Understanding Bad Check Laws: Do They Apply To Ach Payments?

A bad check is a check that cannot be cashed due to insufficient funds in the account holder's account or because the account holder has stopped payment on the check without a valid reason. Writing a bad check is considered a crime if the account holder intends to defraud the recipient. ACH (Automated Clearing House) checks, on the other hand, are electronic checks that do not involve a paper check, credit card, wire transfer, or exchange of cash. ACH checks are processed electronically, and the original paper checks are destroyed. So, while bad check laws refer to the intentional act of writing a bad check to defraud someone, ACH payments are a method of processing payments electronically, which can include converting a paper check into an electronic payment. Therefore, bad check laws do not directly apply to ACH payments, but it is possible for someone to write a bad check that is then processed as an ACH payment.

What is a bad check?

A bad check is a check that can't be cashed because the account on which it is drawn either doesn't exist or doesn't have enough funds to cover the amount of the check. Writing a bad check is illegal and is considered fraud if the check writer knew that there were insufficient funds and intended to defraud the recipient.

There are three types of bad checks:

• Non-Sufficient Funds (NSF) checks: A check is NSF if there is not enough money in the account to pay it or the account is closed.
• Stop Payment checks: The person who wrote the check told the bank to stop payment.
• Checks drawn on a nonexistent account.

If you receive a bad check, you can sue the check writer for the amount of the check plus bank fees. You can also add damages to your claim. Before suing, you must send a demand letter requesting payment for the amount of the check, bank fees, and mailing costs. If you are paid within 30 days, your claim is resolved and you cannot file a lawsuit. If you are not paid, you can sue for the amount of the check plus three times that amount in damages, up to a maximum of $1,500 in California.

To avoid writing a bad check, it is important to keep up to date with your finances and verify your balance and whether any checks you have written have cleared before writing another check.

What is an ACH check?

An ACH (Automated Clearing House) check is essentially an electronic check (sometimes called an e-check) or a paperless check. An ACH check is an electronic transfer of funds without a paper check, credit card, wire transfer, or exchange of cash. From the user's end, an ACH payment is made from one individual or organisation to another.

ACH checks are processed through the ACH network, which is a system in which funds are transferred electronically from one party to another. Financial institutions process these transactions in large batches, several times a day. Trillions of dollars are transferred, and billions of payments are made each year via the ACH network.

One of the most common examples of setting up an ACH payment is direct deposit. Other types of payments for which you may send or receive an ACH check include social security payments, estimated tax payments to the IRS, government benefit payments, economic impact payments, and healthcare claim payments.

ACH payments can clear quickly, sometimes on the same day they are entered, on business days during business hours. However, because of the way ACH transactions are processed, and because the network must guard against fraud and money laundering, payments can take days to complete.

What are the penalties for bad checks?

Writing a bad check is illegal and can result in various penalties. A bad check is one that cannot be negotiated because it is drawn from a non-existent account or an account that does not hold sufficient funds to cover the amount. While banks usually charge a fee for unintentionally writing a bad check, the penalties for intentionally passing a bad check range from misdemeanors to felonies, depending on the amount of the check and the state in which it is written.

The penalties for writing bad checks can vary depending on the specific laws in each state and the circumstances of the crime. Some common penalties for bad check crimes include:

• Fines: A person convicted of writing a bad check may be required to pay fines, with the amount varying depending on the check amount and the jurisdiction. In the US, fines for check fraud can be as high as one million dollars.
• Restitution: The person convicted of writing a bad check may have to pay restitution to the victim, compensating them for any financial losses incurred due to the bad check.
• Community Service: Performing community service may be required as a penalty for writing a bad check.
• Probation: The convicted individual may be placed on probation, which involves a period of supervision with certain conditions set by the court.
• Imprisonment: Depending on the severity of the crime and the jurisdiction, writing a bad check can result in imprisonment. For example, in New York, jail time is capped at three months, while California allows for up to a year of incarceration. In Texas, writing a bad check is considered a felony with a potential prison sentence of up to two years.
• Criminal Record: A conviction for a bad check crime will result in a criminal record, which can impact future employment and other opportunities.

Additionally, banks may charge a non-sufficient funds (NSF) fee for each bad check written, which can be as high as $35. The person who wrote the bad check may also be responsible for any fees incurred by the payee.

How do you avoid writing a bad check?

Writing a bad check can have serious consequences, including criminal penalties, civil lawsuits, and a negative impact on your credit score. To avoid writing a bad check, it is important to follow these steps:

• Keep a Close Eye on Your Bank Balance: Take advantage of online banking to monitor your account balance regularly. This will help you avoid writing checks for amounts that exceed your available funds. Remember that there is a difference between your account balance and your available balance, so always err on the side of caution.
• Understand the Check Clearing Process: Be aware that checks can be processed electronically, and funds may be deducted from your account more quickly than with traditional paper check processing. This is especially true for ACH (Automated Clearing House) transactions, which are electronic transfers without a paper check.
• Verify Check Clearance: Before spending money from a deposited check, make sure it has cleared your account. Deposited funds may take several days to become available, so don't assume the funds are immediately accessible.
• Use Overdraft Protection: Consider adding overdraft protection to your account as a safeguard. This will allow your account to dip below a $0 balance and prevent bounced checks, but be aware that your bank will charge interest and fees for this service.
• Communicate with Payees: If you realize that a check you've written might not clear, contact the payee and request to hold the check until a later date. While it may be embarrassing, it's better than incurring fees from both your bank and the payee.
• Maintain a Buffer: Keep some extra cash in your account as a buffer to account for any unexpected expenses or delays in deposit credits. This can help prevent accidental overspending and bounced checks.

By following these steps, you can significantly reduce the risk of writing a bad check and avoid the associated financial and legal consequences.

What to do if you receive a bad check

A bad check, also known as a "hot check", is one that can't be negotiated because it's drawn from a non-existent account or an account that doesn't hold sufficient funds to cover its amount. If you receive a bad check, there are several steps you can take to resolve the issue:

• Contact the issuer of the check: Politely but assertively inform the issuer of the bounced check and try to settle the matter. If the issuer promises to pay or pay by instalment, you may not need to take further action.
• Try to cash the check again: Wait a few days and ask the check writer if it's safe to redeposit the bounced check. If so, go to the writer's bank and cash it there, rather than redepositing it at your bank, to avoid being charged an additional fee if the check bounces again.
• Send a demand letter: If the issue escalates, draft a formal demand for payment and send it to the issuer and their bank via certified mail with a return receipt requested. In your letter, request to be paid within a specified time frame for the amount of the bounced check, the cost of certified mail, and any returned check fees.
• Sue in small claims court: If you aren't paid or don't hear back from the issuer by the deadline, consider suing in small claims court. The amount of your claim must not exceed your state's small claims limit, typically between $2,000 and $5,000.

It's important to act quickly when you receive a bad check to minimize potential fees and overdraft charges. Additionally, keep in mind that the steps outlined above may vary depending on your location and the specific circumstances of the case.

Frequently asked questions