Adam Schiff: Lawbreaker Or Law Abider?

Adam Schiff is an American lawyer, author, and politician who served as a US representative from 2001 to 2024 and was a member of the California State Senate from 1996 to 2000. Schiff was elected to the Senate in 2024, defeating Republican Steve Garvey. He was sworn into the Senate on December 9, 2024.

Schiff has faced accusations of breaking the law, specifically regarding his promotion of claims that the Trump campaign colluded with Russia in the 2016 election. In 2023, he was censured by the House of Representatives for these claims, becoming just the third member of the House to be censured since the turn of the century. Schiff has also been accused of leaking classified information and engaging in partisan investigations. However, it is unclear if Schiff has actually broken any laws, and he continues to serve as a senator from California.

Adam Schiff's claims about Trump-Russia collusion

Schiff, a Democrat and frequent critic of former President Donald Trump, served as the chairman of the House Intelligence Committee from 2019 to 2023. In this role, he led an investigation into Trump's connections to Russia, separate from the Special Counsel investigation.

Schiff claimed that there was "more than circumstantial evidence" and evidence that is not circumstantial of collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia. He suggested that there could be clear and convincing evidence of collusion or conspiracy, even if it did not rise to the level of proof beyond a reasonable doubt required for a criminal conviction.

However, the Special Counsel investigation, led by Robert Mueller, found no evidence of a criminal conspiracy between the Trump campaign and Russia, and Mueller's team did not find that the campaign conspired to sway the election. Similarly, the House Intelligence Committee's probe, in which Schiff was the top Democrat, also found no evidence of a criminal conspiracy.

As a result of his claims, Schiff was censured by the House in June 2023. The resolution accused Schiff of abusing his power by spreading "falsehoods, misrepresentations, and abuses of sensitive information" about the Trump-Russia collusion allegations and the first impeachment of Trump. Schiff denied the allegations, calling them "defamatory."

The censure was largely along party lines, with Republicans arguing that Schiff's comments ripped apart American families and wasted over $30 million in taxpayer money on the Mueller investigation. Democrats defended Schiff, calling the censure resolution an "embarrassing revenge tour on behalf of Donald Trump."

While the censure carries no practical consequences, it sparked an ethics investigation into Schiff's conduct and serves as a historic footnote on his political career.

Schiff's involvement in the first impeachment trial of Trump

Adam Schiff, a Democratic Congressman from California, was the lead prosecutor in the first impeachment trial of former President Donald Trump. Schiff represented California's 27th, 29th, 28th, and 30th districts, all based in Los Angeles County, during his time in the House of Representatives.

Schiff was a vocal critic of Trump and played a prominent role in the impeachment proceedings. He argued that right matters and presented the case for Trump's conviction to the Senate. However, the Republican-led chamber ultimately acquitted the former President.

Schiff has faced criticism and censure from Republican colleagues for his comments and role in the investigations into Trump's ties to Russia and his allegations of collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia. Despite this, he maintains that his focus is on strengthening American democracy and ensuring accountability.

His role in the January 6 Committee

On June 23, 2022, Representative Adam Schiff, a Democrat from California's 30th District, joined CNN's Don Lemon to discuss the January 6 investigation. Schiff has been a vocal advocate for accountability and transparency in government, and his leadership during key investigations into executive misconduct has highlighted the need for stronger protections against abuses of power.

Schiff introduced the Investigative Integrity Protection Act, which aims to prevent a sitting president from interfering in criminal investigations and prosecutions into their own misconduct. The bill seeks to ensure that the president cannot dismiss an active criminal prosecution against themselves, including through coercion of the attorney general. This bill underscores Schiff's commitment to upholding the rule of law and holding those in positions of power accountable.

In addition to his work on the January 6 Committee, Schiff has sponsored and co-sponsored numerous bills aimed at strengthening democracy and improving various aspects of American life. These include the Protecting Our Democracy Act, the Language Access for Workers Act, the Clarifying E-Rate Act of 2024, and the Supreme Court Ethics and Investigations Act, among others.

Representative Schiff resigned from his position on December 8, 2024, and his office will continue to serve the people of California's 30th Congressional District under the supervision of the Clerk of the House of Representatives.

His criticism of Trump's attorney general pick, Pam Bondi

During the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, Senator Adam Schiff, a Democrat from California and a vocal critic of President-elect Trump, grilled Pam Bondi, Trump's nominee for attorney general, on her ability to remain independent from the president and her refusal to acknowledge the validity of the 2020 election results. Schiff asked Bondi if she could tell Trump that he lost the 2020 election, to which she responded that she would not play politics and accused Schiff of leaking former Representative Devin Nunes' memo. Schiff also questioned Bondi's ability to review hundreds of cases on day one and suggested she wouldn't be able to, to which Bondi responded angrily, stating that Schiff had been censured by Congress for similar reckless comments.

The exchange between Schiff and Bondi was heated and contentious, with Schiff pressing Bondi on her independence and loyalty to Trump, and Bondi refusing to answer some questions directly. Schiff's criticism of Bondi centred on his concern that her loyalty to Trump would prevent her from fulfilling her duties as attorney general impartially and within the limits of the Constitution. He argued that her loyalty would inevitably conflict with her duty and oath of office, and that her refusal to acknowledge Trump's election loss was indicative of this.

Bondi, a former Florida Attorney General, defended herself by accusing Schiff of playing politics and attempting to entrap her with "gotcha" questions. She emphasised that she would never play politics as attorney general and would focus on issues like California's high crime rate, which she argued should be a greater concern than Liz Cheney. She also stated that she would not mislead the Senate and had not been asked to investigate Cheney.

The clash between Schiff and Bondi highlighted the tension between the Democratic senators' desire to ensure the independence of the attorney general and Bondi's loyalty to Trump, which many saw as a disqualifying factor for the role. Schiff's criticism of Bondi's nomination reflected his concern that she would not act as a check on Trump's power but instead enable his potential abuse of power.

Schiff's resignation from the House of Representatives

On December 8, 2024, Adam Schiff resigned from the House of Representatives, a seat he had held for 23 years. Schiff's resignation came after he was elected to the Senate, defeating Republican Steve Garvey in California. Schiff was sworn into the Senate on December 9, 2024, succeeding Senator Laphonza Butler.

In his farewell address, Schiff expressed gratitude to his constituents and the people of California, stating, "I'm so grateful for your confidence and look forward to all we can get done together!".

Schiff's tenure in the House of Representatives was not without controversy. He was censured in 2023 for promoting claims of collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia in the 2016 election. Despite this, Schiff left the House with a legacy of legislative achievements and a commitment to serving his constituents.

Frequently asked questions