Affinity Laws: Open Loop Systems And Their Limitations

The Affinity Laws are a set of formulas that predict the impact of a change in rotational speed or impeller diameter on the head, flow, and power of a pump. They are based on principles of fluid dynamics and can be applied to centrifugal fans and pumps. The Affinity Laws are particularly useful for pump performance prediction, eliminating the need for endless tests on each pump. However, it is important to note that these laws are ideal for theoretical situations, and engineers often apply their own adjustment factors to account for real-world conditions. While the Affinity Laws are widely used, there is some debate about their applicability to open-loop geodetic situations, with some sources suggesting they don't apply as well in such contexts.

Affinity Laws are a set of formulas that predict the impact of a change in rotational speed or impeller diameter on a pump's performance

There are three Affinity Laws:

Law 1: Flow is Proportional to Shaft Speed or Impeller Diameter

This law states that as shaft speed or impeller diameter changes, flow changes by the same proportional amount. For example, if the shaft speed increases by 10%, the flow at the same head will also increase by 10%. This law can be expressed with the formula:

> Q1/Q2 = (N1/N2) or (D1/D2)

Where Q is equal to flow, N is equal to shaft speed, and D is equal to impeller diameter.

Law 2: Pressure is Proportional to the Square of Shaft Speed or Impeller Diameter

According to this law, when shaft speed or impeller diameter changes, pressure changes in proportion to the square of the change. So, if shaft speed increases by 10%, pressure at the same flow will increase by 21%. This law can be expressed as:

> H1/H2 = (N1/N2)² or (D1/D2)²

Where H is equal to head, N is shaft speed, and D is impeller diameter.

Law 3: Power is Proportional to the Cube of Shaft Speed or Impeller Diameter

The third law states that as shaft speed or impeller diameter changes, horsepower changes in proportion to the cube of that change. Therefore, a 10% increase in shaft speed will result in a 33.1% increase in pressure at the same flow. This law is expressed as:

> P1/P2 = (N1/N2)³ or (D1/D2)³

Where P is power, N is shaft speed, and D is impeller diameter.

The Affinity Laws are applicable to both specific centrifugal pumps and a family of geometrically similar centrifugal pumps. They are also known as fan laws and are used to determine performance for changes in operating conditions and scale-up purposes when performance parameters exceed those of existing pumps.

While the Affinity Laws provide a highly accurate prediction of the impact of changes in speed, they are less accurate when applied to changes in impeller diameter as the efficiency of the impeller also changes with a change in diameter.

Affinity Laws apply to centrifugal fans and pumps

Affinity Laws, also known as Fan Laws or Pump Laws, are used in hydraulics, hydronics, and HVAC to express the relationship between variables involved in pump or fan performance. They apply to pumps, fans, and hydraulic turbines, including centrifugal and axial flows. These laws are based on the principles of fluid dynamics and allow for predictions of pump or fan performance under different conditions.

The Affinity Laws for centrifugal pumps and fans specifically indicate the influence on volume capacity, head (pressure), and/or power consumption due to changes in wheel speed (revolutions per minute or RPM) and/or geometric similarity by changing the impeller diameter. It's important to note that the Affinity Laws for pumps are not identical to those for fans.

For centrifugal fans, the Affinity Laws can be used to calculate the resulting volume capacity, head, or power consumption when speed or wheel diameters are altered. The volume flow capacity of a centrifugal fan can be expressed as:

Q1 / q2 = (n1 / n2) * (d1 / d2)^3

Here, q represents the volume flow capacity, n represents the wheel velocity in RPM, and d is the wheel diameter.

The head or pressure of a centrifugal fan can be calculated using the Affinity Laws as:

Dp1 / dp2 = (n1 / n2)^2 * (d1 / d2)^2

In this equation, dp represents the head or pressure, and the other variables remain the same.

Additionally, the Affinity Laws can be used to determine the power consumption of a centrifugal fan:

P1 / P2 = (n1 / n2)^3 * (d1 / d2)^5

Where P represents power, and the other variables remain consistent with the previous equations.

The Affinity Laws for centrifugal pumps function similarly. When the wheel diameter is constant, changes in pump wheel velocity can be calculated using simplified Affinity Laws. For instance, the volume flow capacity of a centrifugal pump with a constant wheel diameter can be expressed as:

Q1 / q2 = (n1 / n2)

Similarly, the head or pressure and power consumption can be calculated using the Affinity Laws when the wheel diameter is constant.

