Cyberbullying Laws: Do They Protect Adults Too?

Cyberbullying is a form of bullying that takes place online, via social media, group chats, or text messages. It can be traumatizing for victims, leading to feelings of embarrassment, shame, anxiety, and depression, and has even been a factor in teen suicides. While cyberbullying was previously not addressed by specific laws, most states in the US now include it in their bullying or harassment laws, and schools are legally obligated to address it. However, the question of whether cyberbullying laws apply to adults is complex and depends on the specific circumstances and state laws. In general, cyberbullying laws are often focused on protecting children and students, with schools being mandated to have policies in place to identify and address cyberbullying. Adults who are victims of cyberbullying can seek legal assistance and may be able to pursue criminal or civil remedies, depending on the specific state laws.

Cyberbullying laws vary across US states

Most states have bullying laws in place to address traditional bullying, and a growing number have also implemented online bullying or electronic harassment provisions. For example, California's Safe Place to Learn Act establishes a student's "right to attend classes on school campuses that are safe, secure, and peaceful." Using an electronic device to cause someone to fear for their life, an extreme form of cyberbullying, can be charged as a misdemeanor in California, punishable by up to a year in jail and/or a fine of up to $1,000.

Florida's "Jeffrey Johnston Stand Up for All Students Act" explicitly mentions cyberbullying and directs school districts to draft policies and report instances of bullying. Schools can suspend or expel students found guilty, but enforcement varies across districts. Missouri defines cyberbullying as including "a message, text, sound, or image by means of an electronic device." An individual who uses social media to bully another person with violent threats may be charged with harassment, typically classified as a misdemeanor.

While some states leave law enforcement in the hands of school officials, other states allow victims to seek remedies in civil courts or pursue criminal charges. The penalties for cyberbullying depend on state laws and can range from school suspension or expulsion to jail time.

In conclusion, cyberbullying laws in the US vary from state to state, with some states having more comprehensive legislation and enforcement mechanisms than others. Victims of cyberbullying should seek legal advice to understand their rights and options for recourse under the specific laws of their state.

Criminal vs civil law in cyberbullying cases

Cyberbullying is a serious issue that affects people of all ages. While there is no federal law that specifically addresses bullying, it can sometimes overlap with discriminatory harassment, which is covered by federal civil rights laws. In such cases, schools are legally obligated to address the issue. Additionally, each state has its own laws, policies, and regulations regarding bullying, and some states include specific provisions for cyberbullying.

When it comes to criminal vs civil law in cyberbullying cases, there are a few key differences. Criminal law deals with behaviours that are considered harmful to society as a whole, while civil law focuses on resolving disputes between individuals or organisations. In the context of cyberbullying, here's how criminal and civil law may apply:

Criminal Law in Cyberbullying Cases

Criminal law comes into play when the actions of the cyberbully meet the legal definition of a crime. This can include behaviours such as stalking, hate crimes, or making credible threats. For example, in Florida, cyberstalking is considered a punishable crime, and a person convicted of aggravated stalking is subject to a felony. In some states, cyberbullying laws are included in broader bullying or harassment laws, and offenders can face criminal charges. These laws often focus on the intent to cause harm and the impact on the victim, such as emotional distress or fear for their safety.

Civil Law in Cyberbullying Cases

Civil law comes into play when a victim of cyberbullying seeks legal remedies through the civil court system. This can include suing the cyberbully for damages or seeking a restraining order to stop the harassing behaviour. Civil law may also be relevant in cases where schools or other organisations are deemed negligent in their handling of cyberbullying incidents. For example, in the case of Mallory Grossman, her parents sued the school district for gross negligence due to their failure to address the cyberbullying she experienced.

Balancing Criminal and Civil Law in Cyberbullying

The application of criminal and civil law in cyberbullying cases can vary depending on the specific circumstances and the state in which the incident occurs. In some cases, cyberbullying may be treated as a civil matter, while in other cases, criminal charges may be pursued. It's important to note that the line between criminal and civil law can be blurry, and some behaviours may fall into a grey area. Additionally, the evolution of cyberbullying legislation means that what constitutes cyberbullying and how it is addressed legally can change over time.

Cyberbullying as a form of harassment

Cyberbullying is a form of harassment that involves the use of technology such as computers, mobile phones, and social media platforms to target and abuse an individual or group. It can include various behaviours, such as harassment, doxing, stalking, and the distribution of personal information or compromising content without consent. Cyberbullying is often anonymous and hard to trace, making it challenging for victims to identify their bullies. This form of harassment can have serious and long-lasting consequences for both the bully and the victim, affecting their mental health, social behaviour, and academic performance.

