers have the right to set work schedules, including break schedules, and they may order employees to take their meal and rest breaks. If an employee does not comply with this, the employer has the right to discipline or terminate them for insubordination.

California law states that non-exempt workers are entitled to a 30-minute uninterrupted, duty-free meal break if they work more than 5 hours in a workday. This meal break must be unpaid only if the employer relieves the employee of all duties, relinquishes control over their activities, and permits them a reasonable opportunity to take the break without impeding or discouraging them. If these conditions are not met, the meal break must be paid. If an employer fails to provide a meal break, they are required to pay their employee an additional hour of regular pay for each day on which a meal break violation occurred.

In addition to meal breaks, employees in California are entitled to a 10-minute uninterrupted, duty-free rest break for every 4 hours worked. These rest breaks must be paid. If an employee works at least 3.5 hours in a day, they are entitled to one rest break, and if they work over 6 hours, they are entitled to a second rest break. If an employer fails to provide a rest break, they are required to pay their employee an additional hour of regular pay for each day on which a rest break violation occurred.

If an employee is denied both a meal break and a rest break in one day, there has been discussion about whether the premium wage owed by the employer is one hour of pay or two hours of pay. In United Parcel Service v. Superior Court of Los Angeles County, the California Court of Appeal ruled that it is two hours of pay since the premium wage requirement is contained in two separate sections of the Wage Orders. Employees who have been deprived of their meal and rest breaks can resolve their dispute informally with their employer, file a wage claim with California's Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE), or seek legal counsel. It is important to note that there are strict deadlines for filing claims or lawsuits, typically within 3 years, but sometimes a 1-year deadline may apply.

Frequently asked questions