Anti-Abortion Laws: Harming Women, Peer-Reviewed Evidence

The revocation of the constitutional right to seek safe abortion care has had a disproportionate impact on the reproductive lives of women in America, particularly women of colour. The decision to overturn Roe v. Wade has resulted in a wave of anti-abortion laws being passed across several states, with at least a dozen banning abortion entirely. This has led to restricted access to safe and legal abortions, forcing women to resort to unsafe alternatives. The criminalisation of abortion not only violates the right to bodily autonomy but also reinforces existing inequalities, with Black, Indigenous, and women of colour bearing the brunt of these restrictive laws.

Women's lack of awareness and knowledge about the legal status of abortion further exacerbates the problem. Studies have shown that correct general awareness and knowledge of abortion laws are limited, even in countries with liberal legislation. This lack of understanding influences women's care-seeking behaviour and their ability to access safe and legal abortion services.

The impact of anti-abortion laws extends beyond the United States, with global implications for reproductive rights and access to safe abortions. The entrenchment of the anti-choice standpoint has far-reaching consequences, influencing foreign policy and impacting access to family planning and reproductive health services worldwide.

The road to law reform is long and challenging, requiring a critical mass of support from various allies, including parliamentarians, health professionals, legal experts, women's groups, and the women themselves. Ultimately, the aim is to achieve reproductive justice, where abortion is recognised as a fundamental human right, ensuring that everyone with an unwanted pregnancy who seeks an abortion can access it safely and legally.

The impact of anti-abortion laws on women's health

Anti-abortion laws have a detrimental impact on women's health, particularly affecting minority women and those from low-income backgrounds. The criminalisation of abortion and the resulting lack of access to safe procedures can lead to serious health complications and even death.

Barriers to safe abortion

There are numerous barriers that prevent people from seeking abortions, including criminalisation, social stigma, and intersectional discrimination. Even in countries where abortion is legal, factors like cost, distance to services, and social stigma can make it difficult to access. This is further exacerbated by the criminalisation of abortion in many places, such as the United States, Sierra Leone, Poland, and Morocco, where those who seek or provide abortions can face harsh punishments.

Health risks of unsafe abortions

Unsafe abortions are the third leading cause of preventable maternal deaths worldwide and result in approximately five million preventable disabilities, according to the World Health Organization. The risk of maternal death is 15 times higher for carrying a pregnancy to term than it is for abortion, and pregnancy-related complications are significantly higher for pregnancies that end in birth compared to abortion.

Impact on minority and low-income women

Black, Indigenous, and racialised women are disproportionately impacted by anti-abortion laws, as they often face additional barriers to accessing healthcare due to systemic racism. Additionally, half of all women who get abortions live below the poverty line, and in states with abortion restrictions, they may not be able to afford to travel to another state to receive care.

Global impact

The impact of anti-abortion laws extends beyond individual countries, as seen with the United States' "global gag rule," which prevents foreign non-governmental organisations from using their own funds to provide abortion services, even if it is legal in their country. This has had detrimental effects on access to healthcare and family planning services globally.

The need for law reform

Advocates for reproductive rights stress the importance of law reform to protect women's health and ensure access to safe and legal abortions. This includes decriminalising abortion, providing accurate information, and addressing social, cultural, and economic barriers that hinder women's ability to exercise their reproductive rights.

The effect of anti-abortion laws on women's education, employment and housing

The US Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade has had a profound impact on women's reproductive rights, with far-reaching consequences for their education, employment and housing. The loss of constitutional protection for abortion has resulted in a patchwork of state laws, with some states banning abortion entirely while others have sought to protect access. This has created a stark divide between abortion-restricted and abortion-protected states, with significant implications for women's lives.

Education

Women, particularly those from marginalised communities, may find their educational goals disrupted by an unwanted pregnancy. The ability to terminate a pregnancy can enable women to stay in education and avoid the financial and social challenges of early motherhood. Restricted access to abortion may force some women to put their educational goals on hold or abandon them altogether. This can have long-term impacts on their employment prospects and economic mobility.

Employment

The connection between abortion access and economic outcomes is well-established. Abortion restrictions can impose significant economic burdens on women, especially those from low-income backgrounds. Denial of abortion services can lead to financial distress, trapping women in lower-paying occupations and exacerbating existing inequalities. Restricted access to abortion is particularly detrimental to Black and Hispanic women, who already face steep economic disadvantages and discrimination in the labour market.

Housing

Restricted access to abortion can also impact women's housing situations. Unwanted pregnancies can create financial strain and housing instability, particularly for women living below the poverty line. The inability to terminate a pregnancy can lead to challenges in securing stable housing and maintaining economic security. This is especially true for women who are already facing housing precarity.

The effects of anti-abortion laws are felt most acutely by marginalised communities, including Black, Indigenous, and racialised women. These communities are more likely to seek abortions and often have worse maternity and neonatal health outcomes. Restricted access to abortion can exacerbate existing disparities in access to quality reproductive healthcare and worsen health outcomes for these communities.

The loss of abortion rights has far-reaching consequences for women's lives, affecting their educational opportunities, employment prospects, and housing stability. The impact is most severe for those who are already marginalised and facing systemic racism, colonialism, and white supremacy. The interplay between abortion restrictions and economic policy creates a cycle of disempowerment and control, undermining women's autonomy and livelihoods.

The influence of anti-abortion laws on women's mental health

Anti-abortion laws have a detrimental impact on women's mental health, as they restrict access to safe and legal abortions, leading to increased stress, anxiety, and psychological distress. The criminalization of abortion and the associated stigma create a hostile environment for women, affecting their mental well-being.

