Trump's Tax Troubles: Did He Break The Law?

The question of whether former US President Donald Trump broke any tax laws is a complex one. While there was no evidence of wrongdoing in the tax returns published by the House Ways and Means Committee, which covered the years 2015 to 2020, the committee's report accompanying the release pointed to a number of questionable claims that it considered worthy of further investigation. These included professional expenses, charitable deductions without the necessary documentary evidence, possible disguised gifts to his adult children, and the use of real estate write-offs.

The tax returns also revealed that Trump had foreign bank accounts in China, the UK, Ireland, and St Maarten, and that he paid more tax abroad than in the US in 2017, the first year of his presidency.

Trump himself has claimed that the release of his tax filings will lead to horrible things for so many people and cause divisions in the US to grow far worse. However, others have argued that the tax cuts introduced during his presidency disproportionately benefited the wealthy and increased economic inequality.

While there may not be definitive evidence that Trump broke any tax laws, the creative accounting strategies he employed to minimise his tax liability and the potential irregularities in his returns have certainly raised questions and concerns.

Did Trump's tax cuts benefit the wealthy?

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) was a major tax code overhaul signed into law by former US President Donald Trump in 2018. The law included a variety of tax cuts and benefits for both individuals and businesses. While the TCJA did provide some benefits to middle- and working-class Americans, there is significant evidence to suggest that, overall, the tax cuts disproportionately benefited the wealthy.

The law included a range of provisions that primarily benefited high-income households, such as large, permanent corporate tax cuts and a 20% deduction for pass-through income. It also cut the top individual income tax rate and doubled the amount that the wealthiest households could pass on to their heirs tax-free. As a result, the top 1% of households received an average tax cut of more than $60,000 in 2025, compared to less than $500 for households in the bottom 60%.

Additionally, the TCJA failed to deliver on its promised economic benefits. While Trump Administration officials claimed that the corporate tax rate cut would boost household income by $4,000, new research shows that workers earning less than $114,000 saw no change in earnings, while top executive salaries increased sharply. The tax cuts also failed to spur economic growth, with no indication of a surge in wages compared to historical levels or GDP growth.

Furthermore, once the individual tax cuts expire after 2025, the majority of taxpayers (53.4%) will face a tax increase, with 69.7% of those in the middle quintile paying more, compared to just 8% of the highest-earning 0.1%. This further reinforces the argument that the TCJA disproportionately benefited the wealthy, as the tax cuts for high-income households were made permanent, while those for individuals were temporary.

In conclusion, while there were some benefits for middle- and working-class Americans, the overall impact of the TCJA suggests that Trump's tax cuts disproportionately benefited the wealthy, creating further windfall benefits for high-income households and exacerbating economic inequality.

Did Trump's tax cuts worsen the national debt?

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) was a major overhaul of the tax code, signed into law by President Donald Trump on 1 January 2018. The reform impacted taxpayers and business owners, particularly through tax cuts. The TCJA cut taxes for shareholders and individual taxpayers, but these cuts for individuals are set to expire in 2025.

The TCJA's tax cuts are adding $1 to $2 trillion to the federal debt, according to official estimates. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that extending the expiring provisions would add $4.6 trillion in deficits over 10 years. The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget estimates that the ten-year cost of the legislation and executive actions Trump signed into law was about $8.4 trillion, with interest.

The TCJA disproportionately benefited the most affluent. It led to an estimated 11% increase in corporate investment, but its effects on economic growth and median wages were smaller than expected and modest at best. The TCJA also failed to deliver promised economic benefits.

The TCJA's tax cuts were financed by issuing additional Treasury securities and paying additional debt service. The TCJA's tax cuts for individuals will expire in 2025, but if these expiring provisions are made permanent, deficits will be persistently higher.

Did Trump's tax cuts increase economic growth?

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) was a major tax code overhaul signed into law by President Trump in 2018. The reform impacted taxpayers and business owners, particularly through tax cuts. Many of the tax reform benefits for individuals were set to expire in 2025.

Economic Growth

The TCJA was expected to spur sufficient economic growth to pay for itself and more. The Federal Reserve projected growth of 2.5% in 2018, 2.1% in 2019, 2.0% in 2020, and 1.8% over the longer run.

According to the House Budget Committee Chairman, the Trump tax cuts resulted in economic growth that was a full percentage point above the Congressional Budget Office's (CBO) forecast. In the first two years after the passage of the TCJA, GDP growth was a full percentage point higher than the CBO's pre-TCJA forecast.

