Minimum Wage Laws: Non-Citizens' Rights Explored

The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and individual state laws govern minimum wage laws in the United States. While the FLSA sets a federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour, many states have their own minimum wage laws, and employees are entitled to the higher of the two rates. Interestingly, the applicability of minimum wage laws is not dependent on citizenship status. In New York, for instance, undocumented workers are entitled to the same protections as citizens, and employers are required to pay them according to federal and state labor laws. This includes a minimum wage of $15 per hour and overtime compensation. While undocumented workers may be more vulnerable to exploitation, with employers taking advantage of their fear of authorities, the law protects them, and non-compliance is considered a violation.

Undocumented workers are entitled to minimum wage

Fair Compensation and Prevention of Exploitation

One of the primary reasons why undocumented workers should be entitled to minimum wage is to ensure they receive fair compensation for their labour. Undocumented workers often perform some of the lowest-paying and most arduous jobs, and they are among those most vulnerable to wage theft and unfair treatment by employers. By guaranteeing a minimum wage, we can protect the rights of these workers and ensure they are not taken advantage of.

Reducing Wage Disparities

Evidence suggests that undocumented workers earn significantly lower wages than documented workers or native-born workers with similar skills. This wage gap can be partly attributed to differences in education and other factors such as language proficiency. However, even when controlling for these variables, undocumented workers continue to earn lower wages. Ensuring a minimum wage for all workers can help reduce this wage disparity and promote more equitable compensation.

Positive Economic Effects

Providing a minimum wage for undocumented workers can also have positive economic impacts. Research suggests that legal status increases the bargaining power of workers, leading to higher earnings. This increase in earnings can boost productivity and result in a net increase in GDP. Additionally, a path to legal employment for undocumented workers can lead to better matching between workers' skills and their jobs, further increasing productivity.

Compliance and Enforcement

While undocumented workers are legally entitled to minimum wage, ensuring compliance and enforcement can be challenging. Undocumented workers may face employer intimidation or retaliation when asserting their rights, and they may be less aware of their entitlements or hesitant to pursue legal action due to fears of deportation. Strengthening labour laws, increasing inspections, and providing accessible avenues for reporting wage theft can help improve compliance and protect the rights of undocumented workers.

In summary, guaranteeing a minimum wage for undocumented workers is essential for ensuring fair compensation, reducing wage disparities, and promoting positive economic outcomes. While challenges remain in ensuring compliance and enforcement, protecting the rights of undocumented workers is crucial to creating a more equitable and prosperous society.

Employers may pay undocumented workers less than the minimum wage

In the United States, undocumented workers are entitled to the same wage and hour rights as those who are authorised to work in the country. This means that employers may not pay undocumented workers less than the minimum wage. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) protects workers, even if they are undocumented, from wage theft and ensures they receive overtime pay, minimum wage, and workers' compensation benefits if they suffer injuries on the job.

Despite this, undocumented workers are often victims of wage theft, with employers taking advantage of their precarious situation by paying them less than the minimum wage or denying them overtime pay. This is illegal under both federal and state law. Undocumented workers can take legal action against employers who deny them their rightful wages, although they may hesitate to do so for fear of losing their livelihood or being deported.

Research has shown that undocumented workers tend to have lower educational attainment than documented workers, which may contribute to the wage gap between the two groups. Additionally, undocumented workers may have poorer physical and mental health, lack local skills such as English proficiency, and face obstacles in accessing jobs that match their skills. These factors can limit their productivity and earning potential.

It is important to note that compliance with minimum wage laws does not appear to be lower for immigrants than for native-born workers. However, unauthorised immigrants may be more likely to be paid below the minimum wage than other workers. Providing a path to legal status for undocumented workers could help reduce wage theft and ensure that employers cannot exploit their workers by paying them less than the minimum wage.

