Murphy's Law: Accessory Dwellings And Legal Implications

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption to the Fair Housing Act states that if a landlord lives in one of four or fewer rental units in a single dwelling, that home is exempt from the Fair Housing Act and discrimination lawsuits. This exemption was created to exemplify why the Fair Housing Act should have exemptions, with the hypothetical Mrs. Murphy, an elderly widow, running a small bed and breakfast and not wanting to share a space with people of colour. While the Mrs. Murphy Exemption is a federal law, each state can reduce its reach, and it does not apply if the landlord has a real estate license, a second building, or hires a real estate professional to find tenants.

Mrs Murphy Exemption only applies to dwellings with four or fewer units

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption is a notable exception to the Fair Housing Act (FHA). This exemption allows landlords to discriminate against certain groups when looking for tenants, which is otherwise prohibited by the FHA.

The exemption applies to dwellings with four or fewer rental units, where the owner lives in one of those units. In this case, the entire home is exempt from the FHA, and the landlord can choose their tenants based on their own criteria.

It is important to note that this exemption does not apply to advertising. Landlords cannot state discriminatory practices in any marketing materials, advertisements, or applications. If a landlord rejects an applicant for discriminatory reasons, they cannot inform the applicant of the real reason for the rejection.

Additionally, the Mrs. Murphy Exemption does not apply if the owner becomes a professional landlord. This can occur if the owner obtains a real estate license, buys a second building, or hires a real estate professional to find tenants. In these cases, the landlord must comply with the FHA and cannot use the Mrs. Murphy Exemption.

While the Mrs. Murphy Exemption is a federal law, each state has the right to reduce its reach or provide more stringent protections. Therefore, it is essential to check the specific regulations in your state before applying this exemption.

The owner must live in one of the units

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption to the Fair Housing Act (FHA) states that if a landlord lives in one unit of a single dwelling with four or fewer rental units, the entire home is exempt from the FHA. This exemption allows property owners to discriminate against certain groups when choosing tenants.

The exemption was created with a hypothetical owner-occupied dwelling in mind, with the fictional Mrs. Murphy as the owner. Mrs. Murphy was an elderly widow who ran a small bed and breakfast to make ends meet. She was also a racist who didn't want to eat with people of other races and worried that her white guests would not approve of sharing a space with racial minorities.

Senator Aiken created Mrs. Murphy in 1964 to exemplify why the FHA should have exemptions. The senator argued that because Mrs. Murphy lived in a property with only four rental units, she should be able to choose her tenants. As a result, the Mrs. Murphy Exemption was put into law under Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

It is important to note that the Mrs. Murphy Exemption does not apply to advertising. Landlords cannot state discriminatory practices in any marketing materials, advertisements, or on applications. If a landlord rejects an applicant for discriminatory reasons, they cannot inform the applicant of the real reason for the rejection. Additionally, if the landlord hires a real estate professional to find tenants, the exemption no longer applies.

While the Mrs. Murphy Exemption is a federal law, each state has the right to reduce its reach. Some states have chosen to limit or override this discriminatory loophole. For example, Massachusetts restricts the exemption to owner-occupied rentals of two units or fewer. Therefore, it is crucial to check the specific regulations of your state before applying the Mrs. Murphy Exemption.

The exemption cannot be used in advertising

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption is a controversial aspect of the Fair Housing Act, which allows property owners to discriminate against certain groups when looking for tenants. However, this exemption does not apply to advertising.

The exemption was created in 1964 by Senator Aiken, who used the hypothetical example of Mrs. Murphy, an elderly widow who runs a small bed and breakfast from her home to pay the bills. Mrs. Murphy is bigoted and worries that her white guests may not like sharing a space with racial minorities, so she only chooses tenants who are white.

Senator Aiken argued that because Mrs. Murphy lives in a property with only four rental units, she should be able to choose her tenants. As a result, the Mrs. Murphy Exemption was put into law under Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

While the exemption still applies today, it is important to note that it does not permit discriminatory advertising. Mrs. Murphy cannot run a rental advertisement stating that certain groups, such as religious minorities or people of a particular sexual orientation, need not apply. This would be illegal.

In addition, Mrs. Murphy cannot tell prospective renters that they are being denied tenancy due to their protected characteristics. She must deny their application without providing a reason.

If Mrs. Murphy chooses to become a real estate agent or obtain a real estate license, she can no longer discriminate against tenants in her home based on sex, religion, or other protected characteristics. In these cases, she must comply with the federal Fair Housing Act, which prohibits discrimination.

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption is controversial, and many fair housing groups have called for its repeal. They argue that it encourages housing discrimination and denies equal opportunities to protected classes. Some states have implemented limitations or overrides to this loophole.

The exemption does not apply if the owner gets a real estate license

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption is a federal law that applies to the entire United States. The exemption states that owner-occupied homes with four or fewer rental units are exempt from certain aspects of the Fair Housing Act (FHA). This means that property owners can discriminate against certain groups when looking for tenants.

However, it is important to note that this exemption does not apply if the owner gets a real estate license. If a property owner decides to take the real estate exam and obtain a license, they can no longer discriminate against tenants in their home based on sex, religion, or other protected characteristics. Real estate professionals must comply with the federal Fair Housing Act, which prohibits discrimination against protected classes in real estate.

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption was created in 1964 by Senator Aiken, who argued that an owner-occupied dwelling with a small number of rental units should be exempt from the FHA. The exemption was based on the hypothetical elderly widow Mrs. Murphy, who wanted to rent out part of her home and choose her tenants. While the exemption originally allowed for discrimination based on race, this is no longer permitted due to the Civil Rights Act of 1866.

Today, property owners who fall under the exemption can still discriminate based on certain factors, such as gender or religion. However, they cannot state their discriminatory practices in any marketing materials, advertisements, or applications. Additionally, the exemption does not apply if the owner hires a real estate professional to find tenants or acquires a second building, as this would classify them as a professional landlord.

The exemption does not apply if the owner buys a second building

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption is a notable exception to the Fair Housing Act, which was a part of the Civil Rights Act of 1968. The exemption applies to owner-occupied homes with four or fewer rental units, allowing property owners to discriminate against certain groups when choosing tenants.

The exemption was created to exemplify why the Fair Housing Act should have exemptions. The hypothetical Mrs. Murphy, an elderly widow, runs a small bed and breakfast to help pay the bills. She worries that her white guests may not want to share a space with racial minorities, so she only rents to white tenants.

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption has limitations and does not apply in all cases. For example, it does not apply if the owner purchases a second building. This means that if the owner of an exempt property, as outlined above, buys an additional building, they cannot use the Mrs. Murphy Exemption to discriminate against tenants in the new building. The exemption only applies if the owner occupies one of the units in the building and rents out the other four or fewer units.

In addition, the exemption does not apply to advertising. For instance, Mrs. Murphy cannot run a rental advertisement stating that specific religious groups should not apply. Furthermore, she cannot tell prospective renters why they are being denied tenancy; she must deny their application without providing her reasoning.

The Mrs. Murphy Exemption is controversial, with many fair housing groups calling for its repeal. These organizations argue that the exemption encourages housing discrimination and denies equal opportunities to protected classes.

Frequently asked questions