Abortion Laws: Impact On Doctors' Work And Lives

Abortion laws have a direct impact on doctors, affecting their ability to provide essential healthcare to women and potentially hindering treatment for patients in life-or-death situations. Doctors fear prosecution, losing their medical licenses, or being charged with a felony if they perform an abortion, even in cases where the patient's life is at risk. The vague and confusing language of abortion laws, which vary from state to state, makes it challenging for doctors to interpret and apply them in practice. This has led to a chilling effect, with doctors scared to provide necessary emergency care. The situation is further complicated by the conflict between state abortion laws and federal laws, such as the Emergency Medical Treatment & Labor Act (EMTALA), which mandates that hospitals stabilise patients in an emergency, including performing abortions when necessary. Doctors in states with abortion bans are struggling to navigate this complex legal landscape, and some have opted to leave these states or the field of OB-GYN altogether.

Doctors may be prosecuted for performing abortions

The confusion around abortion laws has led to a situation where physicians are uncertain about the circumstances under which they can legally perform an abortion. The laws are often vague and open to interpretation, and each state law varies its wording for exceptions. For example, Idaho allows abortions if the physician determines in "good faith medical judgment" that it is necessary to prevent the death of the pregnant woman. Texas allows abortions when, "in the exercise of reasonable medical judgment," the pregnant person has a life-threatening condition.

The lack of clarity on qualifying exceptions has resulted in doctors seeking guidance from hospital lawyers, and some doctors have opted to leave states with abortion restrictions or the field of obstetrics and gynecology altogether. Doctors are now having to navigate legal concepts they don't have the training for while being prohibited from using their expertise to treat patients. This has resulted in delays in care, which can be dangerous for patients.

The restrictive abortion laws also disproportionately affect low-income people of color, immigrants, and non-English speakers, and have the potential to exacerbate already existing racial inequities in maternal and neonatal outcomes. Abortion restrictions create geographic, transportation, and financial barriers to obtaining an abortion, which can result in increased rates of maternal death and adverse outcomes.

Doctors may lose their medical license

The laws surrounding abortion are often confusing and vague, and it is not always clear how much risk of death a pregnant patient must be in for an exception to apply. This leaves doctors in a difficult situation, as they may be prosecuted, imprisoned, or lose their medical license for providing medically necessary care.

The fear of losing their medical license has led some doctors to delay providing care or refer patients to other states for abortions. This can put pregnant people at risk, as their condition may deteriorate while they wait for treatment.

The threat of losing their medical license, as well as other potential repercussions, has caused some doctors to leave states with abortion restrictions or the field of obstetrics and gynaecology altogether. This has exacerbated existing disparities in access to obstetric care and adverse maternal and fetal outcomes.

Doctors may be sued

The fear of being sued has led to a "chilling effect," with doctors being scared to provide necessary emergency care. This has resulted in delays in treatment and, in some cases, women having to travel out of state to receive abortions. The lack of clarity and vague wording in abortion laws have further contributed to the confusion among doctors, who are unsure about the legality of performing abortions even in medical emergencies.

To protect themselves from legal repercussions, doctors in states with restrictive abortion laws may refer patients to other states for abortions or seek guidance from hospital lawyers before providing treatment. However, this often results in delays in care, putting patients at risk. The situation has also led to a decrease in the number of physicians practising in states with abortion restrictions, as some doctors have opted to leave these states or the field of obstetrics and gynaecology altogether.

The threat of lawsuits has had a significant impact on the doctor-patient relationship and has changed the way doctors practise medicine. It has also affected the availability of abortion services, with some hospitals and doctors refusing to perform abortions even in cases where the pregnant person's life is at risk. This has had severe consequences for patients, who may be denied timely and necessary medical care.

Doctors may be charged with a felony

The lack of clarity in abortion laws has left many doctors confused about the legality of performing abortions, even when the patient's life is at risk. The laws are often vague and open to interpretation, leaving doctors unsure of where they stand legally. This has resulted in doctors seeking legal guidance before providing treatment, causing delays in care.

In some states, such as Texas, abortion is allowed when a pregnant person has a life-threatening condition that is aggravated by, caused by, or arising from the pregnancy. However, the exception is not always clear, and doctors fear losing their medical licenses, being sued, or facing criminal charges if they provide an abortion.

The situation is further complicated by the fact that malpractice insurance does not cover criminal charges, leaving doctors vulnerable to potential legal consequences. The fear of prosecution has led to a decline in doctors willing to provide abortions, even in cases where it is legal.

The impact of these laws extends beyond doctors, as patients are also affected. Some women have been turned away from hospitals and forced to travel out of state to obtain abortions, while others have had to wait until their condition deteriorates further.

The legal landscape surrounding abortion is rapidly changing, and doctors are struggling to keep up with the new regulations and reporting requirements. The situation has permanently changed the doctor-patient relationship, with doctors now involving lawyers in medical decisions and patients losing trust in their doctors' ability to provide necessary care.

Doctors may leave states with abortion restrictions

The overturning of Roe v. Wade has had a profound impact on doctors across the United States, with many now facing legal repercussions for performing abortions. As a result, some doctors have decided to leave states with strict abortion restrictions, while others have changed careers or moved to other specialties.

In Texas, for example, a six-week abortion ban has made it difficult for doctors to provide essential care to their patients. Dr. Alireza Shamshirsaz, a physician in Houston, recounted a case where he had to send a couple with a non-viable pregnancy to another state for treatment due to the restrictive abortion laws in Texas. He eventually decided to leave the state and now practices in Boston, where he feels relieved to be in a state without abortion restrictions.

Dr. Catherine Romanos, an abortion provider in Ohio, also faced challenges due to the state's six-week abortion ban. She went from performing 40 to 50 abortions per day to seeing only a handful of patients daily. The constantly changing laws and restrictions have made it difficult for doctors like Romanos to plan their careers and provide consistent care to their patients.

The impact of abortion restrictions goes beyond the doctors themselves. Dr. Zevidah Vickery, a former OB-GYN in Ohio, decided to leave the field of obstetrics and gynecology due to the state's restrictive abortion laws. She retrained as an addiction specialist, feeling that she had no choice but to leave a job she loved.

Dr. Leilah Zahedi-Spung, a maternal foetal medicine specialist, has also been affected by the abortion restrictions in Tennessee. She has had to send patients out of state for care, sometimes putting their lives at risk. Zahedi-Spung decided to move to Colorado, where she feels relieved to be in a state with more lenient abortion laws.

These stories illustrate the difficult choices that doctors are facing in states with strict abortion restrictions. The fear of legal repercussions, combined with the moral and ethical dilemmas, has led many doctors to leave these states in search of more supportive environments where they can provide essential care to their patients without the risk of criminal prosecution.

Frequently asked questions