Georgia's Abortion Law: Did The People Decide?

Georgia's abortion law has been a topic of debate and contention in recent years, with a six-week abortion ban being signed into law by Governor Brian Kemp in 2019. This law, also known as the Heartbeat Bill, was deemed unconstitutional by Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney in September 2024, but the Georgia Supreme Court reinstated the ban shortly after. The law restricts abortions after the detection of cardiac activity in an embryo, which can occur as early as six weeks into a pregnancy. This has sparked protests and rallies by abortion rights supporters, who argue that the law violates the constitutional rights to liberty and privacy. The debate around Georgia's abortion law has also been influenced by tragic stories of women who have died due to a lack of access to legal abortions. While the law includes exceptions for cases of rape, incest, and risks to the mother's life, critics argue that it still imposes significant restrictions on women's reproductive rights. The issue of abortion is a critical voting factor for many Georgians, especially Black women, who view it as an economic, public health, and life-or-death issue.

Georgia's six-week abortion ban

The ban has faced significant opposition and has been challenged in court multiple times. In November 2022, a Fulton County Superior Court judge, Robert McBurney, ruled that the law was "`unequivocally unconstitutional`" as it was enacted when Roe v. Wade allowed abortions after six weeks. However, in October 2023, the Georgia Supreme Court rejected this ruling, stating that the overturning of Roe v. Wade meant that the state had to apply the new interpretation of the Constitution.

The ban has had devastating consequences for people seeking abortions in Georgia, as many are forced to act quickly to terminate their pregnancies. The ban also applies to miscarriages and does not make exceptions for fetal anomalies or medical emergencies. There are limited exceptions for rape and incest survivors and medical emergencies, but these require extensive documentation.

The ban has also been linked to the deaths of several women, including Amber Nicole Thurman and Candi Miller, who died from preventable causes due to confusion and fear of criminal penalties for violating the abortion ban. The law has been criticised for disproportionately impacting Black women, who already face higher risks of pregnancy complications and death due to systemic inequalities in the healthcare system.

The six-week abortion ban has become a critical voting issue for many Georgians, especially Black women, who view abortion as a matter of reproductive justice and a matter of life and death. While Georgia's constitution does not allow for ballot initiatives to directly challenge the ban, the issue is driving voting conversations and mobilising voters ahead of the election.

The Supreme Court's overturning of Roe v. Wade

In the state of Georgia, the overturning of Roe v. Wade cleared the way for a restrictive abortion law to take effect. This law, known as the "Heartbeat Law" or the "Living Infants Fairness and Equality Act", was signed by Governor Brian Kemp in 2019 but was initially blocked by a federal judge before it could be implemented. The law prohibits abortions after the detection of cardiac activity in an embryo, which typically occurs around six weeks into a pregnancy.

The Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade removed the legal obstacle to Georgia's abortion law, and it went into effect. This law includes exceptions for cases of rape and incest, provided a police report is filed, and allows for abortions after six weeks if the mother's life is at risk or if a serious medical condition renders the fetus non-viable.

The impact of this law has been devastating for some women in Georgia. One notable case is that of Amber Thurman, who died due to complications that could have been prevented if she had been able to access a legal abortion. Additionally, the law has been criticised for interfering with a woman's right to control her body and make decisions about her healthcare.

In September 2024, Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney declared Georgia's six-week abortion law unconstitutional, citing that it violated privacy rights and a woman's liberty to control her body and make healthcare choices. This ruling temporarily restored broader access to abortion in the state.

However, this victory for abortion rights supporters was short-lived. The Georgia Supreme Court quickly intervened and reinstated the six-week abortion ban while the state appealed Judge McBurney's ruling. This series of legal battles highlights the ongoing conflict between those who support abortion rights and those who favour restrictive abortion laws in Georgia and across the United States.

The Harris campaign's strategy on abortion

The Harris campaign has been leveraging the issue of abortion rights to mobilize voters in Georgia, despite the absence of a direct ballot initiative. The campaign recognizes that abortion is a driving force in the voting conversation in the state, and is investing time and resources to keep the issue at the forefront. This includes a 50-stop bus tour, "Fighting for Reproductive Freedom," which made three stops in Georgia, as well as rallies and events featuring personal stories and experiences related to abortion.