The Impact of Stigma and Criminalization

Abortion stigma and criminalization are interconnected, with laws that prohibit or restrict abortion contributing to negative perceptions and judgments toward those seeking or providing abortions. This stigma can lead to feelings of shame, guilt, and isolation, negatively impacting mental health. The fear of prosecution or punishment further deters women from seeking safe abortion services, exacerbating stress and anxiety.

Barriers to Access

Anti-abortion laws create barriers to accessing safe and legal abortions. These laws often result in a reduction in the number of abortion providers, as healthcare professionals may be hesitant to offer abortion services due to legal risks and personal beliefs. This leads to longer waiting times, increased travel distances, and financial burdens for women seeking abortions, all of which contribute to mental health strain.

Lack of Information and Education

In many places with restrictive abortion laws, women often lack accurate information about the legal status of abortion and the specific conditions under which it is permitted. This lack of knowledge can lead to confusion, anxiety, and delays in seeking care. Additionally, socio-economic factors, such as poverty and limited access to education, further hinder women's ability to make informed decisions about their reproductive health, affecting their mental well-being.

Disproportionate Impact on Marginalized Communities

The impact of anti-abortion laws on mental health is not evenly distributed. Black, Indigenous, Women of Color, and individuals from marginalized communities disproportionately bear the brunt of these restrictive laws. Systemic racism, neoliberalism, and white supremacy intersect with anti-abortion laws to create additional barriers and worsen reproductive health outcomes for these communities.

Global Perspectives

The consequences of anti-abortion laws on women's access to safe and legal abortion services

Anti-abortion laws have far-reaching consequences for women's access to safe and legal abortion services. These laws often result in a reduction in the number of available abortion services and an increase in the financial, social, and health barriers that women must navigate to obtain an abortion. The impact of these laws is felt disproportionately by marginalized communities, including people of colour, undocumented immigrants, refugees, and asylum seekers, and people from low-income backgrounds.

The impact of anti-abortion laws on service availability

The criminalization of abortion and the enactment of restrictive laws directly contribute to the unavailability of safe and legal abortion services. In countries where abortion is criminalized or heavily restricted, women are often forced to resort to unsafe abortion methods, which can lead to fatal consequences such as maternal deaths and disabilities. The unavailability of safe and legal abortion services also results in an increased demand for post-abortion care to treat the complications arising from unsafe abortions.

Financial, social, and health barriers to accessing abortion services

Anti-abortion laws create and exacerbate financial, social, and health barriers that hinder women's access to abortion services. These barriers include the cost of travelling to another state or country to access care, the social stigma associated with abortion, and the lack of accurate information about abortion services and their legal status. Additionally, the criminalization of abortion creates a "chilling effect," deterring women from seeking post-abortion care for complications arising from unsafe abortions or other pregnancy-related issues.

Disproportionate impact on marginalized communities

The impact of anti-abortion laws is felt most acutely by marginalized communities, who already face barriers to accessing health services. People of colour, undocumented immigrants, refugees, and asylum seekers, and people from low-income backgrounds are disproportionately affected by these laws, as they often have limited financial resources and face additional challenges in navigating the healthcare system. The intersection of systemic racism and moral conservatism further compounds the difficulties faced by these communities in accessing safe and legal abortion services.

Anti-abortion laws have significant consequences for women's access to safe and legal abortion services. These laws reduce the availability of abortion services and create financial, social, and health barriers that women must navigate to obtain an abortion. The impact of these laws is felt most keenly by marginalized communities, who are already facing multiple forms of oppression and discrimination. It is crucial to address these laws and the underlying systemic issues to ensure that all women have equitable access to safe and legal abortion services.

The role of anti-abortion laws in perpetuating systemic racism and social inequalities

Anti-abortion laws have a long history rooted in white supremacy and the exploitation of Black women. They perpetuate systemic racism and social inequalities by restricting access to reproductive healthcare, particularly for minority women.

In the United States, the criminalisation of abortion disproportionately impacts marginalised communities, including people of colour, refugees, migrants, LGBTIQA+ individuals, and racialised and Indigenous people. This is due to the intersectional discrimination and marginalisation that these communities already face, which creates barriers to accessing healthcare services. For example, Black women are three times more likely, and Hispanic women twice as likely, to seek abortions than white women. Additionally, half of all women who get abortions live below the poverty line, and restrictive abortion laws make it more difficult for them to access safe and legal abortions.

The criminalisation of abortion also has a compounding impact on marginalised individuals, as health services are generally less accessible to them. This means that they may have to resort to unsafe and clandestine abortions, which can lead to fatal consequences such as maternal deaths and disabilities. The stigmatisation and criminalisation of abortion further deter women from seeking post-abortion care, as they fear judgment, gossip, and discrimination.

Furthermore, anti-abortion laws contribute to gender inequality by denying women bodily autonomy and reproductive justice. Reproductive justice recognises that gender equality, sexual and reproductive rights, and social justice are strongly interconnected. By restricting access to abortion, anti-abortion laws infringe upon women's right to control their fertility and make decisions about their future. This is particularly harmful to women from marginalised communities, who already face social, economic, and political conditions that hinder their ability to exercise reproductive autonomy.

The enforcement of anti-abortion laws also reinforces gender stereotypes and the idea that a woman's primary role is reproductive and maternal. This further entrenches gender inequality and limits women's opportunities to pursue education, careers, and other life choices.

To address these issues, it is important to not only decriminalise abortion but also to tackle the deeply rooted social, cultural, and economic barriers that make it difficult for people, especially those from marginalised communities, to exercise their reproductive rights. This includes addressing issues such as access to healthcare, transportation, and affordable housing, which can impact a person's ability to seek an abortion.

Frequently asked questions