Murphy's Law: Wisconsin's Exception Or Rule?

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption, a notable exception to the Fair Housing Act, allows owner-occupied homes with four or fewer rental units to discriminate against certain groups when choosing tenants. The exemption was created in 1964 by Senator Aiken, who argued that small property owners like the hypothetical Mrs. Murphy, an elderly widow who ran a bed and breakfast, should be able to choose their tenants. While the exemption has evolved since its creation, with race no longer a factor, it still permits discrimination based on sex and religion. The exemption is controversial, with fair housing groups calling for its repeal, and it does not apply in all states. So, does the Mrs. Murphy Exemption apply in Wisconsin?

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption allows property owners to discriminate against certain groups when choosing tenants

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption, a part of the Fair Housing Act, allows property owners to discriminate against certain groups when choosing tenants. This exemption applies to owner-occupied homes with four or fewer rental units, meaning the owner lives in one of the units. While the Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination against protected classes in real estate, the Mrs. Murphy Exemption provides a loophole for small-scale landlords.

The exemption was created in 1964 by Senator Aiken, who used the hypothetical example of Mrs. Murphy, an elderly widow who ran a small bed and breakfast. Mrs. Murphy, a fictional bigot, worried that her white guests might not want to share a space with racial minorities, so she chose only to rent to white tenants. Senator Aiken argued that due to the small size of her property, Mrs. Murphy should be allowed to choose her tenants. As a result, the Mrs. Murphy Exemption was included in the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

It's important to note that the exemption has evolved since its creation. While it initially allowed discrimination based on race, the Civil Rights Act of 1866 now strictly forbids this. However, property owners who fall under the exemption can still discriminate based on specific factors. For example, if Mrs. Murphy prefers to rent to female tenants or fellow widows, she is within her rights to turn down other applicants.

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption is highly controversial, with many fair housing groups calling for its repeal. They argue that it encourages housing discrimination and denies equal opportunities to protected classes. Some states have implemented limitations or overridden this loophole entirely. Additionally, the exemption does not apply to advertising; property owners cannot include discriminatory statements in their rental advertisements.

While the Mrs. Murphy Exemption provides a legal loophole for small-scale landlords, it is essential to recognize its problematic nature and the potential for housing discrimination. Landlords must remain conscientious about treating all prospective tenants equally and complying with state and federal housing laws.

The exemption only applies to owner-occupied homes with four or fewer rental units

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption is a notable exception to the Fair Housing Act, which was a part of the Civil Rights Act of 1968. The exemption applies specifically to owner-occupied homes with four or fewer rental units, meaning these properties are exempt from certain aspects of the Fair Housing Act. This loophole allows property owners to discriminate against certain groups when selecting tenants.

The exemption was created to exemplify why the Fair Housing Act should have exemptions. The hypothetical Mrs. Murphy, an elderly widow, runs a small bed and breakfast to help pay the bills. She worries that her white guests may not want to share a space with racial minorities, so she chooses only to rent to white tenants.

Senator Aiken, who created the imaginary Mrs. Murphy, argued that because she lived in a property with only four rental units, she should be able to choose her tenants. As a result, the Mrs. Murphy Exemption was put into law under Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It is important to note that this exemption does not apply to advertising; property owners cannot be discriminatory in their advertisements, even if their property falls under the Mrs. Murphy Exemption.

While the Mrs. Murphy Exemption still exists, it has evolved since its creation in 1964. For example, property owners can no longer discriminate based on race, as this is strictly forbidden by the Civil Rights Act of 1866. However, they can still discriminate based on certain other factors. For instance, if Mrs. Murphy prefers to rent to female tenants or fellow widows, the exemption gives her the right to turn down other applicants.