The campaign's strategy emphasizes the negative impact of abortion restrictions, particularly the six-week abortion ban in Georgia, on women's lives and freedoms. Harris has been outspoken about abortion rights since the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, and has highlighted cases where women have suffered or died due to limited access to safe abortions. She has also criticized her opponent, Donald Trump, for his role in overturning Roe v. Wade and his support for abortion restrictions.

In North Carolina, the Harris campaign has seized on the Mark Robinson scandal, tying him and his "extreme" policy positions, including abortion restrictions, to Trump. The campaign has launched ads featuring Robinson's controversial comments and clips of Trump praising him. This strategy aims to appeal to Black voters, suburban voters, and moderate Republicans in the battleground state.

The Harris campaign's approach to abortion as a voting issue is resonating with a broad and diverse coalition of voters in Georgia, including those who oppose the six-week abortion ban and those concerned about reproductive justice, especially in Black and rural communities. The campaign is utilizing personal stories and surrogates, such as Callie Beale Harper, to connect with voters and highlight the real-life implications of abortion restrictions.

Overall, the Harris campaign's strategy on abortion seeks to capitalize on the issue's importance to voters, particularly women, and frame Harris as a strong advocate for reproductive rights and justice. By highlighting the negative consequences of abortion restrictions and tying her opponent to these outcomes, Harris aims to motivate voters to support her and her agenda for protecting and expanding abortion access.

The impact of abortion laws on Black women

Georgia's abortion laws have had a significant impact on Black women, who represent a large proportion of abortions in the state. According to recent data, Black people account for 65% of abortions in Georgia, despite constituting only a third of the population. This disparity has been linked to various factors, including financial constraints due to systemic racism, limited access to contraceptives, and higher rates of unintended pregnancies among Black women.

Additionally, the financial implications of abortion laws cannot be overlooked. Denying abortion access can push people, especially Black and Indigenous communities, further into poverty. As Sabia Wade, an author and educator, noted, "Having a child, especially for Black and brown [and] Indigenous people, can put you further into poverty if you're not already there." The cost of prenatal and postnatal care, hospital bills, and other expenses associated with childbirth can be overwhelming, especially for those already facing economic instability.

Systemic racism also plays a significant role in the impact of abortion laws on Black women in Georgia. Black people often face barriers in accessing contraceptives, contributing to higher rates of unintended pregnancies. Additionally, systemic racism intersects with economic instability, making family planning and abortion access even more challenging for Black women.

The lack of access to medical care and the distance from hospitals, particularly in rural areas, further exacerbates the impact of abortion laws on Black women in Georgia. The state's failure to fully expand Medicaid limits local care, hospital access, and payment options for prenatal and postnatal services. This disparity disproportionately affects Black women, especially those in rural communities, who already face challenges in accessing reproductive healthcare.

The conversation around abortion laws in Georgia extends beyond the procedure itself. For Black women, it encompasses issues of reproductive justice, healthcare access, economic stability, and racial disparities. As Jara Butler, the chief impact officer for Supermajority, stated, "When we think about reproductive freedom, we really need to expand that to reproductive justice because, for communities of color, especially Black women, it's about having access to information that will help you carry a pregnancy to term."

The role of citizen-led ballot initiatives

Georgia's constitution prohibits citizen-led ballot initiatives, which are popping up nationwide to codify abortion rights. The state's six-week abortion ban can only be reversed through federal law guaranteeing abortion access or a new bill passed by the Georgia legislature and signed into law by the governor.

Georgia is one of 25 states that do not allow citizen initiatives or constitutional amendments on a statewide ballot. This direct democratic process has allowed voters in other states to preserve abortion and other reproductive rights by circumventing their legislatures.

Voters in seven states, including conservative ones such as Kentucky, Montana, and Ohio, have protected abortion rights or defeated attempts to curtail them in statewide votes over the past two years.

Georgia Democratic Rep. Shea Roberts has introduced legislation to create a citizen initiative process in the state, but these efforts have been ignored inside the Republican-controlled Legislature. Roberts said voters are constantly asking why Georgia can't have this process, and she has to explain that it's not possible under the current constitution.

The inability to put abortion rights to a vote in Georgia has not stopped the issue from influencing voting decisions. Abortion is quietly driving the voting conversation in the state, even if it isn't on the ballot. The Harris campaign is capitalizing on this, with Vice President Kamala Harris making Georgia one of the stops on her "Fighting for Reproductive Freedom" bus tour.

Frequently asked questions