What Defines Health In New York's Abortion Law?

New York's Reproductive Health Act (RHA) permits abortions after 24 weeks if a health care professional determines that the health or life of the mother is at risk, or the fetus is not viable. The RHA does not explicitly define health, leaving it to the discretion of the woman's medical provider to determine if her health is at risk. This is in line with the precedent set by Doe v. Bolton, where the U.S. Supreme Court held that medical judgment may be exercised in light of all factors—physical, emotional, psychological, familial, and the woman's age—relevant to the well-being of the patient.

The term health is not defined in the RHA

The term "health" is not defined in the RHA, which is in line with the norm of not defining medical terms in the law. This leaves the interpretation of "health" up to the discretion of medical providers when determining if a woman's health is at risk to warrant an abortion after 24 weeks of gestation.

The lack of a definition for "health" in the RHA has been a point of contention, with critics arguing that it creates ambiguity and potential loopholes in the law. However, supporters of the RHA maintain that the term "health" should be interpreted broadly and be left to the judgement of medical professionals.

While the RHA does not provide a definition, the World Health Organization (WHO) defines health as "a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity." This definition highlights that health encompasses not just the physical but also the mental and social aspects of an individual's well-being.

In the context of abortion laws, the term "health" is crucial as it serves as a criterion for determining whether an abortion can be legally performed, particularly in cases of late-term abortions. By leaving the term undefined, the RHA provides flexibility for medical professionals to make decisions based on their expertise and the specific circumstances of each case.

It's important to note that the interpretation of "health" in the context of abortion laws has been addressed by the U.S. Supreme Court in the companion case of Doe v. Bolton. The Court held that medical judgment should consider all factors relevant to the well-being of the patient, including physical, emotional, psychological, and familial factors, giving doctors the room to make their best medical judgment.

Abortion rights are protected in New York State

The RHA ensures that qualified, licensed health care providers can provide early and safe abortion services within their expertise and training. It protects these health care professionals who provide vital care. By ensuring that patients can seek care from advanced practice clinicians, the RHA improves access to safe and affordable care, particularly for low-income and rural communities.

The RHA also holds New York to the standard of Roe v. Wade, the landmark Supreme Court decision that guaranteed a woman's right to abortion. New Yorkers should be able to get the care they need throughout pregnancy, and the RHA ensures that a patient's individual needs and circumstances are what drives decision-making, not interference from politicians. The RHA allows health care providers to treat patients based on established medical standards and an individual patient's health, not an outdated state criminal code.

The RHA also repealed a section of the public health law that required abortions after 12 weeks to be performed in a hospital, and that an additional physician be present for abortions after 20 weeks. This change reflects modern standards of medical care. New York's RHA also removes abortion from the state's penal code, and supporters of the bill argued that abortion should be treated as a health care matter, not a criminal one.

In addition to the RHA, New York State has also passed a series of bills strengthening abortion access by protecting abortion providers from lawsuits by other states where abortions are illegal. The state has set aside $35 million for those from restrictive states seeking abortions in New York, with $25 million going towards expanding infrastructure and capacity, and $10 million towards boosting security for facilities providing care.

Abortion is permitted after 24 weeks if a health care professional determines the health or life of the mother is at risk

Abortion in New York is legal and protected. The Reproductive Health Act (RHA), enacted on January 22, 2019, protects abortion rights, decriminalises the procedure, and eliminates restrictions on voluntary abortions. The RHA permits abortions after 24 weeks if a health care professional determines that the health or life of the mother is at risk, or the fetus is not viable.

The RHA does not define "health", "at risk", or "viable", leaving these determinations to the discretion of medical providers. This is in line with the norm of not defining medical terms in law. The RHA also allows advanced practice clinicians (APCs), including physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and licensed midwives, to provide abortion services if they are qualified and if it falls within their scope of practice.

Prior to the RHA, New York law only allowed abortions after 24 weeks if the mother's life was at risk. The RHA brings the law into alignment with Roe v. Wade, the landmark Supreme Court decision that guaranteed a woman's right to abortion. The RHA also removes abortion from the state's penal code, addressing concerns that abortion should be treated as a healthcare matter rather than a criminal one.

The RHA has been subject to criticism, with some arguing that removing abortion from the criminal code could impact the prosecution of crimes against pregnant women. However, supporters of the bill counter that violence resulting in the loss of pregnancy can still be prosecuted as assault.

In summary, the RHA in New York permits abortions after 24 weeks if a healthcare professional determines that the health or life of the mother is at risk, or the fetus is not viable. This determination is left to the discretion of medical providers, and the RHA also expands the range of qualified providers who can perform abortions. The RHA protects abortion rights and brings New York law into alignment with Roe v. Wade, addressing concerns about the treatment of abortion as a criminal matter.

People of all ages have the right to an abortion through the 24th week of pregnancy

People of all ages in New York have the right to an abortion through the 24th week of pregnancy. This right was established in 2019 with the passing of the Reproductive Health Act (RHA), which allows abortions on demand up to 24 weeks of gestation. The RHA also permits abortions after 24 weeks if a health care professional determines that the health or life of the pregnant person is at risk, or the fetus is not viable. This legislation ensures that abortion remains safe, legal, and accessible for all who need it in New York State.

Prior to the passage of the RHA, New York law banned abortions after 24 weeks of pregnancy, except when necessary to save the life of the pregnant woman. The RHA repealed this restriction and removed abortion from the state's criminal code, instead placing it under public health law. This change aligns with the argument that abortion should be treated as a healthcare matter rather than a criminal one.

The RHA also expanded the range of qualified medical providers who can perform abortions. Previously, only licensed physicians were recognized as able to perform abortions. Now, advanced practice clinicians (APCs), including physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and licensed midwives, are also permitted to provide abortion services if they have the appropriate qualifications and if it falls within their scope of practice. This change has increased the number of medical practitioners who can provide safe abortions, making abortion more accessible to those who need it.

The RHA is significant because it codifies abortion rights into state law, protecting access to reproductive rights for all people in New York. This is especially important given the recent overturning of Roe v. Wade in 2022, which removed the federal guarantee of abortion rights. With the RHA, New York ensures that people of all ages have the right to an abortion through the 24th week of pregnancy and beyond if their health or life is at risk, or the fetus is not viable.

Abortion is legal and protected in the state of New York

The RHA was passed by the New York State Senate by a vote of 38-24 and by the state Assembly 92-47 on the same day. It was signed into law by Governor Andrew Cuomo, who celebrated by lighting One World Trade Center in pink. The RHA allows abortions on demand up to 24 weeks of gestation and beyond 24 weeks if the woman's life or health is at risk, or the fetus is not viable.

The RHA also permits advanced practice clinicians (APCs), including physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and licensed midwives, to provide abortion services if they are qualified and if it falls within their scope of practice. This has increased the number of practitioners who can provide safe abortions, making the procedure more accessible.

The RHA protects the health and rights of New Yorkers, ensuring abortion law and politicians do not interfere with decisions best left to patients and their healthcare providers. It also protects healthcare professionals who provide these vital services.

Frequently asked questions