Lemon Law And Recalls: What's The Connection?

Lemon laws are designed to protect consumers who have purchased defective vehicles. When a manufacturer issues a recall, they are acknowledging that the affected vehicles are defective. However, this does not automatically classify a vehicle as a lemon. For a vehicle to be considered a lemon, the manufacturer must be given a reasonable number of attempts to repair the defect before consumers can seek compensation under lemon laws. The specific criteria for what constitutes a reasonable number of repair attempts vary by state.

In the case of Florida's Lemon Law, for example, the law covers defects reported within the first 24 months of ownership. Therefore, recalls announced outside of this period will not be covered by the law. Other laws, such as the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, can hold manufacturers responsible if they fail to repair defects that prompt a recall.

It is important to note that each state in the United States has its own lemon law, offering slightly different standards of protection. These laws cover what are referred to as nonconformities, which are any defects or problems that occur before the vehicle's arrival to the consumer.

To determine if a recalled vehicle qualifies as a lemon, consumers should consult with a lemon law attorney who specializes in their state's regulations.

What is a lemon law?

Lemon laws in the United States are designed to protect consumers who purchase or lease defective vehicles. Each state has its own lemon law, and while they are all slightly different, they all give consumers a straightforward process for bringing a legal claim against an automaker.

The Florida Lemon Law, for example, applies to both purchased and leased vehicles, but it does not cover all vehicles. It includes personal/household use cars, pickup trucks, and SUVs, but it does not include commercial vehicles, used vehicles, motorcycles, mopeds, off-road vehicles, boats, or trucks over 10,000 pounds G.V.W.

The Florida Lemon Law covers defects under the manufacturer's warranty that affect the use, value, or safety of the vehicle. It does not cover defects that result from accidents, abuse, neglect, modification, or alteration of the vehicle by anyone other than the manufacturer or its authorized service agent.

To qualify for compensation under the Florida Lemon Law, consumers must first give the manufacturer an opportunity to repair the defect. If the manufacturer does not repair the defect after a "reasonable number of attempts," the consumer is entitled to a refund or replacement.

A "reasonable number of attempts" is generally considered to be three repair attempts for the same problem, or if the vehicle has been out of service for 15 days or more for the repair of one or more defects. After this, the consumer must give the manufacturer written notice of the defect and allow them 10 days to respond and repair the vehicle. If the problem persists, the consumer can bring a Lemon Law claim.

It's important to note that the Florida Lemon Law only applies to defects reported within the first 24 months of ownership. Recalls that are announced outside of this "Lemon Law Rights Period" will not be covered by the law, but other laws, such as the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, can hold manufacturers responsible for defects that prompt a recall.

What is a recall?

A recall is a request to return, exchange, or replace a product after a manufacturer or consumer watch group discovers defects that could hinder performance, harm consumers, or produce legal issues for the producers. Recalls are usually conducted voluntarily by the manufacturer. However, in rare instances, if a manufacturer or importer fails to recall a product that poses a health risk, a government agency like the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) may issue a recall order.

In the case of vehicles, recalls that are announced outside of the Lemon Law Rights Period (the first 24 months of ownership) will not be covered by the law.

Does a recall make my car a lemon?

A recall does not automatically make your car a lemon. However, if the manufacturer fails to fix the issue within a given time or number of attempts, your car may be classified as a lemon. The number of repair attempts or the time frame within which the manufacturer must fix the issue is determined by your state's lemon law.

Lemon laws cover what are referred to as "nonconformities," which are any defects or problems that occur before the vehicle's arrival to the consumer. These defects can range from faulty components to substandard materials and even simple human error during the manufacturing process.

If you find yourself in a situation where your car has been recalled, but there is no immediate fix available, it is important to take certain steps to address the issue and protect your rights as a consumer. Contact your local dealership and the manufacturer to inquire about a loaner car and to get details on when parts will be available. Keep detailed records of all communication and expenses incurred from the recall, as these will be valuable evidence if you decide to make a lemon law claim.

If the recall-related issue persists for an extended period and the dealership or manufacturer fails to address the problem, you may want to consult a lemon law attorney who specializes in your state's regulations. They can guide you through the process of filing a lemon law complaint and help you seek the compensation you deserve.

What to do if your recalled car can't be fixed?