In summary, Affinity Laws are applicable to centrifugal fans and pumps and provide a way to calculate volume capacity, head, and power consumption when factors like wheel speed and diameter are altered. These laws are valuable tools in hydraulics, hydronics, and HVAC for predicting and understanding the performance characteristics of pumps and fans.

Affinity Laws are based on principles of fluid dynamics

Affinity Laws are derived using the Buckingham π theorem and are based on the principles of fluid dynamics. They express the mathematical relationship between variables involved in pump or fan performance, such as head, volumetric flow rate, and shaft speed. Affinity Laws are used to predict the head discharge characteristic of a pump or fan from a known characteristic measured at a different speed or impeller diameter.

The Affinity Laws are:

• Flow is proportional to shaft speed: Q1 / Q2 = N1 / N2
• Pressure or Head is proportional to the square of shaft speed: P1 / P2 = (Q1 / Q2)2
• Power is proportional to the cube of shaft speed: W1 / W2 = (Q1 / Q2)3

These laws assume that the pump or fan efficiency remains constant, which is rarely true in practice. However, they are still useful approximations and can be used to predict the impact of changes in speed or pressure on pumps or fans.

The Affinity Laws can also be applied when the impeller diameter is held constant:

• Flow is proportional to the impeller diameter: Q1 / Q2 = D1 / D2
• Pressure or Head is proportional to the square of the impeller diameter: H1 / H2 = (D1 / D2)2
• Power is proportional to the cube of the impeller diameter: P1 / P2 = (D1 / D2)3

In an open-loop hydraulic system, the Affinity Laws are modified to account for the lift that the pump must overcome. The Affinity Laws are useful in hydraulics, hydronics, and HVAC systems, and they apply to both centrifugal and axial flows.

The Affinity Laws are: Flow, Pressure, and Power

The Affinity Laws are used in hydraulics, hydronics, and HVAC to express the relationship between variables involved in pump or fan performance. They apply to pumps, fans, and hydraulic turbines. The Affinity Laws are:

Flow

The first Affinity Law states that flow is proportional to shaft speed or impeller diameter. This means that as the shaft speed or impeller diameter changes, the flow changes by the same proportional amount. For example, if the shaft speed increases by 10%, the flow at the same head will also increase by 10%.

Pressure

The second Affinity Law states that pressure is proportional to the square of shaft speed or impeller diameter. So, as the shaft speed or impeller diameter changes, the pressure changes in proportion to the square of that change. For instance, if the shaft speed increases by 10%, the pressure at the same flow will increase by 21% (1.10^2).

Power

The third Affinity Law states that power is proportional to the cube of shaft speed or impeller diameter. Therefore, as the shaft speed or impeller diameter changes, the horsepower changes in proportion to the cube of that change. For example, if the shaft speed increases by 10%, the pressure at the same flow will increase by 33.1% (1.10^3).

The Affinity Laws are derived using the Buckingham π theorem and are useful for predicting the head discharge characteristic of a pump or fan from a known characteristic measured at a different speed or impeller diameter. They assume that the pump/fan efficiency remains constant, which is a good approximation when used over appropriate frequency or diameter ranges.

Affinity Laws are useful for pump performance prediction without the need for endless tests

Affinity Laws are a set of formulas that predict the impact of a change in rotational speed or impeller diameter on the head and flow produced by a pump and power demanded by a pump. They are based on the following principles of fluid dynamics:

• Flow (Q) is directly proportional to the speed or diameter change.
• Pressure (P) is proportional to the square of the speed or diameter change.
• Power (W) is proportional to the cube of the speed or diameter change.

These laws are useful for pump performance prediction without the need for endless tests. If you know the shape of a pump performance curve at a certain speed or with a certain impeller diameter, you can use the Affinity Laws to predict the performance of the same or similar pump at a different speed or with a different impeller diameter with a high degree of accuracy.

For example, if you know that a pump produces a certain head and flow at a specific speed, you can use the Affinity Laws to predict the head and flow at a different speed. This is especially useful when trying to determine the corresponding revised power required to deliver a revised flow. The pump can then be resized accordingly.

Affinity Laws can also be used to predict how pump performance will change when the impeller diameter changes. By substituting the diameter for the speed in the formulas, you can predict the performance of the pump with a different impeller diameter.

In a laboratory setting, Affinity Laws are valuable as they allow for the generation of a full performance chart at different speeds without having to conduct numerous tests. This is achieved by first establishing the performance of a pump at a few single-speed test curves, and then using the Affinity Laws to calculate the performance at other speeds.

It is important to note that Affinity Laws are based on theoretical ideal situations, and in real-world applications, adjustments are often made by engineers to account for this discrepancy.

Frequently asked questions