Cyberbullying is not limited to a specific demographic and can happen to anyone. It is, however, more prevalent among teenagers and adolescents due to their increased use of social media and online platforms. The anonymous nature of the internet and the ease of access to technology have contributed to the rise of cyberbullying. Additionally, the impersonal nature of online communication can make it difficult to distinguish between jokes and harassment.

Cyberbullying can be a continuation of traditional bullying or exist exclusively online. In some cases, cyberbullying may be the preferred method of confrontation for bullies, especially when the victim is physically stronger or when face-to-face interaction is undesirable. The effects of cyberbullying can be far-reaching, as the content posted online can be easily shared, spread, and remain accessible long after the initial incident.

To address cyberbullying, it is important to recognise and report harassing behaviours. This can include informing a trusted adult, seeking support from friends and family, or contacting law enforcement if there are immediate safety concerns. Additionally, blocking the bully and ensuring online safety and privacy can help mitigate the impact of cyberbullying.

While there is no federal law specifically addressing bullying in the United States, it often overlaps with discriminatory harassment covered under federal civil rights laws. These laws require schools to address harassment based on race, national origin, colour, sex, disability, or religion. Several states, including California, Florida, and Missouri, have passed laws against cyberbullying, recognising the seriousness of the issue.

Cyberbullying and free speech

Cyberbullying, a form of online harassment, is a persistent problem for educators and lawmakers, especially with the popularity of social media platforms. In the United States, more than 30 states have cyberbullying laws, and others have laws requiring public school districts to include cyberbullying in their anti-bullying policies. However, the issue of cyberbullying intersects with free speech, and several court cases have addressed the constitutionality of cyberbullying laws.

While there is no federal law in the United States that specifically addresses bullying, it can sometimes overlap with discriminatory harassment based on race, national origin, colour, sex, disability, or religion. In these cases, federally-funded schools are legally obligated to address the issue. Cyberbullying laws at the state level, however, have faced legal challenges due to their potential conflict with the First Amendment, which protects freedom of speech.

The First Amendment issue arises because cyberbullying laws often criminalize speech, and the language used in these laws can be overly broad or vague. For example, in People v. Marquan M., the New York Court of Appeals invalidated Albany County's cyberbullying law as overbroad. The law prohibited "any act of communicating or causing a communication to be sent by mechanical or electronic means... with the intent to harass, annoy, threaten, abuse, taunt, intimidate, torment, humiliate, or otherwise inflict significant emotional harm on another person." The court found that this law prohibited types of protected speech beyond cyberbullying. Similarly, in State v. Bishop, the North Carolina Supreme Court invalidated its state's cyberbullying law because it failed to require that the victim suffer any injury from the online tormenting and did not define key terms such as "intimidate" or "torment."

Free-speech advocates argue that the breadth and vagueness of cyberbullying laws put them in jeopardy of violating the First Amendment. On the other hand, some legal experts believe that there is a line that needs to be drawn for what people can say online, especially when it comes to protecting minors from psychological harm. The debate around cyberbullying and free speech continues, and it may be up to the U.S. Supreme Court to ultimately decide on the constitutionality of these laws.

Cyberbullying laws in schools

While there is no federal law that specifically addresses bullying, cyberbullying laws in schools are an important aspect of student protection. Cyberbullying is a form of harassment that utilizes the internet or mobile technology to cause harm, intimidate, or harass another individual. It is a persistent and ever-present issue, occurring through various platforms such as group chats, social media, and gaming communities. The impact of cyberbullying on young people's mental health and well-being cannot be overstated, and in some cases, it has even led to tragic outcomes, including teen suicides.

To combat this issue, nearly all states in the United States have implemented bullying laws, and an increasing number of states are including online bullying or electronic harassment provisions. These laws empower school officials to address cyberbullying incidents and hold offenders accountable for their actions, both on and off-campus. Additionally, federal case law permits schools to discipline students for off-campus behaviour that significantly disrupts the learning environment.

The specific cyberbullying laws vary from state to state. For example, in California, the Safe Place to Learn Act ensures students' right to a safe and peaceful learning environment, and using electronic means to threaten or cause fear can result in misdemeanor charges. In Florida, the "Jeffrey Johnston Stand Up for All Students Act" explicitly mentions cyberbullying and directs school districts to draft policies and report bullying instances, although enforcement varies across districts. Missouri law defines cyberbullying and mandates school employees to report it. Making violent threats via social media can lead to harassment charges, with penalties increasing for repeat offenders.

While civil rights organizations like the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) advocate for school administration to handle student behaviour issues, parents of bullied children often desire a stricter approach, potentially involving the criminal justice system. This discrepancy highlights the delicate balance between protecting individuals from harm and preserving free speech rights under federal law.

Frequently asked questions