It was created by Senator Aiken in 1964 to exemplify why the Fair Housing Act should have exemptions

In 1964, Senator Aiken created the fictional character of Mrs Murphy, an elderly widow who ran a small bed and breakfast from her home. Aiken's character was bigoted and worried that her white guests would not approve of sharing a space with racial minorities. As a result, she chose only to rent rooms to white tenants. Aiken argued that because Mrs Murphy lived in a property with only four rental units, she should be able to choose her tenants. This argument led to the creation of the Mrs Murphy Exemption, which was added to the Fair Housing Act under Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

The Mrs Murphy Exemption states that owner-occupied homes with four or fewer rental units are exempt from certain aspects of the Fair Housing Act. This exemption allows property owners to discriminate against certain groups when choosing tenants. The exemption was intended to protect small-scale landlords like Mrs Murphy, who wanted to choose who she shared her home with.

The Mrs Murphy Exemption has been controversial since its creation. Many fair housing groups have called for its repeal, arguing that it encourages housing discrimination and denies equal opportunities to protected classes. While the exemption still exists, it has been limited over time. For example, landlords can no longer discriminate based on race, as this is forbidden by the Civil Rights Act of 1866.

Today, property owners who fall under the Mrs Murphy Exemption can still discriminate based on specific factors. For instance, if Mrs Murphy prefers to rent to female tenants or fellow widows, she can legally turn down other applicants. The exemption also does not apply to advertising, meaning that Mrs Murphy cannot run rental advertisements that discriminate against certain groups. Additionally, if a real estate agent represents the property owner, they must comply with the federal Fair Housing Act and cannot engage in discriminatory behaviour.

The exemption was put into law under Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption was put into law under Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (or 1968, according to another source). The exemption states that owner-occupied homes with four or fewer rental units are exempt from certain aspects of the Fair Housing Act. In other words, if a property owner lives in a home with three other rented rooms, they can discriminate against certain protected classes when choosing tenants.

The exemption was created by Senator Aiken in 1964 to exemplify why the Fair Housing Act should have exemptions. He created the hypothetical Mrs. Murphy, an elderly widow and property owner who runs a small bed and breakfast to help pay the bills. Mrs. Murphy worries that her white guests may not want to share a space with racial minorities, so she only chooses tenants who are white.

Senator Aiken argued that because Mrs. Murphy lives in a property with only four rental units, she should be able to choose her tenants. As a result, the Mrs. Murphy Exemption was included in the Civil Rights Act. However, it's important to note that this exemption does not allow discrimination based on race; the Civil Rights Act of 1866 strictly forbids that.

Today, the Mrs. Murphy Exemption allows property owners who fall under the exemption to discriminate based on specific factors. For example, if Mrs. Murphy prefers to rent to female tenants or fellow widows to support her limited income, the exemption gives her the right to turn down other applicants.

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption does not apply to advertising

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption, created in 1964, states that owner-occupied homes with four or fewer rental units are exempt from certain aspects of the Fair Housing Act. This means that property owners can discriminate against certain groups when looking for tenants. However, this exemption does not apply to advertising.

The exemption was designed to give landlords more freedom in choosing their tenants, but it has come under scrutiny for promoting housing discrimination. While the exemption allows landlords to discriminate based on certain factors, it does not permit them to be discriminatory in their advertisements. For example, a landlord cannot state in an advertisement that people of a specific race or sexual orientation should not apply. Such an action would be illegal, even if the property is exempt from the Fair Housing Act.

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption specifically targets owner-occupied dwellings with a small number of rental units. It was created to exemplify why the Fair Housing Act should have exemptions, giving landlords more autonomy in tenant selection. However, this exemption does not extend to advertising, as it would still constitute discrimination, which is prohibited by law.

Landlords need to be cautious when advertising rental properties, even if they fall under the Mrs. Murphy Exemption. They cannot use discriminatory language or indicate a preference for specific applicants based on protected characteristics such as race, gender, or sexual orientation. Doing so would be a violation of fair housing laws, regardless of the property's exemption status.

In conclusion, while the Mrs. Murphy Exemption provides a loophole for certain landlords to discriminate in their tenant selection, it does not apply to advertising. Landlords must ensure that their advertisements are nondiscriminatory and comply with fair housing laws to avoid legal repercussions and promote equal housing opportunities.

Frequently asked questions