Exploring Physics: Space's Unique Rules

Do the laws of physics apply in space? This question delves into the heart of the cosmos, probing the very rules that govern the universe. It challenges us to consider whether the familiar principles of physics, which dictate the behaviour of matter and energy, remain constant throughout the vast expanse of space or if they are subject to variation. The concept of changing physical laws is not far-fetched, as scientists have discovered evidence suggesting that the early universe following the Big Bang was governed by different rules, leading to the violation of parity symmetry and the dominance of matter over antimatter. Astrophysicists have also found indications that the laws of physics may differ in distant regions of the cosmos, beyond our galaxy. These discoveries spark intriguing possibilities and prompt further exploration to uncover the true extent of the laws of physics in space.

Do the laws of physics change over time and space?

There is no principle of physics that says physical laws or constants have to be the same everywhere and always. However, scientists generally regard the laws and constants as unchanging.

According to Einstein's equivalence principle, the laws of physics are the same everywhere. But recent studies have challenged this notion, suggesting that the laws of physics may change across the universe. For example, an international team of scientists led by John Webb analysed light from a quasar located 13 billion light years away. They found that the fine-structure constant, which determines the strength of interactions between light and matter, may have been smaller in that region of the universe compared to on Earth. This implies that the laws of physics may differ across space.

Furthermore, the magnitude of changes in the laws of physics may not be uniform. The same team's research suggests that the value of the fine-structure constant could vary in different directions, indicating that the Cosmos may not be as symmetrical as previously thought.

While these findings are controversial and yet to be proven, they highlight the possibility that the laws of physics could change over time and space. Scientists continue to investigate and test the constancy of physical laws to better understand their nature and applicability.

Do the laws of physics apply everywhere in the universe?

It is generally believed that the laws of physics are the same everywhere in the universe. This is because, when we observe distant objects in space, we are also observing the past. By observing these distant objects, we can determine that the same laws of physics seem to apply. For example, the spectral lines we observe in distant galaxies are the same as those we observe in spectra experiments on Earth, indicating that the electromagnetic forces at work are the same.

However, there is some evidence to suggest that the laws of physics may be different in certain parts of the universe. For instance, scientists have found that the laws of physics in outer space may be different from those in our galaxy. By analysing a quasar signal from 13 billion years ago, astrophysicists found that the magnitude of changes in the laws of physics in the universe varies. This suggests that the laws of physics may have been different in the past and could change in the future.

Additionally, there is ongoing research into the changeability of physical laws, particularly focusing on the numerical constants that populate the equations of quantum mechanics and gravity. While it is challenging to determine if the laws of physics themselves are changing, there is evidence that the numerical constants within them may be evolving. For example, the mass of an electron was zero until a tiny sliver of a second after the Big Bang when the Higgs field turned on.

Furthermore, there are exotic alternative theories that embrace a shifting gravitational constant. While lab experiments on Earth have returned confusing results, studies off Earth suggest that the gravitational constant isn't changing much, if at all.

Are the laws of physics immutable?

The laws of physics are often thought of as immutable—by definition, they are statements that hold true everywhere and everywhen. However, this does not mean that they cannot change over time or space. In fact, there is evidence to suggest that the laws of physics have changed since the Big Bang, and may continue to do so in the future.

For example, scientists have discovered that the universe was briefly governed by different physical laws than those that exist today. During the epoch of inflation, an ultrashort period after the Big Bang when the universe expanded exponentially, the universe favoured a certain cluster shape for galactic groups, violating parity symmetry. This suggests that the laws of physics may have changed during this time, as the current models suggest that the universe should be essentially symmetrical and not prefer any shape over its reversed image.

Additionally, it has been found that the laws of physics may differ in other parts of the universe. By analysing a quasar signal from 13 billion years ago, astrophysicists have found that the laws of physics in outer space may be slightly different from those in our galaxy. For example, the fine-structure constant, which determines the interactions of electric charges or chemical bonds, may have been smaller in the past than it is now. This could have implications for the size of organisms that could emerge, as well as the shapes of stars and planetary systems.

While the laws of physics may be subject to change, this does not mean that they are not universal. In fact, the fact that we can observe consistent spectral lines from distant galaxies suggests that the nuclear forces and electromagnetism are likely the same everywhere. Additionally, the pattern of galaxy clusters in the universe indicates that gravity is also consistent throughout the observable universe.

Overall, while the laws of physics may be mutable, the changes are likely to be subtle and occur over very long timescales. Physicists will continue to search for clues that the rules of the game are changing at a level we haven't yet perceived.

Do the laws of physics apply in a black hole?

It is believed that the laws of physics apply everywhere in the observable universe. By observing distant objects, scientists can effectively time travel and gain insight into the past, and how the laws of physics may have changed over time.

Astrophysicists have discovered that the laws of physics in outer space are different from those in our galaxy. By analysing a quasar signal from 13 billion years ago, they found that the magnitude of changes in the laws of physics in the universe varies. This means that the laws of physics are not uniform across the universe.

Black holes, however, are a different story. The laws of physics do apply in the vicinity of a black hole, but when it comes to the environment at the very centre/core of a black hole, the equations we use to predict how things in the physical world work become problematic. This is because the distance between masses (which could be measured in light years, AU, miles or nanometres) rapidly approaches zero. This means that the force becomes unimaginably high—so strong that no other force can resist it. This is known as a singularity, a location/condition that our equations tell us both should and can't happen.

In other words, the laws of physics do apply to black holes, but our existing laws, equations and logic cease to be useful or make sense.

Do the laws of physics apply in the early universe?

It is generally believed that the laws of physics are universal and have been since the Big Bang. However, there is ongoing research into whether the laws of physics could be different in the early universe.

Astrophysicists have found that the laws of physics in outer space can be different from those in our galaxy. By analysing a quasar signal from 13 billion years ago, they found that the magnitude of changes in these laws varies in the universe. This implies that the laws of physics in the early universe may have been different from what we know them to be now.

The mass of an electron, for instance, was zero until a tiny sliver of a second after the Big Bang, when the Higgs field turned on. Scientists have also studied light from distant quasars to search for changes in the fine-structure constant over billions of years. This constant bundles a handful of other constants, such as the speed of light, the charge on an electron, the electric constant, and Planck's constant. Despite some hints of variation, the latest studies show that changes to the fine-structure constant are consistent with zero. This means that if the constant is changing, it is doing so in a way that is too subtle for current experiments to detect.

There are also cosmological theories, particularly "multiverse" theories, that allow for the possibility that the laws of physics are different in different regions of space, although generally only on much larger scales than what we can observe. One way this could occur is through spontaneous symmetry breaking, where the universe undergoes transitions, similar to phase transitions, as it cools down from very high temperatures. During these transitions, the final state can take on dramatically different forms, leading to completely different sorts of particles and apparent laws in different regions of the universe.

Frequently asked questions