If your recalled car can't be fixed, there are several steps you can take to address the issue and protect your rights as a consumer. Here's a detailed guide on what to do in such a situation:

Contact Your Dealership

Get in touch with your local dealership, especially if the recall states that your vehicle is unsafe to drive or recommends limiting its use. You can request a loaner car from the dealership while your car is being repaired, even if the recall notice doesn't mention it. Dealerships can provide loaner cars, and automakers can approve payment for these.

Contact the Manufacturer

If your dealership can't help or fails to solve the problem, reach out to the manufacturer directly. They may have information about when parts will be available and how long the repair might take. You can usually find a contact number and website in your owner's manual or on the recall notice itself.

Advocate for Yourself

If the recall is related to a serious safety issue or is causing significant inconvenience and the dealership or manufacturer is unresponsive, consider asking the dealership to repurchase the vehicle. It depends on various factors, but it's important to initiate the conversation. You can also complain to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), as this may pressure the automaker to act.

Consult a Lemon Law Attorney

If you're not getting the desired outcome from the dealership or manufacturer, consider contacting a lemon law attorney who specializes in your state's regulations. Lemon laws are meant to protect consumers who own products with repeated defects. These laws vary by state, so consult your state's consumer protection office for specific details.

To qualify as a "lemon," a car typically must meet certain criteria, including the number of days it has been out of service, the severity of the defect, and the number of failed repair attempts. In most cases, it involves three or four repair attempts within a specific timeframe.

However, keep in mind that lemon laws have statutes of limitation. Most claims must be submitted within one or two years of the vehicle's purchase, and there are usually mileage limitations as well.

Keep Detailed Records

Maintain detailed notes of all communication with the dealership, manufacturer, and their representatives. Also, keep any receipts for expenses incurred due to the recall, such as rental cars, parking, gas, or towing fees. These records will be valuable if you decide to pursue a lemon law claim or seek compensation.

Seek Compensation

In some cases, automakers may offer compensation to owners of vehicles with unfixable recalls. You may be able to get money back for out-of-pocket expenses, or the automaker may help you get a replacement vehicle. Additionally, you may be able to join a class-action lawsuit against the vehicle manufacturer if many vehicle owners face similar economic losses due to the recall.

Remember that each state's lemon laws are unique, so be sure to consult a professional for specific advice regarding your situation.

What is the lemon law process?

Lemon laws are designed to protect consumers who purchase or lease defective vehicles. They require the manufacturer to repurchase a vehicle that has a significant defect that they are unable to repair within a reasonable amount of time.

The lemon law process typically involves the following steps:

Step 1: Identify the Issue

First, identify whether your vehicle or other consumer good has a defect or condition that substantially impairs its use, value, or safety. This could include mechanical issues, safety hazards, or other problems that affect the vehicle's performance.

Step 2: Report the Issue

Report the issue to the manufacturer or its authorized service agent, usually the dealer, as soon as possible. Keep detailed records of all repairs and maintenance, including dates, odometer readings, and any expenses incurred.

Step 3: Allow for Repair Attempts

Give the manufacturer or their authorized service agent a "reasonable number" of attempts to repair the defect. What constitutes a "reasonable number" of attempts may vary depending on the specific lemon law in your state. In some cases, it may be as few as three attempts, while in others, it could be more.

Step 4: Notify the Manufacturer

If the issue persists after a reasonable number of repair attempts, notify the manufacturer in writing via certified, registered, or express mail. This notification should include all relevant documentation, such as repair records and expenses incurred.

Step 5: Request Arbitration

If the manufacturer fails to resolve the issue, you may need to request arbitration. Arbitration is a process where a neutral third party, known as an arbitrator, will review your case and determine whether a reasonable number of repair attempts have been made. Arbitration is often a prerequisite to filing a lawsuit.

Step 6: Legal Action

If you are dissatisfied with the outcome of arbitration or if the manufacturer does not comply with the arbitrator's decision, you may need to take legal action by filing a lawsuit against the manufacturer. It is advisable to seek the assistance of a lemon law attorney to guide you through the legal process and improve your chances of success.

Step 7: Compensation

If your vehicle is determined to be a "lemon," you may be entitled to a refund, a replacement vehicle, or other forms of compensation, such as reimbursement for incidental expenses. The specific remedies available to you will depend on the laws in your state and the circumstances of your case.

Frequently asked questions