Impact on Taxpayers and Businesses

The TCJA cut taxes for shareholders and individual taxpayers, but the cuts for individuals were temporary and set to expire in 2025. The reform impacted individuals based on their income level, filing status, and deductions. The highest earners were expected to benefit the most from the law, while the lowest earners were believed to pay more in taxes after individual tax provisions expire in 2025.

The TCJA created a single flat corporate tax rate of 21%. Many tax benefits that helped individuals and families will expire in 2025.

Criticisms and Alternative Views

Some critics argue that the TCJA failed to deliver on its promises of economic growth. A 2019 Congressional Research Service report on the law's economic impact concluded that there was "no indication of a surge in wages in 2018 either compared to history or to GDP growth." Similarly, a 2021 Brookings Institution report found no evidence that the TCJA provided significant benefits to workers.

According to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, the 2017 Trump tax law was "skewed to the rich," "expensive," and "failed to deliver on its promises." They argue that the law eroded the US revenue base and primarily benefited high-income households while failing to provide meaningful economic benefits to low- and moderate-income families.

On the other hand, some supporters of the TCJA argue that it was a boon for America's economy and working families. They point to increases in real median household income, wages, and reductions in poverty and unemployment rates, especially for minorities and those without a college degree.

Did Trump's tax cuts increase wages?

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), signed into law by President Trump in 2018, was a major tax code overhaul. It cut taxes for shareholders and individual taxpayers, but the cuts for individuals were only temporary and are set to expire in 2025.

The TCJA's impact on wages was mixed. The corporate tax rate was cut from 35% to 21%, and this was done to benefit shareholders, who tend to be higher earners. The law also cut individual taxes, but only until 2025. Once the individual tax cuts expire, the Tax Policy Center (TPC) estimates that the majority of taxpayers (53.4%) will face a tax increase. The TPC also estimates that the 22 million households making $20,000 to $30,000 will collectively pay 26.6% more in 2027 than they would have under the previous law.

The TCJA's impact on wages was also mixed. On the one hand, the law removed the mandate requiring individuals to purchase health insurance, which could free up income for other uses. It also raised the standard deduction, which could result in lower taxes for some individuals. However, the law also suspended the personal exemption, which was $4,150, through 2025. The law's impact on wages likely depends on an individual's income level, filing status, and deductions.

Some analyses suggest that the TCJA failed to deliver on its promise to boost wages. For example, a 2019 Congressional Research Service report found "no indication of a surge in wages in 2018 either compared to history or to GDP growth." Similarly, a 2021 Brookings Institution report found "no evidence that any wage response close to [the Trump administration's] claims occurred in 2018 and 2019." A recent study by economists from the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) and the Federal Reserve Board found that workers below the 90th percentile of their firm's income scale saw "no change in earnings" from the corporate tax rate cut.

However, other analyses suggest that the TCJA did lead to some wage increases. For example, the Tax Foundation estimates that Trump's tax proposals, including making the TCJA permanent, would increase wages by 0.8%. A study by economists from Harvard, Princeton, the University of Chicago, and the Treasury Department estimates that the corporate tax cuts could increase wages by about $750 per worker in the long run, although this is still "an order of magnitude below" what was promised.

Overall, the evidence suggests that the TCJA's impact on wages was mixed, with some groups experiencing wage increases while others saw no change or even a decrease in earnings. The law's impact likely depends on a variety of factors, including income level, filing status, and deductions.

Did Trump's tax cuts benefit corporations?

On January 1, 2018, President Trump signed the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) into law. The TCJA was the largest tax code overhaul in three decades. It created a single flat corporate tax rate of 21%. The reform impacted taxpayers and business owners, particularly through tax cuts.

The TCJA cut the corporate tax rate to benefit shareholders, who tend to be higher earners. It only cut individuals' taxes for a limited period. It scales back the alternative minimum tax (AMT) and estate tax and reduces the taxes levied on pass-through income.

The 2017 Trump tax law was skewed towards the rich. Households with incomes in the top 1% received an average tax cut of more than $60,000 in 2025, compared to an average tax cut of less than $500 for households in the bottom 60%. The law also doubled the amount that the wealthiest households could pass on tax-free to their heirs, from $11 million per married couple to $22 million.

The TCJA's corporate tax cuts did not trickle down to ordinary workers. Instead, they fuelled a record $1 trillion in stock buybacks the year after it passed. The 15 largest corporate beneficiaries of the 2017 tax law have dumped a combined $839 billion into executive-enriching stock buybacks and dividends since its passage.

Trump's plan to slash the corporate tax rate would give the largest corporations a tax cut exceeding federal K-12 education spending. Analysis shows that his plan to cut the corporate tax rate down to 15% would give the largest 100 US companies a total estimated annual tax cut of $48 billion.

Frequently asked questions