Compliance with minimum wage laws is similar for immigrants and natives

In the United States, the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) sets a federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour for covered nonexempt employees. The FLSA provides protections for undocumented workers, entitling them to the same minimum wage and overtime wages as documented individuals. Under the FLSA, an employee's immigration status cannot be used against them, and employers are not permitted to inquire about their citizenship when filing a suit. The Department of Labor's Wage and Hour Division administers and enforces the federal minimum wage law, including for undocumented workers.

While the FLSA sets a federal minimum wage, many states also have their own minimum wage laws, and employees are entitled to the higher of the two minimum wages. For example, in New York State, a minimum wage of $15 per hour has been enacted, with companies given time to adjust based on region and industry. As of 2024, only New York City's "big employers" have met this requirement, while other employers have until the end of 2021 and beyond to catch up.

In summary, while there may be differences in the minimum wage laws at the state and federal levels in the United States, compliance with these laws is similar for immigrants and natives. Unauthorized immigrants may be more likely to be paid below the minimum wage, but they are still protected by laws such as the FLSA, which ensures they are entitled to the same minimum wage and overtime wages as documented individuals.

Unauthorized immigrants are more likely to be paid below minimum wage

Unauthorized immigrants are more likely to be paid below the minimum wage than other workers. This is due to a combination of factors, including their weak bargaining power, lack of legal status, and limited job options.

Undocumented workers often face obstacles that reduce their access to jobs and lower their productivity. They may be unable to work in occupations that match their skills due to their legal status. As a result, they are over-represented in certain sectors, such as cleaning, maintenance, restaurants, and construction. Unauthorized immigrants also have limited bargaining power and may be paid below-market wages. Their lack of legal status makes it difficult for them to advocate for their rights and fair wages.

Additionally, unauthorized immigrants may have lower observable and unobservable skills, such as poorer physical and mental health or an imperfect command of the local language, which can contribute to lower wages. They may also face challenges in obtaining professional licenses, further limiting their job prospects.

Furthermore, unauthorized immigrants are often exploited by employers who take advantage of their vulnerable status. These workers may be hired illegally, and employers can skirt culpability by accepting fake documents or misclassifying workers as independent contractors. This creates an underground labor market where undocumented immigrants are easily exploited and paid less than the minimum wage.

While there is limited research on the impact of minimum wage increases on unauthorized immigrants, the available evidence suggests that they do not face adverse employment effects. In fact, their employment may increase when the minimum wage rises, as employers may substitute them for native-born workers. However, unauthorized immigrants may also be more likely to move away from areas with higher minimum wages to avoid competition and seek better job opportunities.

Undocumented workers are entitled to overtime pay

Undocumented workers are entitled to the same wage and hour rights as other workers. This means that they are covered by the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and are entitled to overtime pay and a fair minimum wage.

In the US, the FLSA sets a minimum wage of $7.25 per hour and overtime at time-and-a-half for all hours worked over 40 in a week. However, many states have their own minimum wages and rules for overtime, and these may apply to undocumented workers. For example, in California, the minimum wage is $10.50 per hour for businesses with 25 employees or fewer, and $11.00 per hour for businesses with 26 employees or more. In addition, overtime is paid at time-and-a-half for all hours worked over 40 in a week and over 8 in a day. If an undocumented worker works seven straight days, they are entitled to time-and-a-half for the first 8 hours on the seventh day and double time for any hours worked beyond that.

In New York, the statewide minimum wage is $15 per hour, and undocumented workers are entitled to overtime pay for hours worked beyond 40 per week.

While undocumented workers have the right to be treated fairly, they are more likely to have their rights violated than authorized workers. Undocumented women are the most likely to be victims of wage theft. However, in numerous decisions, US courts have supported the labor rights of undocumented workers.

In the 2013 case of Lucas v. Jerusalem Cafe, LLC, the court conclusively decided that undocumented workers have the right to sue their employers for unpaid wages, overtime, and the minimum wage under the FLSA. The court also decided that an employee's documentation status is irrelevant and should not be mentioned during a trial.

If an undocumented worker chooses to file a wage claim, they can do so with the relevant state body or the U.S. Department of Labor, without fear of repercussions regarding their immigration status. They can also sue their employer in court.

Frequently asked questions